Re:Roll your own toy UNIX-clone OS
by mfukar on Sunday January 16, 2011 @05:33AM
(#2109128)
The architecture really doesn't matter, in the context of a course. Understanding concepts like scheduling, filesystems, mm etc. and perhaps tinkering with a reference implementation is more rewarding for beginners, and Minix is simple enough to allow a CS undergrad to get involved rather quickly.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
So, if the architecture really doesn't matter, why not use the Lions' book and teach Sixth Edition Unix, or use "The Design and Implementation of the 4.4BSD Operating System"? Is it a holdover from the 1980s, when microkernels were still interesting, or is it because Tanenbaum is seen as a 'real' academic?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lions%27_Commentary_on_UNIX_6th...
Because Minix is neither overly complex, nor obsolete. It nears the sweet spot between simplicity and functionality - I don't know how much of that I can attribute to its architecture. I don't think it has anything to do with academic credibility or holding grudges.
That's my opinion, of course, and perhaps my CS professors stuck to Tanenbaum religiously.
> nor obsolete
Minix is so different from most OSes in use that this doesn't even make sense.
While Minix, like dozens of OSs, is far from having a measurable market share - especially compared to Linux/Windows/BSD/etc - is also far from being either unwanted or disused. It's actively developed and promoted. Why would you characterize it obsolete based on its difference from "mainstream" OSs? That doesn't make sense.
> Why would you characterize it obsolete based on its difference from "mainstream" OSs?
I didn't. I explicitly said that the concept of 'obsolete' doesn't apply to it, because it's so different from everything else.