Re:The Great Public Market Reckoning
by simonh on Monday September 30, 2019 @12:21PM
(#21116987)
All I can really do is recommend some reading about the history of Marxism and communism being put into practice. It’s not a cheery subject.
The question of private property is an interesting one. Sorry but I hoped to come back and write more but I’m out of time to address it at the moment.
On the balance between private ownership versus public responsibility you’re quite right. It’s not a matter of absolutes. Its important to recognise that every right incurs an obligation on others to recognise, protect and provision the conditions to exercise it. I don’t think there’s anything absolute about rights. They are a vital, indispensable concept, but they are hard work and all the more valuable and worthy of respect because of it, both by those granting them and those exercising them.
I’ve already addressed the question of how to reconcile corporatism with regulation. Corporations are limited liability bodies, which confers on them significant legal and financial benefits. I think taxation and regulation are a reasonable and fair quid pro quo. To expand on that, corporations, individuals and companies in general also benefit from the protection and services of government and society. That includes things like access to an educated work force, protection by the legal system, etc, etc. All of those things create an obligation that can be reasonably discharged through paying taxes and following regulations in the service of the public good.
Of course they can always exercise the ultimate freedom - to leave and go elsewhere. From time to time some do.
The question of private property is an interesting one. Sorry but I hoped to come back and write more but I’m out of time to address it at the moment.
On the balance between private ownership versus public responsibility you’re quite right. It’s not a matter of absolutes. Its important to recognise that every right incurs an obligation on others to recognise, protect and provision the conditions to exercise it. I don’t think there’s anything absolute about rights. They are a vital, indispensable concept, but they are hard work and all the more valuable and worthy of respect because of it, both by those granting them and those exercising them.
I’ve already addressed the question of how to reconcile corporatism with regulation. Corporations are limited liability bodies, which confers on them significant legal and financial benefits. I think taxation and regulation are a reasonable and fair quid pro quo. To expand on that, corporations, individuals and companies in general also benefit from the protection and services of government and society. That includes things like access to an educated work force, protection by the legal system, etc, etc. All of those things create an obligation that can be reasonably discharged through paying taxes and following regulations in the service of the public good.
Of course they can always exercise the ultimate freedom - to leave and go elsewhere. From time to time some do.