News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nearly half of white Harvard students are athletes/childr... by Animats on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @06:07PM (#21131262)
Wow. That seriously devalues a Harvard diploma in hiring decisions.

Especially since Harvard is easy once you get in. 97.5% graduation rate. It's not like they're flunking out the losers among the legacy admits. UC Berkeley is around 90%.

Re:Nearly half of white Harvard students are athletes/childr... by csa on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @06:17PM (#21131381)
IMHO, degrees from any school should by default be devalued. Certain departments/majors within certain schools sometimes maybe have some value.

1. Elite schools are motivated to have high graduation rates in order to be competitive in various rankings.

2. Most programs at elite schools are not incentivized to take a tough love approach since it reduces enrollment numbers and ultimately funding. Popular programs get a pass on this.

3. For most elite school grads, if you’re hiring them for their education, then your usually hiring for the wrong thing. The best elite school grads, regardless of major, will get you access to better networks. The median elite school grad will get you someone who is aggressively willing to jump through hoops for rewards. If you don’t know how to capitalize on that, don’t hire these people.

FWIW, some majors at Harvard are definitely not easy — they just cull the weaker students early.

Re:Nearly half of white Harvard students are athletes/childr... by LordFast on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @06:11PM (#21131315)
And that's the overall number. Berkeley's College of Engineering programs have lower graduation numbers.

P.S. It shouldn't be a good thing to brutally weed out students. Facts are facts though.

Re:Nearly half of white Harvard students are athletes/childr... by devnulloverflow on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @06:20PM (#21131414)
It's not about weeding anyone out. Or at least not trying to.

An Engineering degree that really teaches stuff will be difficult. And some students will find it is not for them and leave. Preferably early before they have invested too much in it.

Re:Nearly half of white Harvard students are athletes/childr... by topkai22 on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @06:39PM (#21131624)
There are some serious problems with the pathways to engineering majors though. I don't know if it is still the case, but I remember my state school expected calculus pre-calculus in high school as the norm for engineering majors. To get to that level of mathematics in high school you had to progress from to Alegbra II to FST, to pre-calc or calculus, but you were only required by the school system to take up through Alegbra II, which a lot of students got to in 9th grade. That means that you had to decide to be an engineer at age 14 and keep taking math.

The reason why students exit engineering programs isn't just the material- it can be a terrible teacher (hello physics professor with a thick accent that would insult their students for being stupid), the culture, or being underprepared for the material with no clear path forward to becoming prepared.

Re:Nearly half of white Harvard students are athletes/childr... by vonmoltke on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @06:56PM (#21131770)
> To get to that level of mathematics in high school you had to progress from to Alegbra II to FST, to pre-calc or calculus, but you were only required by the school system to take up through Alegbra II

What's FST?

In my district, students were required to go through Algebra II and Geometry. We were also required to take three years of math. As a result, kids who took Algebra I in middle School went Algebra II->Geometry->Precal, while those who didn't went Algebra I-> Algebra II->Geometry. One group had the requirements by default, and the other didn't need to decide until senior year.

Re:Nearly half of white Harvard students are athletes/childr... by topkai22 on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @07:14PM (#21141790)
FST was functions statistics and trig. Might not be a thing anymore.

We required 3 years of high school math, but if you did algebra in 7th grade it counted toward the requirement. A lot of higher tracked kids were done with thier math requirement by the end of 9th grade as a result.

Re:Nearly half of white Harvard students are athletes/childr... by vonmoltke on Thursday October 03, 2019 @11:38AM (#21148239)
Oh, in my district (at the time) you had to take three math classes in high school, regardless of what level you were at.
Re:Nearly half of white Harvard students are athletes/childr... by uoaei on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @06:13PM (#21131340)
It should be a good thing to weed out bad students. It's not a good thing that there are bad students.
Re:Nearly half of white Harvard students are athletes/childr... by kashprime on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @11:37PM (#21133250)
A Malcolm Gladwell noted in his recent podcast, the entire Ivy league undergrad cohort (17k) would fit into the incoming class at the University of Toronto (ranked ~20 worldwide in most rankings). If Harvard admission is so rigged, and the best and brightest are not making it in, maybe these numbers will do more to lessen it's social and academic cache than anything the courts could do.
Re:Nearly half of white Harvard students are athletes/childr... by lozenge on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @06:27PM (#21131513)
I doubt these legacy admissions are going for a tech job, especially the ones that aren't that smart. They are going to go to jobs where connections and what Harvard brings can help them - politics, lobbying, the media, executive roles in nonprofits and in investment firms.
Re:Nearly half of white Harvard students are athletes/childr... by gist on Thursday October 03, 2019 @01:41PM (#21149678)
> That seriously devalues a Harvard diploma in hiring decisions.

Not even close. It's a brand and it's a good brand ... a very good brand and one of the best and it opens doors. Nobody honestly really cares about what happens behind the scenes the halo is typically that strong.

