News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Employers Used Facebook to Keep Women and Older Workers f... by SpicyLemonZest on Sunday September 29, 2019 @06:57PM (#21110161)
It's not, though. When I buy a page in Cosmo or something, I'm doing that with the intent and result that mostly women will see it. If targeted ads were illegal, it's hard to see how any publication with non-representative demographics could sell ads at all.
Re:Employers Used Facebook to Keep Women and Older Workers f... by analog31 on Sunday September 29, 2019 @07:06PM (#21110207)
The targeted ads in question relate to employment, which is governed by standards for what kinds of discrimination are legal and illegal.
Re:Employers Used Facebook to Keep Women and Older Workers f... by zaroth on Sunday September 29, 2019 @07:50PM (#21110444)
Ok, so are you allowed to place employment ads in Cosmo?

Is it Ok just because it’s overwhelming likely to be women who see it, versus algorithmically targeting women?

Re:Employers Used Facebook to Keep Women and Older Workers f... by gbear605 on Sunday September 29, 2019 @08:09PM (#21110558)
That is how it works legally, yes.
Re:Employers Used Facebook to Keep Women and Older Workers f... by shkkmo on Sunday September 29, 2019 @11:05PM (#21111449)
No, that is not how it works.

> The laws enforced by EEOC prohibit an employer or other covered entity from using neutral employment policies and practices that have a disproportionately negative effect on applicants or employees of a particular race, color, religion, sex (including gender identity, sexual orientation, and pregnancy), or national origin, or on an individual with a disability or class of individuals with disabilities, if the polices or practices at issue are not job-related and necessary to the operation of the business. [0]

[0] https://www.eeoc.gov//laws/practices/

Re:Employers Used Facebook to Keep Women and Older Workers f... by nl on Sunday September 29, 2019 @11:30PM (#21111561)
Are you a lawyer?

I'm not. But I don't believe you are right - advertising in a magazine doesn't exclude people just because their demographic doesn't target them.

If you ran a job ad for a make-up person in women's magazine there is nothing stopping a man who is also interested in make up seeing it and applying.

That is different to the Facebook system, where there was no way for someone from the excluded classes to see the ad.

Re:Employers Used Facebook to Keep Women and Older Workers f... by shkkmo on Sunday September 29, 2019 @11:36PM (#21111584)
I am not a lawyer, but I am directly quoting the US Government Agency that is responsible for enforcing these laws.

US employment law prohibits a large number of normally OK employment practices when they have a disparate impact on protected classes.

> For example, an employer's reliance on word-of-mouth recruitment by its mostly Hispanic work force may violate the law if the result is that almost all new hires are Hispanic. [0]

[0] https://www.eeoc.gov//laws/practices/

Re:Employers Used Facebook to Keep Women and Older Workers f... by shkkmo on Sunday September 29, 2019 @11:03PM (#21111444)
> Ok, so are you allowed to place employment ads in Cosmo?

Yes, if you take care to balance your ad placement so that your job opening advertising policy is not biased against protected classes.

> because it’s overwhelming likely to be women who see it, versus algorithmically targeting women?

That doesn't matter. What matters is the end effect of the advertising policy.

Re:Employers Used Facebook to Keep Women and Older Workers f... by greggman2 on Monday September 30, 2019 @12:15AM (#21111734)
In that case the targeted facebook ads would not be illegal if they were balanced by targeted ads at the groups excluded from the first? Or also not illegal if it can't be proven to have had an actual effect?
Re:Employers Used Facebook to Keep Women and Older Workers f... by TheSpiceIsLife on Sunday September 29, 2019 @08:14PM (#21110585)
Can someone tell me, does Cosmopolitan magazine run job ads?
Re:Employers Used Facebook to Keep Women and Older Workers f... by spamizbad on Sunday September 29, 2019 @10:09PM (#21111169)
It doesn't.
Re:Employers Used Facebook to Keep Women and Older Workers f... by greggman2 on Monday September 30, 2019 @12:13AM (#21111727)
Working Mother Magazine runs ads for jobs if someone wants a more concrete example to use one way or another

https://jobs.workingmother.com/

Re:Employers Used Facebook to Keep Women and Older Workers f... by mav3rick on Sunday September 29, 2019 @07:01PM (#21110181)
Yes but you don't control if a man or an old person can buy the magazine or not.
Re:Employers Used Facebook to Keep Women and Older Workers f... by wesammikhail on Sunday September 29, 2019 @07:17PM (#21110267)
Serious question: How is that relevant though?

