Build 1 functioning brain in silicon, and:
- 18 months later you can build one that's twice as fast using the same principles
- duplicate this brain and get the power of multiple people thinking together (but with greater bandwidth between them than any human group)
- run this brain for 100 years and get an older intellectually functioning human than has ever existed before
- duplicate whatever learning this brain has accumulated over 100 years (which, say, brings to the level of an Einstein) as many times as you have physical resources for (so, clone Einstein)
All those are paths to super-human AI from the production of a human-intelligence brain in a non-biological form.
So, if a human brain can make a computer brain, which is a reasonable assumption, then a human brain can make a brain smarter than itself.
That reminds me of Chesterton's definition of Western science: "Give us one free miracle and we'll explain everything else." :)
Edit: Wish I could remember where I originally got that. Googling it digs up not Chesterton but Terence McKenna.
After all, we know that human brains can be built in some way: we have the evidence for that claim inside billions of skulls. The question is then not to push the theoretical boundaries of computational capability beyond some theoretical level - but merely to achieve it again artificially.
We've managed to copy birds, fish, we've sent people to the moon, we've sent probes outside the solar system, we've beaten countless diseases, we've extended our own lifespans by decades, we've created monuments of human culture... why assume that we won't achieve this too?
Exactly. Skulls. With connection to living and feeling flesh.
> After all, we know that human brains can be built in some way: we have the evidence for that > claim inside billions of skulls
We cannot even model the brain of the simplest worm…
And, unless you claim there is something inherently magical and miraculous in that, it can be reproduced or abstracted.
> We cannot even model the brain of the simplest worm…
I don't believe that's true. I am quite sure we have some models of varying accuracy (as in "good enough") for those. Maybe we cannot run the most accurate ones (modeling the chemical processes within individual neurons) in real time, but, by 2012, we'll be able to run them twice as fast as we do now.
Exactly. Skulls. With connection to living and feeling flesh.
The human brains provide a minimum theoretical limit, that's all. The existence of the human brain proves categorically that it is physically possible to build a computing device that fits inside a skull and has the computational capabilities of a brain. It exists, therefore it can exist.
So, any argument that "it's impossible to build such a device" are refuted by our very existence.
We cannot even model the brain of the simplest worm
See Moore's law and the relationship between computational capacity and neural network modelling.
The problem then is people just referring to "the Singularity" without specifying what they're talking about.
Citation please?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_from_ignorance
To approach this from a different perspective, imagine somebody saying the following at about 1890:
"This ignores the fact that if we ever do make a heavier-than-air flying machine it will either be via (a) reverse-engineering of birds or (b) some kind of evolutionary algorithm."
That would have turned out to be false.
blockquote
>If this is not amazing enough, consider the fact that even when experts are given the results of SPRs, they still can't outperform those SPRs (Leli & Filskov 1985; Goldberg 1968).
>So why aren't SPRs in use everywhere? Probably, we deny or ignore the success of SPRs because of deep-seated cognitive biases, such as overconfidence in our own judgments. But if these SPRs work as well as or better than human judgments, shouldn't we use them?
/blockquote
(I think the idea of 'The Singularity' is bunk for other reasons though)
Computers can solve mathematical equations faster than humans, recall vast amounts of historical knowledge and information in fractions of a second and passably translate between many languages.
Are you saying that your definition of 'smart' wouldn't include many of the capabilities of Wolfram Alpha?
1. The first comment on this article: The singularity refers to the time in human history when computers first pass the Turing test.
2. Wikipedia: A technological singularity is a hypothetical event occurring when technological progress becomes so rapid that it makes the future after the singularity qualitatively different and harder to predict -- hey, y'know what I call the point beyond which the future is hard to predict? I call it "the present".
... and I'm too lazy to keep looking up other definitions, but they're definitely out there.
The second problem with the idea is that some folks seem to have this flawed logical chain in mind:
1. Assume that a human brain can make a computer smarter than itself.
2. In that case, the computer smarter than the human can make a computer smarter than itself, which can in turn make a still smarter computer, and so on, leading to vastly smarter computers very quickly.
This ignores the fact that if we ever do make a computer smarter than a human it will either be via (a) reverse-engineering of the human brain or (b) some kind of evolutionary algorithm. The slightly-smarter computer is then no more capable of building an even-smarter computer than we are, since it also has to fall back on one of these two dull mechanical processes.