News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Brain research on boys’ preference for video games and gi... by whatshisface on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @05:10PM (#21064671)
All of the games I played as a kid were clearly designed for boys and young men (featuring all of the typical things like guns and heavy machinery that men are well known to like more than women). That's just how the market was. If it's like that today, then it is no wonder that boys exhibit signs of enjoying video games more.
Re:Brain research on boys’ preference for video games and gi... by derefr on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @05:16PM (#21064718)
There are plenty of games "for girls" (the hidden-object and life-simulation genres are almost exclusively consumed by women, regardless of theming) but they're not marketed with quite the high-budget superbowl ad-campaign effort that games "for boys" are.

I've encountered the situation many times where I'll find out one of my female friends doesn't play video games. I'll ask why, and—disregarding the people who just don't like to spend time cooped up indoors—it'll usually end out that she's just never been introduced to a game she's enjoyed. Upon introducing her to a game or two in the genres more traditionally targeted at women, she'll be just about as likely as any of my male friends to gradually evolve from there into an avid gamer: one for whom "gaming" is now counted among their serious hobbies; one who might be excited to dedicate a weekend to full "hardcore" engagement with a new game.

In other words, for these ladies, it was 100% a market education problem: the companies making these products weren't managing to make their target audience aware of them.

Re:Brain research on boys’ preference for video games and gi... by dublinben on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @05:44PM (#21064951)
According to some random infographic¹, over 60% of the mobile gaming demographic is female. This kind of game is absolutely being advertised during the Super Bowl. They're just not on the radar of "hardcore" gamers who tend to look down on console and especially mobile players.

¹https://mediakix.com/blog/mobile-gaming-industry-statistics-...

Re:Brain research on boys’ preference for video games and gi... by derefr on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @05:54PM (#21065030)
I didn't want to get into it, but I would like to make a distinction, that I hope should be obvious in retrospect, and is different from the usual "casual"/"hardcore" distinction:

Some people play games; but some other people are only addicted to spending money on slot machines. The kind of mobile "game" you see Super Bowl ads (or, really, any TV ads) for are almost exclusively actually just slot machines at their core, with any game mechanics being tacked-on afterthoughts.

(If you wouldn't let your own children play a given "game", and your intuitive reasoning is the same as why you wouldn't let them wander freely in a casino—then you probably should mark such titles down under the "casino" tally, not the "games" tally, no?)

Importantly, the audiences for these two types of... experiences, let's call them—are mostly non-overlapping sets of people. Plenty of people are addicted to these slot-machine apps but would never play an actual "game", no matter how casual it was. They're not in it for game-mechanical "fun"; they're in it for variable-scheduled dopaminergic rewards. And, vice-versa, the more of an experienced "gamer" someone is—the more actual games they've played (where even FarmVille with all its dark patterns is still a game)—the more they'll have a taste for actual fun brought about by game mechanics, and so the more clearly they can intuitively feel that these slot-machine apps aren't providing such "fun."

Once you take these slot-machine non-games and their mostly non-gamer audiences out of consideration, then things do line up the way I described: there are no game companies targeting women bothering to spend much on advertising.

(There are, however, plenty of games without gendered targeting that have AAA ad spend. Pokemon, for example.)

Re:Brain research on boys’ preference for video games and gi... by throwawawathrow on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @05:54PM (#21065026)
Yeah as I alluded to in this thread I believe most gamers have been female for some time, but somehow for many people (read: many men) they don't 'count' because they're mobile games, or casual games, or not real games. At least that's the responses I've got every time the subject came up in previous discussions.
Re:Brain research on boys’ preference for video games and gi... by univerio on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @05:49PM (#21064991)
I assume an example of a "life-simulation" game is the Sims? What are "hidden-object" games?
Re:Brain research on boys’ preference for video games and gi... by thrower123 on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @06:00PM (#21065084)
They are like eye-spy books or Where's Waldo moved to tablet. You pick try to click on objects hidden in a scene.
Re:Brain research on boys’ preference for video games and gi... by oh_sigh on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @06:11PM (#21065162)
Just what it sounds like - there are objects in a picture and you need to spot them. You'd get a list of 10 objects(guitar, owl, hamper, etc) and you need to find them in a picture of a room. The objects frequently aren't hidden per se but are just hard to spit because there might be 100 objects in the picture.
Re:Brain research on boys’ preference for video games and gi... by derefr on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @06:22PM (#21065263)
At its core, sure, but then imagine taking that and making it the core mechanic of a larger experience, in the way that "moving between tiles and attacking in a direction" is the core of a roguelike.

You can add time pressure; things that only appear once you've found other things; hybridize the mechanics with those of other genres, like adventure-game-like puzzle minigames to combine or use objects; etc.

