It was a very technical decision that clarified the parameters of the debate and sent it back to be re-judged. They didn't uphold/knockdown anything. They did say that chalking a tire is a "search" (using bad logic, IMO), but did not rule that it was "unreasonable".
Also:
>>Because we chalk this practice up to a regulatory exercise
It should not be legal for judges to make puns like that.
(Edited to add substantive remark that belonged here as well.)