Your reasoning isn't flawed but one big reason why I still write some checks is this: they're accepted as payment for free by the receiver where most electronic methods are charged. For example, my apartment's management company charges me $12.95 for a one-off direct debit payment, $6.95/payment for an automatic recurring debit payment, $32.50 for a payment made by debit card, or a whopping $109.55 for a payment made by credit card.
(This means that the free--or at least "included in my rent"--payment option is for me to write a physical check and put it in the night drop box the day before rent is due and then their employees have to deal with the check, as opposed to the computers handling it all. Since the night drop is right there on my way out the door, the convenience factor is still high for me.)
I don't like checks but I flatly refuse to pay money to pay a bill. If I owe you money, you will figure out how to accept it in a way that doesn't cost me more. What I owe is already figured into the balance; charging me more to hand you money is obnoxious. My apartment company isn't the only company like this so I still hand out about 20 checks per year. Fortunately, my credit union gives me one box of checks for free every year and I only use less than one book of them per year so there's no added cost there, too.
It's mind-boggling that this is cheaper and lower hassle for me than the alternatives.
Yes, I could leave sufficient money in that account to deal with it but I send most of my paycheck to savings and retirement accounts that earn much better interest than the paltry 0.05% my credit union's checking account gives me. Plus, the walk is good for my health.
I assume the deal is that an outside service sets up these things for municipalities for "free" but they take a cut so the person paying the bill pays for the free service.
And it's not just monetary charges. It's also a desire to not demonstrate consent when I'm blasted with a CAPTCHA. The instant I get a CAPTCHA, I reflexively hit Ctrl-W to close the tab and either (1) take my business elsewhere or (2) mail a check in.
It's especially infuriating when they wait to hit me with a CAPTCHA at the very end of the process, after I've already copied over account numbers and other information from the paper bill they sent me. I'll find any way I can to waste the time of that company's employees at that point.
If you have a better means of stopping automated fraud, you could make yourself a tidy amount of money...
Checks are far less risky for the payment receiver, it’s much more difficult dispute it and yank the money back.
The apartment staff would not take a check...and there was no posted mailing address to send it too either. There was no way to pay the bill except to also pay them a fee. I hated that just on principle the entire time i stayed there, and is, in fact, my biggest complaint about that apartment complex (which otherwise was a delight to live in)
However I know some phone and satellite tv companies give you a tiny discount if you pay online. Also another thing that annoys me, with satellite radio in the car apparently you can't cancel online. You have to call and be put on hold and then they try to retain you. Seems so unfriendly, I know they don't want people to quit but people sell cars, etc... and knowing that it makes me kinda not want to signup in the first place on a new car, but it is a nice service at least using it.
They he set up some form of electronic payment that took something like 1.5% of the amount paid; it seemed to be largely ignored because paying extra $20-30 feels like more expense than spend time to write and mail the check.
By now the landlord set up another electronic payment system that takes a fixed $2.99 fee for the transaction. I've never written him a paper check since then.
So, if you want to not walk to the bank with a wad of checks, find a payment provider with a right price.
I used to do ACH transfers since those were free at the last place I rented. The management company only charged a $3 debit/credit card fee...
My first paycheck from my first summer job in high school was a check, and my severance from my last company was by check. Other than that, it's all been electronic. My previous three jobs don't allow regular paychecks by physical check, you have to have direct deposit. Physical paychecks are definitely the exception, not the norm.
There's also a lot of resistance to electronic banking in... certain circles. I'm not sure what they think "normal" banking when you speak to an actual teller is.
Where? Everywhere I've banked offered checking accounts for completely free with no minimum balance, and I know many credit unions operate this way. If you're paying money to your bank, stop it.
> Add to that the fact that many banks purposely reorder transactions to force you to take as many overdraft fees as possible, banking for those living paycheck to paycheck is not cheap
This is really scummy but many banks allow you to, for debit cards, deny the transaction instead of overdrafting. That won't help with bounced checks or electronic transfers but it can make a big difference.
