News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cars and the Fourth Amendment by owenmarshall on Friday October 04, 2019 @01:13PM (#21159729)
An old parking enforcement technique is to put a chalk mark on a car's tire: if you come back after two hours and see the same car with the marked tire you know that it has parked too long and can be ticketed.

The 6th circuit recently ruled that is an unconstitutional search[1]: a government agent is physically intruding on a private area (your car) and searching it for information (how long it's been there).

Neat stuff.

[1]http://www.patc.com/articles/2019_taylor_v_saginaw_chapman.p...

Re:Cars and the Fourth Amendment by SilasX on Friday October 04, 2019 @01:40PM (#21159998)
That puts them in a weird, paradoxical position:

1) Illegal: Placing a mark on your tires that will quickly fade with time and invades your car just enough to reveal whether you adhered to the limits.

2) Legal: Monitor the area with video surveillance and take pictures of every license plate that ever parked there, with timestamps and a photo of the occupants, and store that information for eternity, to be shared with any LEO who wants it.

(2) feels a lot more invasive than (1), but courts consider (2) okay because it just uses stuff visible to the public, while (1) actually physically modifies your car.

Edit: See also the conflict with the long-standing, uncontested practice of leaving a fingerprint on a car's tail light at the beginning of a stop before observing any wrongdoing that warrants such a "search": https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19730452

Re:Cars and the Fourth Amendment by kempbellt on Friday October 04, 2019 @01:54PM (#21160169)
Strange how a chalk mark is illegal, but placing a ticket under the windshield wiper, or sticking a "vehicle to be towed" sticker on the window isn't.

To add: I'd personally much rather local LEOs use the chalk method than the camera method.

Re:Cars and the Fourth Amendment by SilasX on Friday October 04, 2019 @01:57PM (#21160191)
In fairness, the argument is about what you can do to a car before you have evidence of wrongdoing, and the sticker/tickets happen after they have observed an infraction, so that's less problematic in the context of the ruling.

Edit:

>To add: I'd personally much rather local LEOs use the chalk method than the camera method.

Me too!

Re:Cars and the Fourth Amendment by vanniv on Saturday October 05, 2019 @07:49PM (#21168761)
The ticket is legal, because by the time you get the ticket, they know you've committed the offense.

The chalk is only illegal because they have to mark your car before you've overstayed, and at that time, the search is unreasonable, since they're just assuming that you're going to overstay.

Re:Cars and the Fourth Amendment by lhorie on Friday October 04, 2019 @03:31PM (#21161093)
If the logic is that it's illegal to "modify" the car, couldn't they just get away with standing a domino or similar piece of wood behind one of the tires? If the car moves out, it topples the domino.
Re:Cars and the Fourth Amendment by SkyBelow on Friday October 04, 2019 @03:38PM (#21161150)
Kinda like the difference between wiretapping laws and recording what people say verses video recordings (which when in HD can have very rough audio encoded inside of the video).
Re:Cars and the Fourth Amendment by mtgx on Friday October 04, 2019 @01:52PM (#21160155)
I feel like because all of this is so new, we haven't had time to fully think about this stuff, and law enforcement is abusing this.

But if we take things one by one, we could see that some real restrictions could be put on the use of this technology, even in the context of existing laws.

For instance, "video surveillance is allowed because everything it sees is public."

But then you can go like "Okay, but..."

1) A regular person wouldn't remember everything it saw in public a year from now, a month from now, or even a day from now.

2) A regular person wouldn't try to build all sorts of automatic connections between various identities it sees in public over longer periods of time (say more than a few hours)

3) A regular person wouldn't be able to take punitive action with the might of the government and taking up weapons against crimes it sees happen in public (so perhaps someone like a government entity needs to be more restricted than regular people when doing certain monitoring activities, because of their inherit potential for abuse?)

Suddenly when you consider all three of these ideas, and there are probably more like them, we can realize that public surveillance doesn't have to be the "free for all" governments would like us to believe that it should be (because the more true that becomes, the more power they have against each individual, way before there's even a hint of a case against someone).

Re:Cars and the Fourth Amendment by bennylope on Friday October 04, 2019 @01:20PM (#21159807)
The court later issued a clarification basically upholding the logic of their ruling but stating that because the chalking was part of valid [regulatory] activities (below) the chalking is okay[0].

> Rather, we hold, based on the pleading stage of this litigation, that two exceptions to the warrant requirement—the “community caretaking” exception and the motor-vehicle exception—do not apply here. Our holding extends no further than this.

From the court's order[1]:

> Because we chalk this practice up to a regulatory exercise, rather than a community-caretaking function, we REVERSE.

[0] https://www.sixthcircuitappellateblog.com/recent-cases/sixth... [1] https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/ca6/17...

