News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ultraprocessed Foods – A New Theory of Obesity by cj on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @06:14PM (#21076169)
Another anecdote: I went completely vegan ~3 months ago. I don't really "feel better". It's always the first thing someone asks when I say I went vegan.. "Do you feel better?" - I feel basically the same.

Although my weight has been trending downward, slowly, which is great since that's happening without trying to limit the amount I eat at all. That's very different from when I wasn't vegan, my weight would always trend slowly upward unless I was making a deliberate effort to cut back on calories.

BUT: I think the real reason I'm slowly losing weight on a vegan diet is the simple fact that eating a restricted diet (ANY restricted diet) requires you to think about and analyze absolutely everything that enters your mouth. It introduces a level of mindfulness that just wasn't there when eating an unrestricted diet. For me, this has had the side effect of also cutting out most processed food (read: junk food) from my diet, even though most junk food is vegan. I'm convinced this is the biggest value of being vegan.. it just makes you think about everything you buy at the grocery store, everything you order when out to eat, etc.

Another commenter calls this "paying attention to what you eat" - I think that's right on target, however cliche it may sound.

Re:Ultraprocessed Foods – A New Theory of Obesity by avinium on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @06:55PM (#21076494)
I consider myself a seasoned dieter (meaning I can manipulate my weight +/-10kg fairly easily). Over at least a dozen weight cuts/bulks, the most effective practice I've found is writing a meal plan, and writing down everything you put in your mouth.

Many people have started losing weight just by doing this - without actively changing their diet. It has a really profound subconscious impact on what/how much you put in your mouth.

The psychological/hormonal aspect of food is fascinating.

Re:Ultraprocessed Foods – A New Theory of Obesity by 11235813213455 on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @07:27PM (#21076683)
my weight is probably going +/-6kg, on a semi-week basis. When I eat, I eat a lot (fruits at will, legumes, fish vapor-cooked, honey, Camargues rice living in France, lentils). I think it's useless to weight yourself, it's easy to feel how much fat you've built, you then need to consume it first before re-eating (I'm around 60-62kg, 1.83m, with a thin morphology so it's not underweight)

I feel really well with that "lower-frequency" diet cycle, it's of course easier when working remote.

Re:Ultraprocessed Foods – A New Theory of Obesity by m0zg on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @10:09PM (#21077498)
+/- 6kg is basically water. 1kg of fat is 8800kcal - 4 days of average adult's caloric intake. There's no way to lose 6kg in a week unless what you've lost is almost entirely water.
Re:Ultraprocessed Foods – A New Theory of Obesity by bo1024 on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @11:22PM (#21077871)
It's not very likely to happen with water either. 6kg of water is 6 liters, which is probably more than the amount of blood in their body. I have to question the measurements on the 6kg fluctuations, going from 60kg to 54kg in a week is serious.
Re:Ultraprocessed Foods – A New Theory of Obesity by ddeck on Thursday September 26, 2019 @12:56AM (#21078305)
That's true, but there is a lot of water in the body aside from the blood.

While most people will feel physical effects after losing 5% of their body weight in water, many can lose up to 8-10% without significant adverse physical or mental impact. Loss over 10% is considered serious dehydration.

World champion marathon runner Haile Gebrselassie famously won the Dubai marathon in 2005 with a 10% body weight loss during the race:

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22450589

Re:Ultraprocessed Foods – A New Theory of Obesity by avinium on Thursday September 26, 2019 @01:47AM (#21078558)
It's pretty common to cut 5-10kg in preparation for wrestling/judo competitions.

A natural 6kg fluctuation isn't inconceivable. I'm fairly sure I could get there starting dehydrated/carb-depleted and pounding a carb-heavy meal with a lot of fluids.

It definitely wouldn't be accidental, though.

Re:Ultraprocessed Foods – A New Theory of Obesity by m0zg on Thursday September 26, 2019 @04:02AM (#21079094)
Cutting for competitions involves diuretics though. They literally piss out the weight to end up in their target weight bracket.
Re:Ultraprocessed Foods – A New Theory of Obesity by hombre_fatal on Thursday September 26, 2019 @12:06AM (#21078051)
I've fluctuated about that much in 48 hours just going from eating a lot of food constantly -> fasting (no food, no water). Think about all the food and liquid you can pack into your stomach and intestines.

Seems crazy, but try it. I went from like 180lbs to low 160s. Of course, it comes back when you start eating and drinking again.

