- They are NOT speaking of the 0.1 %.
- They are speaking of the 0.01%. One person out of 10000. Not multimillionaires. 100 millionaires and billionaires.
There is a very good reason why the tax foundating speaks of the 1% and not of the 0.1% or 0.01% : it is usefull to protect billionaires.
They always say hand wavy stuff about billionaires whenever they get asked about paying for grand projects. But we’ve all seen how that works out in real life every time. I highly doubt that sort of categorization will ever carry over when it matters.
Uh, they don't all do that, so there can't be a reason that they all do. Some of them do, some of them fund tax protest groups that work to shift he tax burden further from the rich to the working class.
So what’s the point? Even confiscatory 100% taxes on billionaires wouldn’t raise much money (about $127 billion per year, compared to the multi-trillion cost of social programs on the table). And getting rid of preferential treatment of capital gains would risk departing from what’s become an international consensus.
I think we need a better reason than "because everyone is doing it" here.
2. 0.01% is 32,966 people, not 100
3. There are 585 billionaires in the US [0]
4. Billionaires make up 0.00017% of the population
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_the_numbe...
B) The 0.01% is not all billionaires, but they are all extremely high-net-worth individuals. These are people that are not only set for life, but with proper money management and tax planning, could carry on for generations without having to do a lick of work.
There are over 500 billionaires. My point being that OP's point comes off as an emotional argument as opposed to a data-based one.
Edit: I now understand the OP meant "100-millionairs". Even so, the math is still off. As of 2015 there were ~5000 100-millionaires and billionaires in the US[1]. That's 0.0015% of the population.
[1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/chloesorvino/2015/06/15/5000-u-...
By "100 millionaires" he means hundred-millionaires, that is, people who have one hundred million dollars or more. By "100 millionaires and billionaires", "hundred-millionaires as well as billionaires".
Income taxes aren't on wealth; they're on income.
Billionaires usually own most value in stock (and usually in a company they own or founded). The majority of the Forbes 400 are there due to founding a company that was found so useful to others, that the owner is worth billions.
When they sell ownership they get taxed at very high rates, and this is after their company being taxed (which is simply an income tax on owners, but called corporate tax). If they give the ownership to others (like children), they get taxed.
What about estate taxes?
Say a billionaire is holding 3,412,037 shares of SPY. 0 transactions buying or selling for the full fiscal year. Just dividends being paid out reinvesting. What taxes would this person pay?
If you own an asset that is constantly paying taxes, you have lost that value to taxation. A stock shareholder owns a portion of the company. A stockholder loses value exactly equal to the amount of taxes the corporation paid.
This is why economists have the maxim: "companies don't pay taxes; people pay taxes." This doesn't mean companies don't pay tax; it means every dollar a company pays in tax is a dollar taken from some set of people.
Without corporate taxation, the shareholders would own a company which owns more cash. Academic literature has shown a dollar in cash at a company is worth a dollar in market cap, which is priced into stock values.
Now, depending on how dividends work, the billionaire likely also paid taxes on those, either at cap gains rates (remember, that income was also already taxed at the corporate level) or at personal income levels, depending on whether the dividends are classified as qualified dividends or non-qualified dividends.
Then, when the billionaire dies, the rest gets taxed if he/she passes it own. This rate for a billionaire is currently around 40%, and many states have an inheritance tax on top of that.
So the billionaire does and will pay significant amount of taxes over their lifetime.
And yet, they would have paid a pittance compared to their income (not to mention wealth), and it would absolutely no impact on their purchasing power or lifestyle (where the 10K of the 50K could make the difference between having savings, or having a health operation, or sending the kids to college, and many other important things).
That's how irrelevant and unilluminating is this kind of metric...
I don’t see how that’s relevant when the OP already used relative terms.
I can't make the slider go up to 1B in income here (https://smartasset.com/taxes/income-taxes#tvFxGKBdZE), but according to that if you make 10,000,000 in SF, you'll pay $5,207,046 in taxes, so over half. Whereas, matching your statement, you'll pay 10K on 50K, so 1/5. From an income tax perspective, >50% certainly seems significantly larger than 20%.
Of course, this is pure income, so its as if we're talking about an athlete, and things of course change if the capital is not income. Similarly, none of this takes into account sales tax, etc. etc.
