Re:Streets with Nooks and Crannies Are Beloved and Endangered
by praptak on Friday October 04, 2019 @01:36PM
(#21159959)
There are reasons why most services aren't public ones and should not be - this argument actually works.
For each service that is public there's usually a good counterargument. Is there one for public subsidizing of private car parking?
Re:Streets with Nooks and Crannies Are Beloved and Endangered
by secabeen on Friday October 04, 2019 @07:16PM
(#21162712)
In and around a commercial district, there is. If your customers are living in a standard suburban area around your commercial core, the city will often provide parking so that those customers can reach the businesses in that area. See the publicly owned parking lots in Santa Monica, Santa Barbara, Palo Alto, etc. Without those lots, there would be a lot less business (and thus less tax revenue) because the customers couldn't get to the businesses.
Re:Streets with Nooks and Crannies Are Beloved and Endangered
by biggestdecision on Friday October 04, 2019 @08:46PM
(#21163110)
Or you can design your city to not be so car-centric. Why aren't commercial districts designed so that walking or using public transportation to reach them is viable?
If you put cars right at the center of urban planning, you'll always build cities that require people to own cars.
Re:Streets with Nooks and Crannies Are Beloved and Endangered
by secabeen on Monday October 07, 2019 @02:09PM
(#21184084)
This is true, but the challenge is that you can't just change how wide the streets are or how big the buildings are in an urban area overnight. It takes decades to change the transportation orientation of a neighborhood, and in the meantime, people have to live/work there.
That's because you could use your same argument about any public service. We pay for it in spades through income and council taxes.
Deliberately semi-quoting your argument:
You get public services for an insanely low price (healthcare, firemen, police, libraries, schools) for your own private benefit. You are forcing everyone around you to pay for you to not die/not have your house burn down/not get robbed/learn/get your kids educated etc because you don't feel like paying for it yourself.
Can't afford your own healthcare/fireman/police/library/school? Then perhaps we shouldn't let you use them unless you are willing to pay market rate for the service.