In some sense, any game where progression is gated by a threshold of gathered collectables—and where the hard part is detecting the collectable, not navigating to or otherwise retrieving the collectable—is a hidden-object game. Pokemon Snap is a hidden-object game—the objects are shot compositions. The Ace Attorney games are hidden-object games—the objects are literal evidence, but then during the trials they're evidence+opportunity pairings. "Hacking" games, where you detect vulnerabilities to exploit, are hidden-object games. Trade-war or Elite type games (i.e. inefficient-market exploitation simulators) are, on an abstract level, hidden-object games. :)

And, of course, games in other genres can employ hidden-object mechanics, too. Platform games have special coins in out-of-the-way locations, where the challenge is just inferring that that was a visitable place to begin with. RPGs have treasure that shows up as little often-hard-to-spot motes of light on the field rather than big obvious chests. Etc.

Re:Brain research on boys’ preference for video games and gi... by UnpossibleJim on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @11:13PM (#21067249)
This is somewhat anecdotal but the company I work for makes and publishes puzzle games, match three and hidden object games for the mobile space, which are by and large marketed towards women. However, large, AAA console and PC titles look to be marketed towards men. Now, there is A LOT of money put into these games and we run fairly comprehensive marketing campaigns, but rarely televised (though I think we ran one on The Bachelor with small returns which did not warrant the cost). So it isn't that we don't make women aware of the product but we have to follow nontraditional avenues of advertisement to reach them and mobile phones seem to be the preferred gaming platform for women, statistically speaking. At least as far as what I've seen from my company's data.
Re:Brain research on boys’ preference for video games and gi... by throwawawathrow on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @05:19PM (#21064742)
My experience as well. People on this site tend to think everything goes back to hunter gatherer societies and genes (a field they generally know little about) when the most plausible explanation (advertising) is something they know a lot more about. Kinda puzzling, or maybe a coping mechanism.
Re:Brain research on boys’ preference for video games and gi... by mjevans on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @06:21PM (#21065238)
Would 'escape room' and/or puzzle-room games (maybe more like the Myst genera) be under the Hidden Object umbrella, or possible a "puzzle environment" genera?

Also, IMO, Puzzle Environment is (hopefully) non-gendered, but I've never seen stats for it.

Re:Brain research on boys’ preference for video games and gi... by Simon_says on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @04:52AM (#21068952)
The problem is hoping for reality to be a certain way rather than evaluating the evidence and seeing where it leads. Maybe you hope to change it to be non-biased in the future? In any complicated trait that's a complex interaction of nature and nurture, it's unlikely that all of the forces would be balanced perfectly for there to be no difference between groups.
Re:Brain research on boys’ preference for video games and gi... by baroffoos on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @11:14PM (#21067253)
Guns and heavy machinery are not topics for boys. Its just that those things are pushed on boys more while they are growing up. My sisters main game right now is counter strike.

I saw an interesting video last year where they used toddlers young enough to have no visible gender and they got in babysitters to help the toddlers play with toys. They gave the toddlers random gendered names and clothes. They then asked the babysitters what they think the kids's favorite toys were.

In almost every test the babysitter handed the kids the toys associated with the gender they thought the kid was from the name and not what the kids actual gender was. They then went to comment that the perceived genders toys were the kids favorite.

Re:Brain research on boys’ preference for video games and gi... by Lio on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @05:53AM (#21069221)
I'd offer the counter example of other infant primates expressing gender preferences for toys.

https://www.newscientist.com/article/dn13596-male-monkeys-pr...

Re:Brain research on boys’ preference for video games and gi... by ZeroGravitas on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @07:58AM (#21069863)
An interesting fact from that study that gets often overlooked is that the female monkeys spent as much time playing with the "boy" toys as the male monkies.

They only had a stronger preference because the boys didn't play with the cuddly toys as much.

A subtle but important distinction.

This is similar to studies that show women's favourite colour is actually blue. But what gets reported is that they have a stronger preference for pink, because, compared with men, more chose that and that somehow gets into the consciousness as "girls prefer pink over blue".

Re:Brain research on boys’ preference for video games and gi... by agumonkey on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @01:38AM (#21067949)
I beg to differ. Early on boys will pick up wood staff and play fight. They need no hint here.
Re:Brain research on boys’ preference for video games and gi... by Funes- on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @06:28PM (#21065313)
>all of the typical things like guns and heavy machinery that men are well known to like more than women

Okay, so either men liking guns, heavy machinery, and videogames more than women comes from a inherent, biological difference between men and women, or it all comes from a huge, complex social construct that has been cultivated and dominant for centuries. Which one is it, then?

Re:Brain research on boys’ preference for video games and gi... by seph-reed on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:42PM (#21065941)
I'm going to take off my "mature adult" hat here, and say something I think which is probably totally groundless, but I want to talk about it anyways.

A lot of little boys are hyper as fuck, and I don't think that's a social construct. I think that's just how little boy bodies tend to produce energy: in excess.

Also, a good description for most games might be "twitchy." I think these two line up.

But in answer to your question, Nature vs Nurture: the answer is always both, but far more nature than we'd like. When we hit the cyborg/embedded computers line, that's when I think it'll be 50/50.

