News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Match.com Used Fake Ads to Swindle Users, F.T.C. Says by jdm2212 on Thursday September 26, 2019 @12:35AM (#21078206)
I do the same thing with a gmail address -- just do [email protected], because gmail drops everything after the + for routing the email but still tells you which address it was sent to.
Re:Match.com Used Fake Ads to Swindle Users, F.T.C. Says by guessmyname on Thursday September 26, 2019 @12:51AM (#21078277)
I used to do this, but it is troublesome some times because some websites use libraries that strip or replace the plus sign and the final email ends up being an address that you don’t have access to.

Most of the time this is not a problem because you can create the account again with the correct email, but I have lost a few good usernames in some popular websites because I pulled this trick on them, Gravatar is one of these websites and the simplest one to explain.

I wanted a specific username that was available; I signed up with an email that looks like [email protected] and the operation went through, then when I tried to log in, the website kept saying that the email was incorrect. I tried to reset the account using the username instead, which would force them to send a reset link to the email associated to this account, but the emails never arrive. I gave up that and other good usernames in many websites because of the inappropriate handling of email addresses by some popular web libraries.

Also, the same way you learnt this “trick” other programmers discovered it too and implemented a stripping algorithm to remove the unique ID during the registration process, so it is not very useful nowadays unless the website is very obscure and their developers either are rookies or do not have time to prevent this.

Re:Match.com Used Fake Ads to Swindle Users, F.T.C. Says by mikorym on Thursday September 26, 2019 @02:02AM (#21078632)
> are rookies or do not have time

Reputable websites don't have an incentive to strip out the ID. It is only websites like "sold out" dating websites or otherwise nefarious websites that have that incentive in the first place. So, [email protected] is still useful for filtering and indexing, and in fact if a website does strip out the ID you should ask yourself why would they need to do that.

Re:Match.com Used Fake Ads to Swindle Users, F.T.C. Says by masonic on Thursday September 26, 2019 @02:45AM (#21078810)
Any many just fail, assuming '+' is an invalid character
Re:Match.com Used Fake Ads to Swindle Users, F.T.C. Says by Twisell on Thursday September 26, 2019 @03:07AM (#21078899)
I was once at the receiving end of business talk clearly addressed to someone else on my gmail account.

At first I believed it was some scam but it soon got clear that my account was accidentally siphoning mail from someone using this supposedly clever scheme...

Re:Match.com Used Fake Ads to Swindle Users, F.T.C. Says by Splatter on Thursday September 26, 2019 @12:45AM (#21078250)
What's frustrating is that very many sites know of this method and simply trim the "+uniqueid" from a gmail.com address before inserting it into their database.
Re:Match.com Used Fake Ads to Swindle Users, F.T.C. Says by input_sh on Thursday September 26, 2019 @02:09AM (#21078666)
Pay for your email address to solve the problem. On my email provider, I can create a catchall alias: *@example.com will end up in my [email protected] mailbox.

So, instead of doing [email protected], I can do [email protected].

Re:Match.com Used Fake Ads to Swindle Users, F.T.C. Says by systemcluster on Thursday September 26, 2019 @03:05AM (#21078892)
If your email provider does not offer a catchall alias option, this is also achievable with an email forwarder (e.g. mailgun), provided you are ok with giving another service provider access to the content of your received mails.
Re:Match.com Used Fake Ads to Swindle Users, F.T.C. Says by manigandham on Thursday September 26, 2019 @04:34AM (#21079232)
Technically most email is not encrypted so every single mail server in the middle also has access.
Re:Match.com Used Fake Ads to Swindle Users, F.T.C. Says by mavhc on Thursday September 26, 2019 @03:20AM (#21078945)
If only it were possible to encrypt emails, oh well
Re:Match.com Used Fake Ads to Swindle Users, F.T.C. Says by CharlesColeman on Thursday September 26, 2019 @10:47AM (#21081368)
> So, instead of doing [email protected], I can do [email protected].

Fastmail has an interesting variation of this that supports multiple users on the same domain: [email protected]. My wife and I both use that feature heavily on our domain.

Re:Match.com Used Fake Ads to Swindle Users, F.T.C. Says by jdm2212 on Thursday September 26, 2019 @12:50AM (#21078273)
That's a bummer. FWIW there are a fair number of non-gmail domains that are gmail-backed (e.g. a lot of universities' email systems) so it should still work with those consistently I hope.
Re:Match.com Used Fake Ads to Swindle Users, F.T.C. Says by rypskar on Thursday September 26, 2019 @01:34AM (#21078489)
It don't need to be gmail-backed for + to work. I use it on my own domain without any problems and there is no gmail involved
Re:Match.com Used Fake Ads to Swindle Users, F.T.C. Says by __david__ on Thursday September 26, 2019 @02:56AM (#21078847)
On my domain I made _ and . Also work the same as +, for annoying sites that somehow think + is an invalid character for email addresses.
Re:Match.com Used Fake Ads to Swindle Users, F.T.C. Says by solution3982 on Thursday September 26, 2019 @01:19AM (#21078422)
>What's frustrating is that very many sites know of this method and simply trim the "+uniqueid" from a gmail.com address before inserting it into their database.