Look at it this way. If someone gets an Academy Award it's a branding that says 'you are chosen and special for some reason'. Doesn't matter if the film is good or sells the most ticket. Someone has decided it's special (or a production person/director/producer is special) and that's that.

When someone buys a luxury product sure it's most likely a more quality product but that is not what they are paying for or they care about. Not only do they not want to hear it's made in the same factor that makes things for Target but if they did hear they'd probably not care that much either.

> Especially since Harvard is easy once you get in. Did it occur to you that perhaps people rise to what is expected of them and are perhaps more fearful of failing or take advantage of all sorts of help so they do graduate? Or that they work really hard because they are there and are afraid to flunk more so than at a lesser university? It's also obvious that there are probably 10 people that could 'do the work' for those that are admitted. It has never been about the best and smartest at any upper tier college. And there isn't even a way to measure that anyone who thinks top grades and testing is what matters hasn't dealt with enough people in the world who are productive, have achieved but do not test well.

Re:Nearly half of white Harvard students are athletes/childr... by HodgeTheCat on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @05:15PM (#21140807)
Full disclosure, I’m an undergrad at Yale.

I think that the high graduation rates at Ivy schools are fundamentally misleading in a couple of ways, if your takeaway is that getting a degree there must be easy. First of all, for academic and demographic reasons, most people at these schools would still have overwhelming odds of graduating elsewhere. Broadly speaking, it’s not the “dumbest” kids who flunk out, but those who are least likely to be in college in the first place.

The comparison of Berkeley/MIT/Caltech is interesting in that their attrition rate is much higher than HYP etc. IMO that reflects well on academic standards for the “alt ivies”, but I think the crucial point here is to recognize that academic programs have substantial influence in this regard.

Most obviously, there’s the difference in grading across fields, with STEM being the least forgiving across the board at top institutions. Thus it’s natural that the STEM dominant institutions have higher burnout.

The second, less obvious piece has to do with rules around changing programs, and opportunity cost. Notably most of the Ivy schools (and many alt schools) allow students to switch majors without significant hassle. Since many “soft” majors at Ivy schools are still on the FIRE/Consulting pipeline, the natural course of action for someone who’s underperforming in a more difficult program is to remain in the institution and change their major. This isn’t necessarily true for the STEM-first schools, whose humanities undergrads are less successful winding up in a lucrative east coast industry.

So I’m inclined to think it’s more about incentives than any conscious effort by the schools.

Re:Nearly half of white Harvard students are athletes/childr... by TrackerFF on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @06:20PM (#21141385)
Hope I don't come off as a conspiracy nut, but:

I think it's important to remember that in the big picture of things, very, very few employers care about whether a hire went to Harvard or not.

But as it happens, the ones that do, also wield a lot of power.

I think a lot of these places only care partially about the intellectual prowess of their candidates, but also about a lot of other factors. Socioeconomic background, networks, pedigree, and what not.

Hiring the right kid from Harvard / Yale / Princeton / whatever means that he/she can be a good future resource not just because they're smart, but because they have many other attributes with considerable upsides 20-30 years down the road.

Hell, I'll put it in plain text: I think a lot of elite universities are valued in the job market because they're breeding grounds for rich elites, where the new generation of rulers can mingle and network, which is very useful for future operations. It's about grooming people for succession .

Obviously doesn't hold true for everyone there, but the ones that know how the system is rigged, will follow the rules.

Re:Nearly half of white Harvard students are athletes/childr... by bilbo0s on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @06:12PM (#21131331)
I don't know man?

Just Devil's Advocate.

But what if these legacy admits are not as dumb as people think they are?

Just kind of, throwing that possibility out there.

Re:Nearly half of white Harvard students are athletes/childr... by eropple on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @06:20PM (#21131413)
It's less "dumb", more "trained." Ezra Klein had an excellent podcast with Daniel Markovits a couple weeks ago that touched on this--being optimized (by parents and the local culture around you) to succeed at getting to Harvard (or Yale or whatever) doesn't mean that it's the best thing for you or for society to be afforded the significant benefits that we, both consciously and unconsciously, assign to that.
Re:Nearly half of white Harvard students are athletes/childr... by mtnGoat on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @06:20PM (#21131416)
the fact they are using the legacy backdoor to get in, instead of the great academics route... kinda would dictate they aren't on the same level of "smarts".

People only use the backdoor when the front one wont work.

Re:Nearly half of white Harvard students are athletes/childr... by paulgb on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @06:25PM (#21131487)
I agree, but to clarify a point: the "nearly half" number includes athletes, legacy admits, children of faculty and big doners, whether or not they would have otherwise gotten in on academic merits. The authors estimate that only a quarter would have. I didn't read deeply enough to see if they broke that number by legacy admits only.
Re:Nearly half of white Harvard students are athletes/childr... by gnicholas on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @06:25PM (#21131489)
Does the study say that they "used the legacy backdoor"? I think most college applications just ask the applicant if any family members attended or teach at the institution. It would be pretty foolish to leave that blank if you had family members that had gone or taught there.