Re:Grumman X-29: An impossible fighter jet with inverted wings
by Gibbon1 on Sunday September 29, 2019 @03:27PM
(#21109130)
> This causes the wing root to stall before the tip, which allows a pilot to maintain control as the onset of stall appears.
I think I've read and been told that also you want the root where the flaps are to stall before the middle where the ailerons are. Because stalling and losing your aileron control during a turn is bad news.
Re:Grumman X-29: An impossible fighter jet with inverted wings
by Gravityloss on Sunday September 29, 2019 @04:26PM
(#21109417)
If one of your wing tips stalls, you will have a very fast roll and there is a high probability of entering a spin.
Also if a part of the wing that is far aft stalls, then that can cause pitchup, making the stall worse.
An aircraft with benign behavior stalls so that the nose stays pointing straight ahead with no roll or yaw but it drops (pitch).
Re:Grumman X-29: An impossible fighter jet with inverted wings
by na85 on Sunday September 29, 2019 @07:33PM
(#21110344)
The loss of aileron control isn't hugely dangerous in and of itself. What's dangerous is the incipient spin. There is a yaw-roll coupling in most aircraft such that you can use the rudder to bank if you have to, even with zero aileron authority.
Using a forward-swept wing causes the spanwise (along the wing's length) flow to be net inward, rather than outward which is the case in a conventional aircraft. With the right mix of composite materials to control aeroelastic twist this causes a similar effect to washout wherein the wing root will stall before the tips, but greatly reduces wingtip vortices and thus reduces total aerodynamic drag. As someone else pointed out, you also get an induced drag benefit because both the canards and main wings are producing upward moments, so the total magnitude of lift force required for a given weight is less.
The "so what?" of all that is it lets you build a smaller, faster, more agile aircraft at the cost of significantly increased aerodynamic and control complexity.