Of course, the other key question is what the taxes are for. If the purpose of the tax is to "impact their purchasing power or lifestyle", then I guess until you tax them to the point where they make 40K it will never match the 50K person? If the purpose of the tax on the other hand is to raise revenue for programs then it seems to be quite effective.
In the US, billionaires make just 1.3% of all income. 80% of income is earned by the bottom 99%. Confiscatory taxes would definitely achieve the second purpose, punishing the rich, but would have little effect on how much taxes ordinary people would have to pay to fund government.
Yes.
Though "punish" is an unnecessarily emotional word to use to describe a secondary function of taxation, which is to influence the structure of the economy writ large. It's been mentioned before that high marginal tax rates on top earners were almost never triggered, which is true. Instead of becoming personal income that could be used to wield undue influence on personal whims, wealth created by large enterprises (virtually the only way to accrue billions and billions of dollars of net worth) stayed within those organizations, where it could justifiably be used to raise wages and improve infrastructure, and where whatever use it eventually saw was validated by a support structure of interested parties with real sway.
Obviously it should do both.
Joking aside, if the purpose is to fund the government as good as you can (that is, societies central pool of resource to be able to produce democratically controlled and publicly available "nice stuff") then it makes sense to take as much as you can from the rich (which can afford it) and a normal amount from the average/poor (which can't afford to pay much).
A tax could be:
1) None. Then a country wouldn't be able to maintain e.g. an army or basic infrastructure, and either the country would be at the mercy of other countries that can, or the majority would be at the mercy of moguls that can afford to pay for those things. Some third world places are close to the latter.
2) Flat ($10K for a lawyer making $2M/year, $10K for a single mother of two juggling 2 jobs and making $40K). Most would agree that's bad.
3) Fixed ratio (e.g. 30% of said lawyer's income, 30% of the income of the single mother of two juggling two jobs). The lawyer is then left with $1.4M, more than enough to live in luxury, pander his kids etc, buy 4 new cars per year, etc, whereas the mother can barely survive and do basic spending or cover an emergency with the $28K that remain. Not sure how you find it, not a big fan.
4) Progressive scale. The government gets more from the lawyer (and as people getting richer) and not a fixed ratio. The reach still keep more than enough to do whatever BS they want (e.g. $2M - 60% is still 800K/year). Plus most of their money is not in income but wealth, and the ultra rich have already hid it through 2000 schemes.
>In the US, billionaires make just 1.3% of all income.
Property beyond a certain level should be taxed way worse than income. It's just hogging resources from society and giving to much power to money-based, as opposed to bloodline based, neo-feudal lords. Let's throw that majority of the wealth that they own into collective infrastructure for that "bottom 99%" (which, after all, earns 80% of income and pays more taxes).
This is an argument for taxing consumption, not wealth.
If I have $100M sitting in a bank account it isn't consuming any resources at all.
For the ultra rich they go to so many channels, as to be effectively removed (else, they'd also be taxed as income to begin with). A deposit in Switzerland or Turks and Caicos doesn't do much good (if anything) to your local economy...
And of course, as a rich person you have all kinds of assets like real estate too...
Real estate is a bit tricky since it can be both consumption and investment. While I'd rather see taxes on imputed rent like they have in some countries to cover the consumption part, property taxes do a pretty good job.
Government exists because of and for society, and the purpose of taxes is to create the greatest net benefit to society.
Taxes are not to punish anyone, they are levied to fund services for society. Determining the optimum rate is complex and open to debate. But fairness is entirely irrelevant to the question. Whether the top marginal rate is 10%, or 90%, it should be whatever maximizes the usefulness to society.
We have a capitalist economic system, and it works pretty well for us, but that doesn't mean anyone has an inherent natural right to their capital. When it comes down it, property rights are all fictitious and exist only because society says it does. It's hardly wrong for society to decide to recoup some of what it has created.
Since I've seen Rayiner argue repeatedly on HN that European-style universal health care is a good idea, it stands to reason that what he's saying is that taxes need to increase across the board, not that any one cohort of payers needs to be shielded from increase.
How about increased wealth taxation on the 1% of earners, and the 0.1% of owners?
I fundamentally disagree with that point. Government exists to protect people and their property. People have a natural right to themselves and to an extent their property - rights do not come from society, rights are internal and society functions to abridge them where beneficial.
Well, your property is not others property. So protecting someone having X property, means disallowing others to use that property.
