Re:Prominent scientists warn UN Secretary-General Guterres
by colinb on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @09:18AM
(#21124976)
"often" is a weasel word here. How about "sometimes"? Sometimes good questions come from outside a field. Nevertheless, when I'm suffering from a serious medical condition, I prefer to see a medical doctor. When my central heating packs up, I call a licensed gas-fitter.
Argument from authority seems like a bad plan. But arguing against someone _because_ they have authority seems worse.
Re:Prominent scientists warn UN Secretary-General Guterres
by airbreather on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @11:13AM
(#21126206)
However, we are not talking about treatment or repairs, so poor if not irrelevant comparisons.
It is recognised that the most valuable person/s in review panels are the rank outsiders that ask the questions that are considered already answered or too outlandish to consider.
There are a number of studies I can't be arsed to dig up, however Feynman and the challenger investigation is one slightly oblique example.
Outsiders do not have the fear of pointing at the elephant in the room.
Just because someone has a degree in a certain subject does not make them the only one that can ask questions about that subject.
This is called "White coat syndrome".