News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Capitalism, Alone by amelius on Monday September 30, 2019 @04:33PM (#21119407)
One dimension not addressed is how individual people join forces as companies and effectively turn against other groups of people.

What would happen to the economy if we'd only allow companies of 1000 people, of 100 people, or perhaps even of 1 person?

Re:Capitalism, Alone by agitator on Monday September 30, 2019 @05:24PM (#21119792)
This is a fascinating concept!

On one hand it would keep companies from completely vertically integrating or expanding to encompass many verticals. Which would stimulate the economy in one way because more people would be exposed to the profits at the top or near the top of the market. Also the increased competition might result in the improvement of various small aspects of technology that would result in better efficiencies across the whole.

But on the other hand, limiting the size of companies would make us less competitive on a global scale because of the inherent cost in being forced to buy components, as opposed to vertically integrating. Also product costs may increase, which could negate any increases in wealth among the people.

Re:Capitalism, Alone by godelski on Monday September 30, 2019 @07:50PM (#21120746)
This is a super complicated topic and I'm not sure it could practically be done. Vertical and lateral integration usually result in huge cost savings. It also reduces complexity. But this is also a feature that monopolies (or monopoly like companies) exploit. I don't think it would be competitive enough if all players weren't playing by this rule. Competition is good, but so is size (think like Bell Labs [0] and how much Google can do). This is all completely a guess though. But monopolies aren't inherently had, they just usually are because they exploit that power to hinder innovation. Monopolies can actually have huge benefits.

[0] Bell Labs was an agreement that Bell could have the monopoly (to reduce wiring and because of the network effect that they could take advantage of to connect the US with telephone lines) but there was also heavy regulation done during this deal that I'm sure others here are much more informed about and can correct/add to my comment with.

[^] I don't think there's ever been a "free market" nor do I think there ever could be. The US's largest economic growth happened in a "free market" in name only (propaganda a lot for the Russians) but was heavily regulated.

Re:Capitalism, Alone by gojomo on Monday September 30, 2019 @06:05PM (#21120114)
Vernor Vinge's short story 'Conquest By Default' features an interstellar anarchic civilization which has such a rule-against-scale (in any organization, including 'governments') as its highest law. That civilization then encounters Earth, with a number of oversized nations.
Re:Capitalism, Alone by originalvichy on Monday September 30, 2019 @05:05PM (#21119651)
Other such limits are welcome. An umbrella organization should be allowed to only partake in a certain number of categories of business, and in a limited number. Barely anything is being done to control the power equity has over the system many deem as "competetive".

But this won't change. You can't change the system to protect others from greed, when people defend greed. One day they might gain from greed.

Re:Capitalism, Alone by hittaruki on Monday September 30, 2019 @05:56PM (#21120059)
Such arbitrary limits won't work, especially now. For ex: WhatsApp has about ~50 employes[0]. The kind of wealth and value you can create with few people in software is very dissimilar to other sectors which (at least for now) requires a large number of people involved to be viable.

Another issue is what do you consider as part of a company? In the case of uber, would it include all the drivers or are they there on individual companies?

I guess all this comes down to what you are optimizing for: Quality of life for a median human or overall inequality. I think right now it is optimized for the former.

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WhatsApp

Re:Capitalism, Alone by iad on Monday September 30, 2019 @07:30PM (#21120638)
If it would have prevented WhatsApp from being acquired by Facebook, wouldn't that have been it working?
Re:Capitalism, Alone by godelski on Monday September 30, 2019 @07:54PM (#21120769)
The parent is drawing contrast to other companies. For example, let's say you are an ISP. There's a clear network effect there as well. But obviously 50 people can't dig all the ditches and run all the hubs needed to take advantage of that when your country is the size of the US.
Re:Capitalism, Alone by natosaichek on Monday September 30, 2019 @09:27PM (#21121172)
One practical way of imposing such limits might be to eliminate limited liability. If owners are directly responsible for corporate actions, that might provide a defacto limit on company size based on profitability, insurance costs and organizational control efficiencies. (And maybe the intrinsic possible externalities ofa particular business.)
Re:Capitalism, Alone by david927 on Monday September 30, 2019 @06:39PM (#21120338)
And lower liability limits so that if you, say, pollute a river, all owners are personally liable.