But what gives you or anybody the right to your property anyway? Aside from papers, which don't mean anything in terms of justice, moral, fairness, etc -- only in terms of legality?
We were all caveman, naked and property less to begin with, so where did your rights to your property began?
Even if you think the current market system is fair, the starting point was not equality + market system, but whatever arrangements happened at a time of colonial plundering (off of native Americans), slavery, when even poor whites and women couldn't vote (the most part of US history), plus feudal arrangements (in most other places).
Even if someone got their current property "fair and square" in 2019 selling stuff at the market, said property got its start (and ended to the people that have it) from conditions that were anything but fair and square - and not even very long ago.
Before the abolition of slavery and universal vote, any kind of property arrangement (and any kind of inheritance and all the second and n-th order property arrangements since them), is unjust and moot.
So, as a member of a society, I don't see why someone should be allowed to own huge amounts of real estate or money...
>rights do not come from society, rights are internal and society functions to abridge them where beneficial.
Internal to what?
If someone has the power they can stomp on all your rights, including your "right to life" (as has happened in history time and again), and they and people would just laugh their asses off when they hear your complaint that you have "internal rights".
You only have rights because society collectively secured those rights, and gave them to its members (and it took lots of fighting to secure them in the first place). Heck, if you were a black person, without Rosa Parks, you might still not have the right to many things. And it wasn't much better for the average white throughout history.
And it wasn't even that it was thought of as injustice. To make such things be thought of as injustice (instead of having justice be whatever the king of lords etc say), also took a lot of fighting and ideological work. You could be killed as a slave that tries to escape, and you wouldn't even be considered just, but just a low-life critical, to the good law abiding citizens...
Nothing comes from nature or "internally".
Ok, so everything else is owned by everyone equally. (It's actually important that these things are all owned in commons rather than unowned.) In a state of nature, you walk over, pick up an apple off the ground. By applying your work to pick up the apple, it is now more your apple than it is other people's. That's where property comes from. An application of personal labor. It gets more complicated from there, but that's the start of it.
>You only have rights because society collectively secured those rights, and gave them to its members (and it took lots of fighting to secure them in the first place). Heck, if you were a black person, without Rosa Parks, you might still not have the right to many things. And it wasn't much better for the average white throughout history.
And it wasn't even that it was thought of as injustice.
More accurately, if you don't have the rights and only have those society gives you, it WASN'T an injustice. That's one of the reasons it is important that you have the rights innately. If you only have what society gives you, then it denying you things is totally within its rights and just.
In a practical sense, you only can exercise those rights society protects (if you want to remain a part of society). That doesn't mean you don't have them, which is why it can be unjust to deny you their use.
The conception of internal rights is one of the big reasons we don't have slavery or serfs anymore. You can laugh at it or say it's unrealistic, but it's surprisingly important that rights come innately rather than from external sources.
My point is that the even the more taxes they pay, they're not enough. They should pay way more than the poor, not merely more.
Although I suppose showing that the top 1% has 19% of the income while the bottom 50% has 11% of the income does show the vast income discrepancy.
People don't understand that taxes are the only way to make capitalism work overall by making money trickle down to the poorest and into public infra structures and services. All they see is $$ leaving their account.
The article appears to be discussing the individual tax rates paid by the wealthiest, not the percentage of total tax paid. Those are two different things.
The GP appears to have introduced the latter statistic, as often happens in this debate, to distract from the actual statistic under discussion.
Therefore, the headline of the article “the rich pay less than than you” is pretty clearly false.
But the observations of the article itself check out. The tax system has gotten radically less progressive over the last 50 years. The argument is over whether or not it should be made more or less progressive given current realities.
People can differ in their opinions on that, but the historical trend is clear as day.
I have no idea what it looks like before 1986.
The stat under discussion in the article is not "share of all taxes", it's effective individual income tax rate by income percentile. The latter has definitely become less progressive over time, as the article makes clear with data.
If "share of all taxes" since taxes is a statistic you think is illustrative of something relevant, notice that since 1980, real family income for the top 5% has dramatically outpaced the median real family income, so it only makes sense that their "share of all taxes" would go up:
https://www.cbpp.org/income-gains-widely-shared-in-early-pos...
https://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2017/11/11/the-tax-foundat...
https://economistsview.typepad.com/economistsview/2008/08/th...
https://www.cbpp.org/research/federal-tax/tax-foundation-fig...
