News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: How do I make the move to consultant? by nlh on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @06:13AM (#21190534)
I have some meta advice, having done a bunch of really fun consulting gigs over the past few years:

* Flexibility is super important to a lot of people. I like to tell clients “one of the best things about hiring a consultant is that you have no long-term obligations to me. You can cancel our contract on a day’s notice if you want, and I won’t be the slightest bit annoyed.” I’ve never had anyone actually do that, but folks always always react positively to that offer and appreciate it.

* Bill by the week, do a one-week minimum, and pair that with the above. You’ll be surprised how often that week turns into six months (or more).

* A lot of full-time folks get very threatened when a consultant arrives on the scene (particularly if you’re a generalist, but even if you’re a specialist). This is just a natural protective instinct. Don’t be put off by this - go out of your way to reassure them you’re there to help, work with them, and help them do their jobs better. The defensiveness will often turn into supportiveness and they can become your biggest champions.

* Think of yourself like a business, not an employee. Make sure you can be independent, go over-and-above on documentation, and communicate like a professional. Don’t get mixed up with company drama or gossip. You’re above the fray (and that’s why you should be paid accordingly.)

Re:Ask HN: How do I make the move to consultant? by notzuck on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @10:28AM (#21192677)
Me and my partner do the same. Billing weekly is what has allowed us to have no contracts in place, worst case scenario we lose 2 weeks pay but that's never happened.

We have no contracts because plenty of people have a budget but most are not allowed to sign on behalf of the company without legal and procurement involvement. We're now doing over 500k / year on this model and we've just hired our first offshore contractor to help us with a new implementation we won last week. The plan is to be at 1 million in revenue (with tiny overheads) within the next 18 months.

Re:Ask HN: How do I make the move to consultant? by snowwrestler on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @11:43AM (#21193489)
I'm amazed that companies with required legal and procurement processes will just pay an invoice without a contract. My employer's finance team absolutely will not write a check unless they can tie the invoice to an approved contract.
Re:Ask HN: How do I make the move to consultant? by jklein11 on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @01:58PM (#21195060)
You might want to talk to a lawyer about how not having an agreement exposes you to risk. This smells like the kind of thing that works out just fine for years until something hits the fan and it explodes in your face.

I’d love to learn more about how you got to 500k in revenue. Any chance you have some time to chat?

Re:Ask HN: How do I make the move to consultant? by AdamGibbins on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @11:50AM (#21193584)
How do you get gigs without a contract? That no doubt violates all sort of insurance, security and finance rules for most companies.
Re:Ask HN: How do I make the move to consultant? by sturza on Saturday October 12, 2019 @01:39PM (#21234811)
This sounds amazing for me. I'd like to invite you to an email conversation about your learnings with this experience. I have my email in my bio.
Re:Ask HN: How do I make the move to consultant? by TooCleverByHalf on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @11:19AM (#21193223)
If you wouldn't mind sharing, I'd be interested in hearing what kind of work you provide to clients when hired to consult.
Re:Ask HN: How do I make the move to consultant? by hazelnut on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @11:26AM (#21193310)
Do you have multiple clients at the same time?

How many weeks do you have no client work? I guess you use it for networking/marketing, right?

Re:Ask HN: How do I make the move to consultant? by jitendrac on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @12:56AM (#21200162)
Can you provide the details of your consultationcy? Like - Do you code/develope a project!?
Re:Ask HN: How do I make the move to consultant? by notzuck on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @01:53AM (#21200436)
Implement, support and customise a solution owned by one of the large software vendors. We also do strategic consulting around what products to use, what to integrate, vendor negotiation etc.

We are consultants in software dev, business processes automation,finance, supply chain etc.

Re:Ask HN: How do I make the move to consultant? by jitendrac on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @05:00AM (#21201357)
That is great, wish you a luck for your 1M target.
Re:Ask HN: How do I make the move to consultant? by notzuck on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @10:04PM (#21199294)
Sorry about the formatting. I don't know how to get HN to format things better.

Lots of questions attached to my comment. I'll do my best to answer some here.

Question: snowwrestler 9 hours ago [-]

I'm amazed that companies with required legal and procurement processes will just pay an invoice without a contract. My employer's finance team absolutely will not write a check unless they can tie the invoice to an approved contract."