Re:Ultraprocessed Foods – A New Theory of Obesity by _carl_jung on Thursday September 26, 2019 @04:48AM (#21079291)
This isn't what people typically mean when they talk about weight loss, though. Which is why normally you hear recommendations for measuring your weight at the same time every day with an assumption that your eating patterns are roughly constant.
Re:Ultraprocessed Foods – A New Theory of Obesity by dragonelite on Thursday September 26, 2019 @04:03AM (#21079099)
This, i find i can lose like around 2.5kg by fasting 2 days 1.5kg is usually water weight and 0.5 kg feels like food mass and the other 0.5kg fat loss. The water and food mass weight will come back once you start eating again.
Re:Ultraprocessed Foods – A New Theory of Obesity by jbarberu on Thursday September 26, 2019 @09:37AM (#21080753)
- "I managed to strip 60kg off my race car"

- "Wow, how did you manage that??"

- "I just emptied the gas tank!"

Re:Ultraprocessed Foods – A New Theory of Obesity by 11235813213455 on Thursday September 26, 2019 @03:51AM (#21079062)
I'll try to measure it, it's something like 58-59kg, after a long bike ride the sunday and 64-65kg after eating - I buy 10-12kg of fruits/legumes twice a week - so yes it's 80% water
Re:Ultraprocessed Foods – A New Theory of Obesity by xzel on Thursday September 26, 2019 @01:44AM (#21078540)
Not to be gross but the colon can hold a lot of weight until you empty it. It could be a mix of that and water.
Re:Ultraprocessed Foods – A New Theory of Obesity by wastedhours on Thursday September 26, 2019 @04:20AM (#21079176)
Completely agree - but as a counter point too, this for me also led to anorexia (not going vegan, but a restricted, over-analysed diet). I changed my diet and started monitoring and analysing everything, combined with what must've been a vulnerable mental state, meant I couldn't rationalise eating anything. I'm talking under 700 calories a day for months on end.

One minute you're being mindful about your intake, the next you're stood paralysed in the chilled aisle physically unable to choose a meal as they're all "so bad".

If you're in tip-top mental health, then restricted diets can work. But for anyone reading who's dealing with proper body image or any other food related issues - just be careful please.

Re:Ultraprocessed Foods – A New Theory of Obesity by tripzilch on Saturday September 28, 2019 @07:19AM (#21099745)
I've heard this called orthorexia instead of anorexia. I hope you're doing better :)
Re:Ultraprocessed Foods – A New Theory of Obesity by yc-kraln on Thursday September 26, 2019 @02:49AM (#21078823)
About a year ago I started being hypervigilant on my food intake: Three meals a day, no snacks, take a picture of everything. No other restrictions. In the past year I've lost 75 pounds...
Re:Ultraprocessed Foods – A New Theory of Obesity by heroHACK17 on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @08:28PM (#21077013)
> BUT: I think the real reason I'm slowly losing weight on a vegan diet is the simple fact that eating a restricted diet (ANY restricted diet) requires you to think about and analyze absolutely everything that enters your mouth.

SO true. It's all about altering those marginal decisions that add up to something noticeable.

Re:Ultraprocessed Foods – A New Theory of Obesity by batiudrami on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @09:54PM (#21077445)
When I went vegetarian ~4 years ago I didn't feel noticably better either. But I eat meat when I go overseas - and after a week meat one or two meals a day I feel properly rubbish.

Being vegetarian has made my weight much easier to manage too - which is a helpful additional benefit.

Re:Ultraprocessed Foods – A New Theory of Obesity by top_kekeroni_m8 on Thursday September 26, 2019 @06:20AM (#21079677)
How are you vegetarian if you still eat meat occasionally?
Re:Ultraprocessed Foods – A New Theory of Obesity by loco5niner on Thursday September 26, 2019 @03:51PM (#21084800)
part-time vegetarian based on location (maybe has family overseas or something).

Sounds legit to me.

Re:Ultraprocessed Foods – A New Theory of Obesity by batiudrami on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @08:25PM (#21132339)
Yeah. I have cut my meat intake by 99%+ - and for simplicity I describe myself as a vegetarian. But if I am overseas I will order a vegetarian menu option if there is one but I'm not going to drag my friends across town to find somewhere I know will suit me, so sometimes it means ordering a meat dish, especially in east-Asian countries.

It depends on the country, and sometimes city, of course.