Re:Cars and the Fourth Amendment by owenmarshall on Friday October 04, 2019 @02:01PM (#21160227)
I don't think that's the right reading. At least, that's not how I read it.

> Alison Taylor, a frequent recipient of parking tickets, sued the City and its parking enforcement officer Tabitha Hoskins, alleging that chalking violated her Fourth Amendment right to be free from unreasonable search. The City moved to dismiss the action. The district court granted the City’s motion, finding that, while chalking may have constituted a search under the Fourth Amendment, the search was reasonable. Because we chalk this practice up to a regulatory exercise, rather than a community-caretaking function, we REVERSE

The sixth circuit has reversed the district court's dismissal that the search was reasonable. Both the sixth circuit and the lower court agree that marking the tire is a search; the lower court dismissed and held that the search was reasonable.

The amended decision says that once the case advances the city can argue that their actions fall under 4th amendment exceptions, but that their current motion did not sufficiently make that argument.

The chalking may be found OK during further proceedings, depending on how the city argued, but at the time that decision was issued it was not.

Re:Cars and the Fourth Amendment by bennylope on Friday October 04, 2019 @03:08PM (#21160875)
Yeah, I think I've mixed something up.

I was [lightly] researching this a few weeks back and am pretty sure I found that the net effect of the final ruling was that for the purpose of enforcing regulations [any] city could mark tires, and that because it the outside of the vehicle on public property it was not trespass...

Re:Cars and the Fourth Amendment by SilasX on Friday October 04, 2019 @01:33PM (#21159930)
So, am I understanding that right, that they're upholding the chalking-tires technique, but saying it holds up for reasons other than the vehicle and caretaking exceptions?

Also:

>>Because we chalk this practice up to a regulatory exercise

It should not be legal for judges to make puns like that.

(Edited to add substantive remark that belonged here as well.)

Re:Cars and the Fourth Amendment by gowld on Friday October 04, 2019 @04:21PM (#21161546)
It was a very technical decision that clarified the parameters of the debate and sent it back to be re-judged. They didn't uphold/knockdown anything. They did say that chalking a tire is a "search" (using bad logic, IMO), but did not rule that it was "unreasonable".
Re:Cars and the Fourth Amendment by snagglegaggle on Friday October 04, 2019 @02:40PM (#21160589)
For a while I have struggled with how vehicles in the US are treated. A national ID system and the requirement to ID onesself is opposed for many likely valid reasons but a national ID system for cars and the requirement to ID yourself is in some way materially different?

As I just recently commented elsewhere: There is a right to travel and a right to engage in interstate commerce. Sure, you can argue there is no right to drive a car, but only inasmuch as there is no right to operate a printing press and distribute leaflets.

Re:Cars and the Fourth Amendment by gowld on Friday October 04, 2019 @04:21PM (#21161553)
There is no right to operate a printing press on the public roadways.
Re:Cars and the Fourth Amendment by snagglegaggle on Friday October 04, 2019 @06:10PM (#21162332)
Mixing the metaphor broke it. Starting again: I have a right to travel. Some travel involves vehicles, which are currently licensed. This is analogous to requiring permits and searches for specific kinds of speech.
Re:Cars and the Fourth Amendment by braindeath on Friday October 04, 2019 @08:22PM (#21163013)
You don't have a constitutional right to operate a vehicle in the US.
Re:Cars and the Fourth Amendment by snagglegaggle on Friday October 04, 2019 @08:44PM (#21163098)
That's debateable, did you read my comment? If you take exception to a specific point speak to it.
Re:Cars and the Fourth Amendment by owenmarshall on Saturday October 05, 2019 @09:30AM (#21165386)
It is debatable, has been debated by the courts and settled: you have a right to freely travel, but there is no right to use any particular mode of transportation without government regulation.

This is why sovcits who are “traveling in commerce” without license and insurance always lose their “legal” arguments. Because the issue is settled - there is no constitutional right to drive a car.

Re:Cars and the Fourth Amendment by snagglegaggle on Saturday October 05, 2019 @03:52PM (#21167543)
Ok, that's great, but jurisprudence only stands inasmuch as there's no new arguments. Those rulings could be overturned.

Nothing is ever truly settled. Pointlessly respecting jurisprudence without regard for time and society is a recipe for contempt of the law.

Re:Cars and the Fourth Amendment by owenmarshall on Saturday October 05, 2019 @05:34PM (#21168113)
Okay, overturn the case law - state your thesis and advance a novel argument.

So far I’ve seen driving:traveling::printing:speech. Not only is that not an argument, it conveniently overlooks that we have restrictions on speech today - libel and slander, incitement, etc.

What is your thesis? Driving should be completely unconstrained by the state? Why? Or is it that we should have national IDs? Why?