Here is how I think about it: If my intention is to discriminate against men and publish an ad in a female magazine, sure, I cant control if a man buys and sees the ad or not. But discrimination was my intention to begin with regardless of how effective my efforts were. Besides, those efforts will be pretty effective. Instead of magazine advertising being 100% effective - as is in the case of FB targeted advertising - they will be just slightly less effective (lets say 90% or w/e number you want to put here). That´s because in the magazine´s case we know for certain that that vast majority of female magazine consumption is done by women - That´s literally what they are made for.

So in a sense, we are arguing about degrees of effectiveness rather than the nature of discrimination. Not only is this a slippery slope, but imo it flips everything in business on its head as having a target audience for your product or a service will be considered discriminatory!

Re:Employers Used Facebook to Keep Women and Older Workers f... by heavyset_go on Sunday September 29, 2019 @07:31PM (#21110339)
> Not only is this a slippery slope, but imo it flips everything in business on its head as having a target audience for your product or a service will be considered discriminatory!

No, it doesn't. If you determine that your target audience watches BET, and you decide to only advertise your product on BET, that's 100% legal.

If you prevented anyone but your target audience from using your service, and you end up discriminating against a protected class, that's a different story.

There are entirely different standards when it comes to hiring and employment.

Re:Employers Used Facebook to Keep Women and Older Workers f... by scarface74 on Sunday September 29, 2019 @10:16PM (#21111203)
There is no need for slippery slopes or hypotheticals. All physical advertising platforms have policies against discrimination for job ads and rentals. Newspapers have had stricter requirements for those two areas for years and there are specific laws governing them. Just because it is “on the internet” doesn’t change anything.

Yes you can advertise jobs in Ebony or Cosmopolitan. There is nothing stopping a non Black or man from picking up those magazines.

Re:Employers Used Facebook to Keep Women and Older Workers f... by shkkmo on Monday September 30, 2019 @12:01AM (#21111687)
> How is that relevant though?

It is not. Your intent to discriminate is not necessary for you to fall afoul of US equal opportunity laws. Demonstrating disparate impact of your employment policies on a protected class without a valid business is can be sufficient for you to lose your case.

Re:Employers Used Facebook to Keep Women and Older Workers f... by dlp211 on Sunday September 29, 2019 @07:36PM (#21110369)
Facebook is way more like a newspaper than a target demo periodical but even when you put the Ad in Cosmo, you pay for the Ad impression no matter who views the Ad. You, as the advertiser have no control over that impression.
Re:Employers Used Facebook to Keep Women and Older Workers f... by caf on Sunday September 29, 2019 @09:07PM (#21110879)
If it were common for, say, nursing positions to be advertised in Cosmo, then presumably male nurses looking for work would know this and be able to buy that magazine.
Re:Employers Used Facebook to Keep Women and Older Workers f... by SpicyLemonZest on Sunday September 29, 2019 @07:05PM (#21110206)
When you're discriminating illegally, it doesn't usually matter whether it's possible for someone to subvert your discrimination.
Re:Employers Used Facebook to Keep Women and Older Workers f... by air7 on Sunday September 29, 2019 @07:05PM (#21110205)
While true, its a bit of a nitpick and misses the point GP made.
Re:Employers Used Facebook to Keep Women and Older Workers f... by nkrisc on Sunday September 29, 2019 @07:22PM (#21110290)
No. If you place an ad on Facebook for housing and choose to exclude people who identify as "black", there's no way for those people to find your ad, save for creating a new Facebook account and pretending to be white.

Anyone is welcome to purchase a copy of Ebony magazine. It's targeted, but it's not exclusive.

Re:Employers Used Facebook to Keep Women and Older Workers f... by sturgill on Sunday September 29, 2019 @07:57PM (#21110486)
But should Ebony be allowed to market ads on Facebook and exclude white people? I honestly don’t know where I come down on this issue: it feels different to say, “we have a better ROI if we exclude certain demographics from seeing our ads” than to say “black people can’t eat at this diner.”

Let’s take a company like REI: is it wrong for them to put their stores in places that are most profitable? Should luxury good companies be required to have store fronts in inner cities?

I’m legitimately not sure I’m comfortable with either answer. “Women / older people are unlikely to respond to this ad; so we’ll have a better ROI by excluding those groups” feels awkward but like a legitimate business interest. If I sell male hygiene products can I exclude women from seeing the ads, not because I don’t like women but because the ad is less likely to be relevant?

“I don’t want to work with women or older people so I’ll not show them the ad” feels unquestionably wrong.

Re:Employers Used Facebook to Keep Women and Older Workers f... by nkrisc on Sunday September 29, 2019 @08:03PM (#21110514)
The short answer is: it depends. I don't think you'll run into much trouble in excluding women from your ads for beard care products, but you might of you're excluding them from your ads for housing.

