Re:EFF Wins Access to License Plate Reader Data to Study Law...
by jumpingmice on Thursday October 03, 2019 @10:24PM
(#21154291)
Implied consent passed in California in 1998.
Re:EFF Wins Access to License Plate Reader Data to Study Law...
by AnthonyMouse on Friday October 04, 2019 @12:51AM
(#21154863)
The 1998 California legislature was full of people who were adults before the interstate highway system was built. And the Patriot Act was passed in 2001; doesn't mean the sentiment doesn't date to the McCarthy era.
Re:EFF Wins Access to License Plate Reader Data to Study Law...
by snagglegaggle on Friday October 04, 2019 @09:19AM
(#21157342)
While there is no right to driving automobiles there is a right to travel and interstate commerce. Notably there is no right to travel at a specific speed or in a specific way so it follows that there is some right to travel by car, and the various tracking mechanisms of vehicles violate the 4th.
Saying there is no right to travel via automobile is like saying certain methods of disseminating speech are not protected.
Your argument would only hold water in the future if self-driving cars become widespread and it isn't necessary to display a number plate on a car without a human driver, thereby giving people a reasonable transportation alternative that allows for anonymous freedom of movement. Until then, the government should not be able to simultaneously mandate number plates and use them for mass surveillance.