So maybe it isn't really that big of a deal?
No, I did not do that.
I do not want to discuss if "groups" is a "big deal" or not.
I am interested in the question if "groups" in distributed, federated systems is a solved problem or not.
One of the creators had a conversation with kaniini, one of the pleroma devs, about this: https://social.coop/@datatitian/102893246730611249
I still have an account on mastodon thought and I'm far more active there than on twitter, mostly because new is interesting and to support a good cause.
I also sometimes follow development and hope that it might get more features from both Google+ or Facebook. Groups would be an obvious improvement in my book.
That way maybe it could become more than a twitter clone, which matters to me because in my opinion Twitter is close to useless except as a better way to receive spam and propaganda (it is even easier to ignore than the spam folder in my mail.)
But at the end of the day it's still a Twitter clone, so offers absolutely no value to me.
Agree in the long run.
In the short run playing with interesting tech has its own value at least as long as it only replaces more useless stuff (I guess tv is the thing I "sacrifice" to have time for tech.)
And that is the one reason I haven't already started a Mastodon instance and tried to talk all my family and friends into using it instead of Facebook.
Some people like everything to be public; fine. But some people, like me, want to be able to control who sees stuff; as far as I can tell, the only platform which allows that at the moment is Facebook.
Why not make "groups" an option, so that it can serve both kinds of people?
Last I checked, Twitter doesn't have groups.
Usually, focusing on doing one thing only is how you make good products.
Most email programs use a built-in rendering engine anyway, and sometimes browsers can actually use the email code (e.g. MHTML is basically MIME+HTML, HTML sanitization[0], Opera used M2 for RSS support). So a browser having a built-in email client might be undesirable, but it is not "insane".
[0]https://frederik-braun.com/firefox-ui-xss-leading-to-rce.htm...
Mastodon not implementing a "limited visibility" option would be more like a web browser refusing to implement Private Browsing mode.
It's funny how something that seemed so insane at the time is now the de facto standard way of taking pictures.
In Mastodon (or most ActivityPub software), a DM thread can even be splitted and recipients added/removed at any point.
Mastodon does not come with features that enable the idea of "groups"?
I just found issue 139 [0], but "mastodon groups" is an extraordinary bad combination of search terms.
The author seems to dismiss the idea that "groups" are an obvious requirement (IMHO) for any "social" software. Instead he seems to be assuming that one instance of the software might serve one "group" - with no easy way to scale "instance" to many servers.
Pleroma seems to plan for a groups feature [2][3], also using a framework that might be much easier for scaling, but seems to be struggling with implementation.
I see GNU social seems to have groups [1], but in the linked issues people write about bugs with that.
I am not sure this is really how it is, so please correct me if I am wrong.
Would anybody with more knowledge please like to explain why such a basic feature is missing from "social" software alternatives?
I want to understand what the problem is here, I feel like this is the first feature that should be considered from day one. It seems to me trying to handle such a basic feature as an afterthought has a high potential for disaster score (PFD>80): will require a deep re-design and rewrite, trigger several different implementations, standards and endless discussions, in the end will destroy everything.
I understand that groups and p2p / federation is complicated - but is this not a solved problem?
If not, is it a good idea to put this on top of the agenda for "offer alternative for big social brother"?
[0] https://github.com/tootsuite/mastodon/issues/139 [1] https://gnusocial.net/doc/groups [2] https://git.pleroma.social/pleroma/pleroma/issues/656 [3] https://git.pleroma.social/pleroma/pleroma-fe/issues/625
No, tags can not replace groups.