News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Roll your own toy UNIX-clone OS by tseabrooks on Saturday January 15, 2011 @08:06PM (#2108287)
My Op Sys class in school was designed around compiling your own toy 'unix' kernel and rewriting large portions of it from scratch for educational reasons. We used the Tanenbaum book and his "Minix" system. It was far and away the most informative class I had in school.
Re:Roll your own toy UNIX-clone OS by derleth on Sunday January 16, 2011 @01:37AM (#2108860)
> We used the Tanenbaum book and his "Minix" system.

The 'problem' with this, if you want to approach it that way, is that Minix is not representative of how most OSes in the real world work: It's a microkernel in a world of monolithic kernels, which means studying it to learn how the rest of the OS world works is a bit like looking at electric engines to figure out how your gas-powered car runs on the inside.

(There's also the jibe that microkernels are the wave of the future, and always will be.)

Re:Roll your own toy UNIX-clone OS by mfukar on Sunday January 16, 2011 @05:33AM (#2109128)
The architecture really doesn't matter, in the context of a course. Understanding concepts like scheduling, filesystems, mm etc. and perhaps tinkering with a reference implementation is more rewarding for beginners, and Minix is simple enough to allow a CS undergrad to get involved rather quickly.
Re:Roll your own toy UNIX-clone OS by derleth on Sunday January 16, 2011 @05:04PM (#2110391)
So, if the architecture really doesn't matter, why not use the Lions' book and teach Sixth Edition Unix, or use "The Design and Implementation of the 4.4BSD Operating System"? Is it a holdover from the 1980s, when microkernels were still interesting, or is it because Tanenbaum is seen as a 'real' academic?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lions%27_Commentary_on_UNIX_6th...

http://www.freebsd.org/doc/en/books/design-44bsd/

Re:Roll your own toy UNIX-clone OS by mfukar on Monday January 17, 2011 @12:45AM (#2111348)
Because Minix is neither overly complex, nor obsolete. It nears the sweet spot between simplicity and functionality - I don't know how much of that I can attribute to its architecture. I don't think it has anything to do with academic credibility or holding grudges.

That's my opinion, of course, and perhaps my CS professors stuck to Tanenbaum religiously.

Re:Roll your own toy UNIX-clone OS by derleth on Thursday January 20, 2011 @01:23AM (#2122888)
> nor obsolete

Minix is so different from most OSes in use that this doesn't even make sense.

Re:Roll your own toy UNIX-clone OS by mfukar on Friday January 21, 2011 @04:59AM (#2126977)
While Minix, like dozens of OSs, is far from having a measurable market share - especially compared to Linux/Windows/BSD/etc - is also far from being either unwanted or disused. It's actively developed and promoted. Why would you characterize it obsolete based on its difference from "mainstream" OSs? That doesn't make sense.
Re:Roll your own toy UNIX-clone OS by derleth on Saturday January 29, 2011 @05:01AM (#2155156)
> Why would you characterize it obsolete based on its difference from "mainstream" OSs?

I didn't. I explicitly said that the concept of 'obsolete' doesn't apply to it, because it's so different from everything else.