I think you have to consider intent as well as outcome.

Re:Employers Used Facebook to Keep Women and Older Workers f... by scarface74 on Sunday September 29, 2019 @10:18PM (#21111214)
There is no might there are specific laws governing advertising when it comes to jobs and housing that don’t apply to other areas.
Re:Employers Used Facebook to Keep Women and Older Workers f... by nl on Sunday September 29, 2019 @11:33PM (#21111575)
Magazine buyer's aren't a protected class.
Re:Employers Used Facebook to Keep Women and Older Workers f... by avani on Sunday September 29, 2019 @10:23PM (#21111238)
Um.. I think most luxury goods stores are in inner cities.
Re:Employers Used Facebook to Keep Women and Older Workers f... by yawaramin on Sunday September 29, 2019 @08:33PM (#21110707)
> But should Ebony be allowed to market ads on Facebook and exclude white people?

That's not what this thread is about. The question here is what is the difference between advertising on Facebook and excluding some demographics, and advertising in a paper magazine where you don't have the power to exclude anyone from viewing the ad.

Re:Employers Used Facebook to Keep Women and Older Workers f... by zaroth on Sunday September 29, 2019 @07:52PM (#21110460)
Is it really any better to make people choose just really good proxies for their intended audience which theoretically anyone could be a member of but in practice is not that way?

And if this isn’t really any better, where does that leave you?

Re:Employers Used Facebook to Keep Women and Older Workers f... by nkrisc on Sunday September 29, 2019 @07:58PM (#21110489)
Where else would you draw the line? I don't think what I described is a real problem in practice. Housing and jobs are often advertised in rather neutral publications, not special interest ones. But what Facebook enables goes beyond targeting based on interest, it's explicitly exclusionary.

If your local newspaper could print a special edition for minority subscribers that didn't include job listings, that would be a problem. Advertising in a special interest publication is not, on its own, a problem. Of course there's no clear lines in reality, everything must be evaluated in context.

Re:Employers Used Facebook to Keep Women and Older Workers f... by Barrin92 on Sunday September 29, 2019 @07:19PM (#21110270)
not really, because people are aware of the fact that they're going to find say, women targeted ads in cosmo, so they can seek them out. The 'discrimination' in this case is simply aggregate consumer preference, every individual outlier still gets precisely the content and ads they want.

If facebook displays housing ads only to white people a black person is very likely not even aware that they're being discriminated against in some specific way, the entire control is in the hands of facebook and the ad buyer, and intransparent.

The situation would be equivalent if facebook gave you complete control over their algorithm and let you choose what type of ads you want to be exposed to. Which would make discrimination much less of an issue. Or the other way around, the current facebook situation would be akin to the store owner quickly cutting the housing ads out of cosmo as soon as black people walk into the store.

Re:Employers Used Facebook to Keep Women and Older Workers f... by Lukeas14 on Monday September 30, 2019 @04:09PM (#21119228)
I think that's the main reason why buying an ad in Cosmo is different from buying a targeted Facebook ad in terms of discrimination. Cosmo might be written with women in mind but anybody can go and buy it. But it's pretty much impossible for someone who identifies as a man on Facebook to see ads that are only targeted towards women. The Facebook example is more similar to a real estate agent who only shows certain properties to white families.
Re:Employers Used Facebook to Keep Women and Older Workers f... by anigbrowl on Sunday September 29, 2019 @07:02PM (#21110187)
You hire people through ads in Cosmo? I doubt that.
Re:Employers Used Facebook to Keep Women and Older Workers f... by SpicyLemonZest on Sunday September 29, 2019 @07:08PM (#21110221)
I don't think the original comment was asking about employment discrimination specifically. I've seen a lot of people get confused on this topic, and end up thinking it's illegal to discriminate by gender on any advertising at all.
[dead]
Re:Employers Used Facebook to Keep Women and Older Workers f... by big_chungus on Sunday September 29, 2019 @10:32PM (#21111297)
Not really, because it's a question of principle: is it okay to target to a specific demographic, or not; and does that vary based on whether we are discussing a legally-protected class? The significance of what is being advertised doesn't exactly change the definition of right and wrong. If we're being honest, cosmo is probably as accurate a filtering mechanism for white, middle-aged, middle-class women as facebook could be.

The issue seems to be when people _exclude_ certain groups, rather than when people _target_ specific ones; i.e. I can filter for middle-aged white guys for testosterone-boosting pills, but most would balk at filtering _out_ blacks, young people, etc. for rental ads. The question is, is there an ethical difference, and why? I think all of us can agree that a cosmo ad for women is fine, and tossing out a black guy's resume is not; the question is where is that line, and why? These sorts of technologies are bringing us closer to either side, so it's relevant to figure out where it is.