Most major banks in the US require something if not a minimum balance to waive the monthly fee. Something like $x threshold for certain direct deposits, or you're a student/young adult, or you use your debit card x times a month.
Smaller banks and credit unions can have problems too: locations or lack of participating ATMs or the same problems as the big banks. There are absolutely scenarios where it can be easier (time and money-wise) to just go to the check cashing store.
Some unbanked people are undocumented and afraid to open accounts that might be closed/seized. Some have piss poor credit. Some of those folx won't be able to open new accounts because their chexsystems report has some negative item on it. A single issue like your car breaking down once can snowball into a much bigger situation.
> deny the transaction instead of overdrafting
Honestly, for paycheck to paycheck folx, this can still hurt. There won't be $200 in overdraft fees, but imagine, your PG&E bill is now past due because they couldn't charge your card. Now they want $20 for reconnection on top of the past due bill and 2x more in the form of a deposit due to bad credit. Welp, maybe the $200 in overdraft fees would have been easier to deal with.
Living paycheck to paycheck sucks for so many reasons, and so many of those reasons out of the individual's control.
In the USA as of 2017, 8.4 million households (6.5% of households) don't have any bank account. [1]
That's an odd way to phrase it, since it doesn't seem like a particularly large sample as you state it. So how many individuals are you talking about, given your turnover?
So I walked a $300K check from my bank two blocks to my escrow company to save the $50. The check must have been more expensive for everyone to handle (even at the bank, they had to wait for a manager to operate the special "check typewriter" - not everyone was allowed to operate it), but for whatever reason, it was "free".
Also MyPayrollHR did have direct deposit:
> This communique came after employees at companies that depend on MyPayrollHR to receive direct deposits of their bi-weekly payroll payments discovered their bank accounts were instead debited for the amounts they would normally expect to accrue in a given pay period.
https://krebsonsecurity.com/2019/09/ny-payroll-company-vanis...
US banking is a decrepit mess because the treasury allows it to be.
And no one in the US has problems sending and receiving money from anyone else in the US either...
The parent's point is that legacy systems still exist in the US, as I'm sure they do in the EU. That doesn't mean that getting paid by a paper check is particularly common for regular workers. The vast majority of people are paid electronically. No one likes dealing with checks and for the most part no one really has to. The only times I ever do that is when I'm paying a contractor many thousands of dollars for e.g., work on my house. Usually those guys are older and self-employed, and either don't know how to accept money electronically or don't want to because of fees (and I don't blame them). In those instances I get a cashier's check made. That's the only time I have to deal with it.
There are of course instances where an employer might not provide direct deposit because they find the added expense too much to bear (as another poster pointed out). We're not living 50 years in the past, as you might imagine. Checks are not particularly common.
And the actual point is that no, they don't, they were cleared away because their existence is a pox on everyone.
Having seen both systems upclose, for the average consumer the European banking system is about a hundred years in the future from the American one, which is a steaming hot cesspit of legacy systems and banking institutions that spend all their time figuring out ways to milk more money out of consumers.
Case in point:
> or don't want to because of fees
It's not okay to charge people fees to send or receive money.
(Technically, European banks still can do that, but since the EU has forced all banks to accept transfers from each other using a common system, and that all money transfer are executed as "shared fees" where the sender pays the fee to their institution and the receiver pays the fee to theirs, free and open competition has driven the price of sending and receiving money to 0€.)
You’re telling me checks don’t exist in the EU anymore? Forgive me for being skeptical.
> where the sender pays the fee to their institution and the receiver pays the fee to theirs, free and open competition has driven the price of sending and receiving money to 0€.)
You’re gonna have to elaborate, because that sounds like both parties pay money to perform an exchange, which is even worse than what we have, where one party does.
Are you saying that if I wanted to pay someone $100 I have to cough up an additional $5 and the receiving party has to pay $5 to get their $100? In what way is that “no fees” unless the receiving party is reimbursing the paying party directly? Unless I’m missing something here, a transfer of $100 cost $110 under this system.
