Re:Prominent scientists warn UN Secretary-General Guterres
by Beltiras on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @06:52AM
(#21123986)
Many of the signatories are not climate scientists. Lead signatory is an engineer that worked for oil and gas his entire life.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Prominent scientists warn UN Secretary-General Guterres
by airbreather on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @08:04AM
(#21124361)
Often the best questions come from someone outside the field.
Just because someone has a degree in a certain subject does not make them the only one that can ask questions about that subject.
This is called "White coat syndrome".
Re:Prominent scientists warn UN Secretary-General Guterres
by colinb on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @09:18AM
(#21124976)
"often" is a weasel word here. How about "sometimes"? Sometimes good questions come from outside a field. Nevertheless, when I'm suffering from a serious medical condition, I prefer to see a medical doctor. When my central heating packs up, I call a licensed gas-fitter.
Argument from authority seems like a bad plan. But arguing against someone _because_ they have authority seems worse.
Re:Prominent scientists warn UN Secretary-General Guterres
by airbreather on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @11:13AM
(#21126206)
However, we are not talking about treatment or repairs, so poor if not irrelevant comparisons.
It is recognised that the most valuable person/s in review panels are the rank outsiders that ask the questions that are considered already answered or too outlandish to consider.
There are a number of studies I can't be arsed to dig up, however Feynman and the challenger investigation is one slightly oblique example.
Outsiders do not have the fear of pointing at the elephant in the room.
Re:Prominent scientists warn UN Secretary-General Guterres
by Beltiras on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @09:06AM
(#21124865)
They are however most often answered by someone within the field. These folks are saying they have an answer, not a question.
Re:Prominent scientists warn UN Secretary-General Guterres
by Oletros on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @11:40AM
(#21126614)
They are not asking questions, they are saying that all the other scientists are wrong