Answer: This is common. The smaller clients that we work with don't have strong controls in this area. Some of mid-size and larger clients don't either. If the client is larger than 'owner operated' we work directly with C-level or less as long as they are the buyer. One of our clients is a large cosmetics company, the CEO directed accounts payable to make payment for all of our invoices without scrutiny. This is common to all our clients, you have to make sure you build strong relationships with the buyer / c-level as you want to act as that person peer and NOT the peer of his / her employees. When you talk to an employee you want them to see you as an extension to the CEO. For plenty of large enterprise businesses, they may force a contract but you'd be surprised at the lack of controls or care in a lot of organisations.

"Question: jklein11 7 hours ago [-]

You might want to talk to a lawyer about how not having an agreement exposes you to risk. This smells like the kind of thing that works out just fine for years until something hits the fan and it explodes in your face. I’d love to learn more about how you got to 500k in revenue. Any chance you have some time to chat?"

Answer: You don't need a contract as long as you can show that you have entered into an agreement. I usually send an SOW and get an email confirmation that's fine. Sometimes I just get them to sign off on a business requirements document instead. I also write that 'payment us accepted and deemed as agreement". This is perfectly legal in my legal jurisdiction. Oral agreements are also "just as valid as a written contract" but it's harder to prove. Our revenue is more than 500k, 500k is the retainer revenue, the rest is made up of one off implementation work. We used to for a very large software vendor several years ago. When we went independent we contract all of our old client base and won two small contracts then we got referrals (business owners know other business owners). We also run several marketing websites and I personally cold call target clients, put ads in trade publications etc.

"Question: AdamGibbins 9 hours ago [-]

How do you get gigs without a contract? That no doubt violates all sort of insurance, security and finance rules for most companies."

Answer: I don't understand the first part of your question. No we are not violating any rules.

"Question: TooCleverByHalf 10 hours ago [-]

If you wouldn't mind sharing, I'd be interested in hearing what kind of work you provide to clients when hired to consult"

I don't want to dox myself so I'll be a little vague. We used to work at a large software vendor implementing and customising a commonly used back-office system. We now offer the service independently. We also provide long term support and advisory around technology strategy, vendor negotiations etc.

"queston: hazelnut 10 hours ago [-]

Do you have multiple clients at the same time? How many weeks do you have no client work? I guess you use it for networking/marketing, right?"

Answer: Yes, we have multiple clients at the same time. Some are retainer clients and some are in discovery or implementation stage. We have never had a period of no work, we have the opposite problem of too much work which saw us working from 6am - 2am everyday for several months. We have now raised our rates to a place where we can hire contractors to help us.

Required reading. Anything by Seth Godin for marketing. Everything by Alan Weiss, the god of independent consulting and "the personal MBA" which delivers many small pieces that allow you think clearly about various aspects of business.

Re:Ask HN: How do I make the move to consultant? by jklein11 on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @10:40PM (#21199474)
Thanks for the reply! I think your answer has me a little bit more confused. You mention that you get the hiring manager to sign off on the SOW or BRD. I am suprised they would have the authority to do this but not sign a contract. I wouldn’t Think a contract would help you get paid for invoices necessarily. At the end of the day the invoice is probably less than the cost of enforcing the contract. I would be concerned about my liability if I was acting without a contract. For example, let’s say I get sick and miss a milestone. This missed milestone costs the company $X in revenue. A good contract would have language that protects me from this. Without a contract you might be left on the hook( or paying a lawyer handsomely)
Re:Ask HN: How do I make the move to consultant? by notzuck on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @11:40PM (#21199790)
They don't actually sign anything. They just need to have any positive response via email followed by a paid invoice, that's enough for the client to be in contract with me should we ever end up in court. Given that I invoice on a weekly basis, there's not much risk on my side. The only risk is that I ruin their business by badly implementing their supply chain or similar but I have liability insurance to cover this.

Everything I do is on a time and materials basis and the client get an invoice every week so there's no real way for them to claim I haven't delivered scope etc. I also make the client test everything that I deliver and tell me, via email, that they have accepted it.

I do understand the usefulness of a contract but my many years at Accenture showed me that contracts don't stop you from having to go to court and spend a lot to defend yourself. I am not against signing a contract with a client, it just makes it harder to sell and it locks me into terms and conditions. No contract gives everyone a lot of flexibility.

Alan Weiss takes the same approach. If I were to enter in to a large piece of fixed scope work with an enterprise client, I would likely get my lawyer to put together a master services agreement though.