Re:Employers Used Facebook to Keep Women and Older Workers f... by shkkmo on Sunday September 29, 2019 @11:00PM (#21111424)
> The significance of what is being advertised doesn't exactly change the definition of right and wrong.

We are discussing legality and yes, what is being advertised has a significant impact. The rules around employment and housing are VERY different from the rules around makeup and viagra.

> The issue seems to be when people _exclude_ certain groups, rather than when people _target_ specific ones;

Nope, both are illegal (for protected classes) when it comes to housing and employment.

Re:Employers Used Facebook to Keep Women and Older Workers f... by kjs3 on Sunday September 29, 2019 @10:56PM (#21111405)
Quit conflating the issue.

The poster you're defending (and, frankly, the whole argument) was trying to make the point that "targeted ads", as a category and devoid of context, was a good thing because you reach the target you want to reach. Fair enough. But if it's an employment ad, and you only want to reach upper class white males, well, that's discrimination. Period. If your "principles" enable that, well there you go.

Re:Employers Used Facebook to Keep Women and Older Workers f... by big_chungus on Sunday September 29, 2019 @11:13PM (#21111483)
Conflating the issue with what?

Let's take the flip side. Pretend I am one of the many companies which have adopted discriminatory hiring practices in favor of certain minorities. I want to hire more of said minorities. I target facebook ads towards them. Is that any better or worse? As far as I'm concerned, they are the same; but many people I know would say that's fine.

Re:Employers Used Facebook to Keep Women and Older Workers f... by shkkmo on Sunday September 29, 2019 @11:53PM (#21111649)
> Pretend I am one of the many companies which have adopted discriminatory hiring practices in favor of certain minorities. I want to hire more of said minorities.

Yup, that is illegal. Discriminating based on protected classes is illegal, regardless of which groups within that class you are discriminating for/against.

>> For example, an employer's reliance on word-of-mouth recruitment by its mostly Hispanic work force may violate the law if the result is that almost all new hires are Hispanic. [0]

[0] https://www.eeoc.gov//laws/practices/

Re:Employers Used Facebook to Keep Women and Older Workers f... by kjs3 on Sunday September 29, 2019 @11:19PM (#21111516)
"I've been given advantage for decades/centuries. We're giving an advantage to the disadvantaged so they have a chance to catch up for years/months. I'm being discriminated against!". Got it.
Re:Employers Used Facebook to Keep Women and Older Workers f... by big_chungus on Monday September 30, 2019 @12:50AM (#21111864)
People today have not been given such advantages. Example: let's say I'm a poor white guy from Appalachia. Will you really tell me I have been given advatages for centuries? When you hire normally, you can somewhat absolve yourself of concern for personal situation; you judge based on emperical information as presented by the candidate. When you play God and take it upon yourself to be the judge, you are morally responsible for discovering everything about some one's life and weighing each impartially against the other. How arrogant must one be to believe himself capable of such a judgement; the judgement not of one resume against another, but of one soul against another? If we could evaluate people's whole selves; we would not have resumes, nor references, nor interviews.
Re:Employers Used Facebook to Keep Women and Older Workers f... by eropple on Monday September 30, 2019 @01:55AM (#21112124)
> Example: let's say I'm a poor white guy from Appalachia. Will you really tell me I have been given advatages for centuries?

Yes. That you happen to be poor, in that situation, does not obviate the cultural and sociodynamic power, in this country, from being white. And it's those advantages that just--for example--mean that if you are walking on a dark street in a city at night, a cop is orders of magnitude less likely to stop you and ask "hey, boy, what are you doing out so late?". That you might be poor, of course, is a reason why you are not as culturally or sociodynamically powerful as a middle-class or a rich white man, or maybe even a rich--gasp!--black man. But that white skin is an implicit handicap in your (and, as it happens, my) favor, even if other accidents of birth or providence happen to stack up on the other side. And it is downright immoral not to acknowledge it.

"Play god"--hogwash and worse words. Acknowledge structural imbalances. Poverty is one. Racism in a country that makes racists powerful is another, and it's bigger, and it's multiplicative with the aforementioned poverty in the first place.

And while we're being real about this, it is also worth noting that the historical fear of being "lesser than the black man" is one of the sadder causes of poor whites aligning with rich whites against the poor whites' economic and social interests--that is, the racial fear and resentment helps keep them poor. "Racial unity of poor whites with their economic exploiters" is a pretty good one-line summary of the post-Colonial American South in general, now that I think about it.