Re:Echolocation in blind people reveals the brain’s adaptive...
by miki123211 on Sunday October 06, 2019 @11:42AM
(#21172696)
Totally blind person here. I haven't used echolocation much in my life, except for the standard wall/door detection tricks, of course. I've met a very small number of people who do it successfully, though. One guy I know is a near expert. He lost his sight like 4 years ago and he alrady learned it on a pretty advanced level. He taught us to detect things like glasses on a table and tell where they are. The class was only like 3, 4 hours though, so I guess it's just the tip of an iceberg.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Echolocation in blind people reveals the brain’s adaptive...
by elliekelly on Sunday October 06, 2019 @12:15PM
(#21172906)
The article mentions that echolocation is a way the brain adapts in some blind people but your comment seems like echolocation is at least partially learned skill.
Since you’ve taken a class on it I’d be curious to know whether you got the sense it’s something most people could learn if they wanted to spend the time/effort? Or does it seem like the sort of thing that some people just seem to pick up “naturally”?
Re:Echolocation in blind people reveals the brain’s adaptive...
by miki123211 on Monday October 07, 2019 @01:08AM
(#21177701)
The things he tried to teach us could be done by most students at least semi-reliably. I think practice helps here, but talent helps too, just like with learning to play a musical instrument. There are people for whom it comes easily, but it seems other people can be taught too. This is all anecdotal evidence, though.
Re:Echolocation in blind people reveals the brain’s adaptive...
by AllanHoustonSt on Sunday October 06, 2019 @12:31PM
(#21173018)
Does training for something like this lean more towards perfecting technique or forcing adaptation through repetition like training a muscle?
Re:Echolocation in blind people reveals the brain’s adaptive...
by miki123211 on Monday October 07, 2019 @01:09AM
(#21177706)
We had just one class, so I can't really tell for certain. The advice the guy gave us was to try this at home, in various situations and see what we can do.