The article is not very clear on that, and there is nothing to indicate such on the plot itself (which will be taken out-of-context at some point).
But I agree, it probably will be taken out of context and unfortunately not everyone has even a basic understanding of how taxes work.
The trend is more muted (the poor pay a slightly higher percent of the total), but the rich still pay the majority of taxes and have a much higher effective rate.
Yep, and those "deductions" are now referred to as "tax shelters" (post-1986). Basically, high-earners could invest a relatively small amount of capital into a "business" that was certain to generate large tax losses. These were things like llama farms or avocado farms. The entire purpose was to generate deductions, since the capital invested was smaller than the tax losses generated. The "investor" literally didn't care if he ever got his money back, since the deductions alone were worth the "investment".
Pretty much no one paid the highest rates of the past, because people who have that much money are well-advised, and it was very easy to avoid having that much taxable income.
Can you give an example of how that works? As a non-rich person if I invest $100 it seems like the largest taxes I can pay is $100 (100% tax). How do I generate > $100 tax loss for a $100 investment?
You can depreciate the cost of the alpaca much more quickly than most assets. You can also depreciate related assets - barns, fencing, farm machinery - even if you own these already, as long as you weren't previously using them for business purposes.
You can also deduct your losses against capital gains made elsewhere. And potentially save on property taxes, if your property becomes "agricultural".
Essentially there's a difference between an accounting loss created by depreciation and creative categorisation of spending and/or use of legitimate tax breaks, and a genuine out-of-pocket spending loss created by losing money on an "investment".
Your taxes are calculated on your accounting losses, not on your spending losses. The difference can be written off against taxes due on other income, reducing your final tax bill to zero - without having to spend the full "loss".
This was for the reason that farms sometimes have a large lead time before they're productive and I want to give you the chance of surviving the first few years that weren't productive.
I think this was notorious as a citrus and almond farm thing.
Except for costs that must be capitalized and depreciated/amortized, which includes lots and lots of things (computers, furniture, anything else with a useful life)
The important take away here is that modern legislation dictates much of what our economy looks like. With other tax regulations we would invest completely differently, for better or for worse.
I read the article, in which this expected point is addressed. From TFA:
>They have constructed a historical database that tracks the tax payments of households at different points along the income spectrum going back to 1913, when the federal income tax began.
That is actual payments, not whatever the tax law says should be paid. Did you think academic economists wouldn't address this point?
Read the article again carefully, paying attention to the interactive graph, you will notice that it is discussing the change in total effective tax rate, which is why the total tax rate for the super wealthy in 1950 was 70% when the top marginal rate was 91%. Still massively higher than today's effective individual tax rates on the wealthiest.
> What you should really look at is real effective tax rates by income level.[1] What you'll find is that the top 1% make 19% of all income, but pay 37% of all taxes, with an average tax rate of 27%.
That's not the effective individual tax rate at all. That's burden of tax revenue by population income percentile. You appear to be mixing terms.
NB: I'm not saying automation doesn't matter, or that it won't matter going forward. I'm saying that if no automation had happened at all, we'd almost certainly still be in this situation. The bulk of the distribution changes result from human decisions, not tech.
Sounds like you're doing the "pretend SS and medicare don't exist" fudge, right here.
https://twitter.com/gabriel_zucman/status/118103695973867520...
And I take with a huge block of salt any tax article with phrases like "These charts don’t tell us whether the top 1 percent contains the same people year after year, experiences a complete turnover annually, or something in between." Good heavens, I hadn't realized that a 100% turnover in the top 1% of earners was possible! Those investments must be doing terribly.
Even income taxes aren't as progressive as you would think, because a large fraction of upper-class wealth comes from dividends and capital gains, which are taxed at a rate below the income of a household earning $78,951 year! The biggest tax deductions are for homeowners (including second homes) and retirement savings, which overwhelmingly go to the wealthy. The idea that the wealthy pay a high tax rate is absurd if you look at the whole picture.
It's well known that despite the high marginal tax rates of the past, very few people ever paid those. Deductions abound that have since been eliminated.
What you should really look at is real effective tax rates by income level.[1] What you'll find is that the top 1% make 19% of all income, but pay 37% of all taxes, with an average tax rate of 27%.
The bottom 50% earn 11% of all income, but only pay 3% of all taxes, for an effective rate of 3.73%.
[1]https://taxfoundation.org/top-1-percent-tax-rate/