News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Unsteady income in young adulthood linked to thinking pro... by coldtea on Friday October 04, 2019 @09:31AM (#21157444)
>Instead of spending all that time and effort invalidating the opinion of those who have successfully made it out of those circumstances, why don't you ask them how they did it and what they think can be done to help those who haven't?

Don't worry about that, for the types I talk about, we get to hear "how they did it" at every chance they get to brag about it.

People also hear "what they think can be done to help those who haven't", and more often than not, its condescending garbage, like "you just need to try harder", "motivation is key", "those people are lazy", and so on.

They are the worst judges of the factors of their success. For one, as the saying goes, "no winner believes in chance". It's all about their character and grit, nothing circumstantial -- so even if we take their words as gospel, there's nothing there applicable to others, except "change your character".

In fact compared to that, the born-rich are perhaps more considerate than the outliers that made it.

>The problem with keyboard warriors is that it isn't actually action. It's akin to the studies showing that people who talk about what they're going to do get the same emotional satisfaction from actually doing it.

Which is neither here, nor there. This is a discussion, we are all "keyboard warriors" here.

>What you've managed to do is dismiss the very people who have the most insight and made yourself feel better to boot. What's not to like, right?

Or, you know, I've managed to shed some light into things that are still a large problem in modern society, and that people tend to view wrongly.

Also, when you assume (e.g. that I'm poor myself and needed to say those things to "feel better") you make an ass out of, etc...

Re:Unsteady income in young adulthood linked to thinking pro... by qaq on Friday October 04, 2019 @09:56AM (#21157713)
You like to focus on extremes. The important question is how a person from poor background can move into middle class. Who becomes a billionaire is pretty irrelevant even if you are from well to do family your chances of making it to ,,, are still extremely low.
Re:Unsteady income in young adulthood linked to thinking pro... by coldtea on Friday October 04, 2019 @10:31AM (#21158075)
>The important question is how a person from poor background can move into middle class.

The important question for a society is how many persons of poor backgrounds move into middle class (and how many middle class persons fall into poverty).

And the answer should be systemic, not just about "laziness" and "lack of motivation" and so on, because that wont explain how some societies manage to have way less pour/homeless/etc and more middle class, and others fail at it. Or how the same society changes its ratios over time...

Re:Unsteady income in young adulthood linked to thinking pro... by malvosenior on Friday October 04, 2019 @01:38PM (#21159975)
The cultural mores of poor communities are also "systemic", your argument seems to entirely discount the role they play in individual opportunity.
Re:Unsteady income in young adulthood linked to thinking pro... by celticmusic on Friday October 04, 2019 @09:40AM (#21157527)
There's always reasons why the dismissal of those with the most insight is the "right" thing to do.

It turns out human beings can rationalize a lot of things that ought not be rationalized.

Re:Unsteady income in young adulthood linked to thinking pro... by coldtea on Friday October 04, 2019 @10:32AM (#21158084)
Notice how you take for granted (that they have the "most insight") what you should prove...