You pay the fee to your banking organization, which is 0€. The receiver pays the fee to their banking organization, which is also 0€.
Or in other words, there are no fees.
The idea being that the EU has made it very easy to switch banks, and forced a regime where a customer can freely pick the bank that has the lowest fees, which lead to a situation where no bank that wants to retain customers can bill them for transferring money.
They still exist in a couple countries but have completely disappeared in most. When wire transfers are free to consumers and cost cents to business account holders, why would anyone use something else?
I worked in a bank for a bunch of years, a decade ago we were processing <100 checks a year, which was an unusual (and expensive) service; about half of the checks was companies doing international sales to unusual countries and the other half was scams; so that business was shut down - some banks do offer a service of cashing checks, but many banks will not.
A wire transfer to an account in another banks is (depending on your bank) either free or something like 0.15-0.30 eur, certainly cheaper than a stamp if one would need to send a paper check.
All of which is disturbing to me now but I was young and dumb and didn't stay with them long.
(A few years earlier, I had an after-school job at K-Mart and they paid everyone with actual cash in an envelope!)
Also, the government no longer sends out physical social security checks, they stopped doing that like five years ago.
They also refuse cash and donation as a settlement, so in the spirit of the deceased I don't cash it, and a new one arrives every six months.
I guess I'll find know the Solicitor has retired when the cheque stops coming...
There are thousands, if not millions, of people doing business like this. When I was shopping around for a home mortgage, a broker that I knew by personal family recommendation had me send tax returns to hername@isp and I, figuring that this stuff could land anywhere regardless of whether the broker operates so sadly, applied AES to the PDF and sent it on over, calling by phone to provide the password. I guarantee 99% of her clients don't bother. And I wouldn't be the least bit surprised to learn that she renamed the saved file on her computer to include the password.
So I don't think anyone is out, right?
I know a while back the local news was talking about this issue and interviewing workers, and some of them were unsure about their money. but sounds like they got it back at least. So sounds like now just a court battle, but at least the individual workers aren't involved in the nightmare directly it looks anymore.
Sounds like it probably was days before putting it back, as they had to call and talk to someone - told them it was a mistake then later yet another disappeared... Then call again, etc... Even a Facebook group was started with many employees who all had the same issue.
Here's the clip https://youtu.be/ELZaXpJiMFU
You can refuse to give it to anyone who doesn't need it for tax purposes. Which is almost everyone. But, this is the stupid part, they can refuse to do business with you on that basis.
Per the article, Cachet Financial Services ended up holding the bag. They tried reversing a bunch of payroll account payments, but ultimately relented. Presumably some of that money will eventually be recovered.
> I don't know why anyone would think they could get away with a fraud this large.
Given the M.O., it's likely that this started small (as most fraud does). He cheated once with a float to cover a shortfall, then started making larger and larger bets. And eventually he lost a bet too large to cover, and had to try cheating in a different and more dangerous way with money in the payroll account, and got caught.
Even if they did put it back, still overdraft fees during that time if someone had a check cashed or automatic payment sent due to those funds being removed.
I don't know why anyone would think they could get away with a fraud this large. I just think this stuff highlights how outdated the banking system is.
I've always hated the idea of checks, I rather the money be gone right away then keeping track of it... Since checks still show on your balance even if not cashed yet. Then checks have your entire account number people could misuse. I have never wrote a check in my life though, but I know my family does for bills but I know more and more places have online bill pay... They trust mailing their entire account info than doing it online.
However I feel both banking and the whole social security number thing needs to be rethought. it's insane you use the same number for everything and you pass it around to employers, contracting jobs freelancing or affiliate programs that pay commissions, credit cards, cable company, satellite tv, cell phone, doctors, dentists, etc. Well I know for doctors and stuff they say you can refuse to give it, but pretty sure they'll give you a hassle for exercising your rights. I know a while back there was some dentist storing patient information in a unsecured FTP account.