Re:Ask HN: How do I make the move to consultant? by comprev on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @06:36AM (#21190697)
We've recently had an ex-consultant join our team as a perm and one of the biggest challenges he's faced is reducing his ego. It's taken several months to adjust his working methods into a "team player" and realise he's not the only smart person it the room.
Re:Ask HN: How do I make the move to consultant? by lowercased on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @09:55AM (#21192322)
from the other side - I've worked for many years as either the only or the primary person responsible for delivering a project. I've spent a few months on a team in a project this year. The one 'adjustment' I had to make was understanding that if something wasn't delivered, it wasn't "my fault" (or wasn't my fault automatically).

I missed a couple of delivery dates - the world didn't end. I pushed out some stuff with errors - other people on the team picked those up and fixed them. I did the same for others when I could.

The mindset wasn't so much "I'm the only smart person in the room" as "I've spent 10 years being personally responsible for nearly every aspect of every system - and done that reasonably well - and now there's other people in the process". There's some adjustments to make, and sometimes you don't always know the best way to make those adjustments.

Now, some (most?) of the people on that team had < 5 years of professional experience. A couple had ~10-12. I have 25 years. There were times when I tried to offer up my perspective/experience - not because I'm necessarily "smarter" but... if I've seen problems and know how to avoid them... shouldn't we try to avoid them, and help the business avoid those problems?

Now, I have been on teams where I am the smartest person in the room (or... the most productive, or the most accomplished, or whatever). It's not like that all the time, but it does happen sometimes, and it can be awkward. Pretending that everyone has equal skill and experience and that all inputs are valid doesn't benefit the project or business, although it might, in the short term, help team morale by not hurting feelings of some people. Some of those same people might end up leaving at a moment's notice anyway (which I've seen happen - don't upset person A - they're valuable(!) - then person A leaves with 1 hour notice).

Re:Ask HN: How do I make the move to consultant? by robinduckett on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @07:04AM (#21190896)
Personally, I thrive when being a facilitator, and I love being the dumbest guy in the room as I get to learn a bunch from interesting people. Keeping egos out of the room is important.
Re:Ask HN: How do I make the move to consultant? by mosselman on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @07:02AM (#21190882)
We also had an ex consultant join recently and that wasn’t at all like you describe for us.
Re:Ask HN: How do I make the move to consultant? by spurdoman77 on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @07:51AM (#21191180)
Surprise that consultants can be as different as normal people. Fundamentally I dont think there is a big difference, they just prefer different kind of work.

Personally as an employer I really enjoy consultants, because I habe freedom not to order their services when I dont need them anymore. With employees I am kind of obliged to keep them hired until they want to leave.

Re:Ask HN: How do I make the move to consultant? by mosselman on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @02:29PM (#21195428)
> Surprise that consultants can be as different as normal people.

That was my point, yes.

Re:Ask HN: How do I make the move to consultant? by raihansaputra on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @07:41AM (#21191122)
That might really depend on their experience. "Consultant" is a wide term. They can work for the Big 4 companies around people like them, or one-man-army helping small businesses with stubborn clients. What might be successful for them by having to push those clients might not be a best fit for a team. Doesn't mean they won't fit, but both the team and the ex-consultant need to know the context.
Re:Ask HN: How do I make the move to consultant? by Aeolun on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @09:15AM (#21191902)
> This is just a natural protective instinct.

It is also because incoming consultants, or visiting people from overseas, often suggest seemingly practical, but actually pie in the sky solutions, that sends us off on yet another hare brained revision of the system.

By the time it turns out the solution wasn’t so practical after all, they’re long gone.

It’s very nice when you can steer them to suggest the correct things though, and management is suddenly willing to listen.

Re:Ask HN: How do I make the move to consultant? by ramblerman on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @07:36AM (#21191093)
Nice summary, this is great advice.

Out of curiosity what size businesses do you target?

Re:Ask HN: How do I make the move to consultant? by nlh on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @07:44AM (#21191142)
I wish I could say I “targeted” folks but that would give me too much credit and attribute too much intention :) The gigs I’ve gotten have been referrals / connections through friends. Sweet spot for me is post-funding startup (just beyond scrappy - eg can afford me). But I’ve also done at least one gig for a large multinational. That was the exception, though.
Re:Ask HN: How do I make the move to consultant? by ajcodez on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @08:44AM (#21191604)
In my experience consulting opportunities come through personal connections and often to work with early stage clients that are not very technical. What you bring is experience they can trust because you were referred by someone they know. Clients often don’t have the ability to get the project started or hire the right people so often consultants start as the interim lead developer and then migrate to the interim hiring manager and then pass the baton. I recommend asking for equity if you’re launching early stage companies for clients.
Re:Ask HN: How do I make the move to consultant? by domlebo70 on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @10:54AM (#21192954)
This is great advice. Thanks