Unemployment had been steadily declining for like 6 years before the tax cut. You can't just attribute the continuing drop in the U3 rate to the tax cuts.
The decrease in unemployment has gotten slower since the last huge tax cuts so you can't even use it as an example of "maybe it worked, its hard to say".
Unemployment is 3.7%, which is pretty closest to the lowest ever observed figures (other than during World War 2). How much faster can it drop?
Economists will always be the people policy-makers turn to, because they are the only people who actually try to understand the economy. Economists sometimes try to advance an agenda (and the actual economist varies by person), but the alternative is to turn to someone who only has an agenda.