Re:Negative Rates Are Rewriting the Rules of Modern Finance
by listenallyall on Monday September 30, 2019 @05:29PM
(#21119825)
Not true. LTCM had some of the most restrictive covenants among similar funds. Minimum lockup of at least 2 years, and redemption notice of 3 or 6 months (hey its been 20 years) - in other words, if you wanted to redeem, you had to give multiple month notice. The investors had no way of forcing LTCM to liquidate any holdings in a panic, in fact the covenants were to protect against that exact scenario, so the firm could ride out their positions.
Counterparties, on the other hand, very different story, if they didn't force LTCM'S hand, they would be stuck with an empty bag.
You're correct that many of LTCM trades did eventually work out positively. But when you're driving a car at 200 mph, a mundane pothole is deadly. When your hedge fund levered 30x, a temporary liquidity crisis is also fatal.
Re:Negative Rates Are Rewriting the Rules of Modern Finance
by conistonwater on Monday September 30, 2019 @02:37PM
(#21118365)
I don't think that's right, at least this is not the way I learned it: the terms on which you borrow money to fund your investments should be considered a part of the model. So if you borrow short term and invest long term, your model itself now includes maturity transformation, and it can blow up just like any such model. Sure you can then construct a different model that's basically the same but without the maturity transformation, and that's okay, you'll get different returns. Thinking about it this way I think it's still fair to blame LTCM, their investors were free to do whatever their contract allowed them to do.
Re:Negative Rates Are Rewriting the Rules of Modern Finance
by owenversteeg on Monday September 30, 2019 @05:20PM
(#21119755)
That's true, and very important. And while I think (or, at least, I hope) large investors keep that in mind after so many high profile explosions like LTCM, I think small time retail investors tend to forget that, and that there's a reason Vanguard (for example) suggests 70% stocks and 30% bonds. Doesn't seem too important, until you need the money...
Re:Negative Rates Are Rewriting the Rules of Modern Finance
by SilasX on Monday September 30, 2019 @03:37PM
(#21118924)
>The flight to liquidity caused them to liquidate positions before they converged, compounding losses.
But that wasn't some incidental thing; it indicated that the core idea behind their arbitrage was flawed -- that there is a reason that the more liquid (US) bonds were consistently overpriced: to account for the fact that, during the occasional crisis, investors flee to them!
In other words, LTCMs collapse was the fault of the investors in LTCM, not the fault of the model. There are hundreds of hedge funds that have continued using the same basic model as LTCM, and have lasted through two recessions and several global financial shocks. They have achieved that by learning from LTCM: keep the model, dump the stupidly overleveraged investors.