Unfortunately, there is a mathematical theorem (greater idiot theorem) that makes it technically impossible to generate a new random string that becomes an inbox that goes to your inbox.

How do I know that it's technically impossible?

Because otherwise Gmail would have done it already, since this takes 20 minutes and fixes a glaring security issue that gives spammers access to your email that you didn't grant.

I can't have an IQ 50 points higher than all Gmail engineers, so it must stand to reason that I'm the greater idiot. Hence there must be something preventing this obvious solution. QED.

Re:Match.com Used Fake Ads to Swindle Users, F.T.C. Says by hmate9 on Thursday September 26, 2019 @01:27AM (#21078458)
Wait, isn’t this exactly what Apple is doing with Sign in with Apple?
Re:Match.com Used Fake Ads to Swindle Users, F.T.C. Says by solution3982 on Thursday September 26, 2019 @01:57AM (#21078597)
yes. But that doesn't mean it's possible, or Gmail would be doing it too. they have PhD's and stuff. (or used to).

so for sure it isn't possible for some reason, even if someone else is doing it.

what other explanation can there be? why would they just have a glaring security hole like that, allowing anyone you try to give a trackable email to with + to just remove it with a regex? It doesn't make sense. there must be some reason it can't work.

Re:Match.com Used Fake Ads to Swindle Users, F.T.C. Says by maimeowmeow on Thursday September 26, 2019 @02:07AM (#21078653)
Because there is a top tier spam filter that is powered by the ai, and cloud computers? qed qft
Re:Match.com Used Fake Ads to Swindle Users, F.T.C. Says by nothrabannosir on Thursday September 26, 2019 @03:17AM (#21078931)
Outlook and Apple already offer this service, it’s not impossible.

The + need not have been intended as a spam filter; I use it for bona fide filtering of separate clients’ projects.

Re:Match.com Used Fake Ads to Swindle Users, F.T.C. Says by dmarlow on Thursday September 26, 2019 @12:40AM (#21078225)
I used to do this, but I kept forgetting the "uniqueid" for the sites I used. I'd often resort to using my regular email for the forget password prompts and then would have to search my inbox to figure out the correct email (if using from another device where the creds aren't saved).
Re:Match.com Used Fake Ads to Swindle Users, F.T.C. Says by inetknght on Thursday September 26, 2019 @12:50AM (#21078270)
Today that problem is solved by the use of a password manager.
Re:Match.com Used Fake Ads to Swindle Users, F.T.C. Says by newnewpdro on Thursday September 26, 2019 @01:12AM (#21078380)
Unfortunately, being part of the standard, it's become fairly common to strip this from email addresses.

It's more effective to have an entire domain at your disposal and just invent [email protected] whenever an email address is needed. On the server end all you need is a catchall to handle it, and you can blackhole whatever addresses become spam magnets (while also knowing which vendor's responsible).

Re:Match.com Used Fake Ads to Swindle Users, F.T.C. Says by __david__ on Thursday September 26, 2019 @03:04AM (#21078884)
It is not part of any standard. + is a valid email address character and is not special in any way.
Re:Match.com Used Fake Ads to Swindle Users, F.T.C. Says by newnewpdro on Thursday September 26, 2019 @03:23AM (#21078956)
It's specified in RFC5233 [0], by "standard" I meant codified in RFC form, like everything else we treat as open internet "standards".

[0] https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc5233

Re:Match.com Used Fake Ads to Swindle Users, F.T.C. Says by hdfbdtbcdg on Thursday September 26, 2019 @03:38AM (#21079009)
> On email systems that allow for 'subaddressing' or 'detailed addressing' (e.g., "[email protected]"),

This rfc merely acknowledges that some systems do this. It doesn't say the must or even should.

Re:Match.com Used Fake Ads to Swindle Users, F.T.C. Says by pseudalopex on Thursday September 26, 2019 @03:30AM (#21078980)
RFC 5223 uses + as an example. It doesn't even specify whether the detail part comes before or after the user part.
Re:Match.com Used Fake Ads to Swindle Users, F.T.C. Says by dvfjsdhgfv on Thursday September 26, 2019 @01:58AM (#21078604)
This used to work a decade ago when spammers were clueless.
Re:Match.com Used Fake Ads to Swindle Users, F.T.C. Says by albertgoeswoof on Thursday September 26, 2019 @04:38AM (#21079255)
This is ok but many sites strip the plus now (usually the most nefarious ones). Plus you’re linking your identity back to your gmail account which is probably not what you want to do on a dating site or in general online.

I wrote about this here: https://idbloc.co/blog/background/2019/04/14/keep-your-addre... and it’s one of the main reasons https://idbloc.co exists