Re:Brain research on boys’ preference for video games and gi... by thanatropism on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @11:06PM (#21067215)
My father's peer group used to get in brawls with boys from three streets over for the hell of it. See also Achewood's "The Great Outdoor Fight".
Re:Brain research on boys’ preference for video games and gi... by rjf72 on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @12:14AM (#21067534)
There was an excellent series on this exact question released in Norway called Hjernevask [1]. Linking to Wiki there since it provides a link directly to each video as well as a brief synopsis. It had a profound impact on its release in Norway starting extensive discussion of the topic and ultimately led to the removal of government funding for gender studies programs. The primary methodology was simply approaching researchers with contrary research and seeking their views and opinions.

This is also not an American style documentary where things are taken out of context or efforts made to entrap researchers or anything like that. It's just regular interviews on both sides of the argument alongside giving each side the opportunity to express themselves as well as their views on research that tends to run contrary to their own personal views. But all in all this ultimately serves to greatly emphasize how tenuous the appeals to a social construct are when contrasted against the other option.

It goes without saying, but all episodes are of course also subtitled in English.

[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hjernevask

Re:Brain research on boys’ preference for video games and gi... by majormajor on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @10:08PM (#21066876)
The artifacts of the social construct are all around us, starting with most Western religious texts, so... people's confidence that everything is biological and that everyone who spent millennia on indoctrination was just wasting their time surprises me. Redirecting people's biological urges is exactly what society has tried to do for ages. At this point it's gotten pretty good at it. So why do we assume that the things people are directed at in gendered ways is anything close to indicators of gendered natural ability, affinity, or talent when it comes to the brain?
Re:Brain research on boys’ preference for video games and gi... by hackinthebochs on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @10:40PM (#21067072)
>So why do we assume that the things people are directed at in gendered ways

Because we're well past assumptions and have significant amounts of hard evidence that point towards relevant structural differences in the brain along gendered lines and behavioral differences that manifest at the earliest ages.

Re:Brain research on boys’ preference for video games and gi... by throwawawathrow on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @06:42PM (#21065430)
That huge, complex social construct is called advertising and it is something HN users should know about seeing how most of their jobs is serving as much of it to as many Internet users as possible. You wouldn't think HN users would get into a job that involves shaping the minds of literal millions of people without being aware of the consequences that would entail, would you?
Re:Brain research on boys’ preference for video games and gi... by fzeroracer on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @08:07PM (#21066138)
It's from the huge and complex social construct. I think this has been fairly well documented throughout the evolution of video games, specifically when you start looking at the golden era of arcades and games like Pac-Man (whose demographics consisted mostly of women).

With the home console revival and growth of PCs, games were marketed primarily towards young men as the default demographic. There's also the fact that what's considered for men vs women can vary drastically depending on whether we're talking about the US, Korea, Japan etc.

Re:Brain research on boys’ preference for video games and gi... by jdm2212 on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @05:30PM (#21064844)
My (female) SO is a huge fan of the Sims, which must be as close to social media as you can get in video games. So there's some stuff out there for girls.
Re:Brain research on boys’ preference for video games and gi... by einpoklum on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:09PM (#21065658)
More importantly IMHO, they were designed with male protagonists, and few-if-any playable female characters.
Re:Brain research on boys’ preference for video games and gi... by legostormtroopr on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:43PM (#21065951)
> few-if-any playable female characters * Joanna Dark (Perfect Dark) * Lara Croft (Tomb Raider) * Sarah Kerrigan (Starcraft) * Sonya (Command & Conquer) * Samas Aran (Metroid) * Sonya Blade (Mortal Kombat) * Chung-li (Street Fighter) * Jill (of the Jungle)

Those are ones I can name without Googling from games before 2000. If you think there haven't been female playable characters in video games, you weren't paying attention.

Re:Brain research on boys’ preference for video games and gi... by einpoklum on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @02:23PM (#21073618)
You're proving my point. There is a list - longer than this one of course, but a very finite list - of examples. You wouldn't think of listing the playable _male_ characters in games, because those would be, well, almost all characters in all games.
Re:Brain research on boys’ preference for video games and gi... by slavik81 on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @04:05AM (#21068760)
> Sonya (Command & Conquer)

You mean Tanya? Cha-ching!

Re:Brain research on boys’ preference for video games and gi... by txsoftwaredev on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @06:00PM (#21065082)
There is no shortage of video games both enjoyed by boys and girls. One popular "game" among younger children is "Roblox". It appeals to both girls and boys. My son tends to enjoy the more high paced action type games and my daughters enjoy the ones focused on running a store, dress up etc. They all enjoy playing games but my son can play for a much longer period of time. My daughters seem to get bored quicker and switch over to Netflix or similar.
Re:Brain research on boys’ preference for video games and gi... by hrktb on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @06:24PM (#21065274)
> it appeals to both girls and boys

It still seems to be mostly marketed at boys. Looking at the itunes store page, first item is a video with running, shooting, fighting, racing cars and burning armors. Second photo a mosaic, third fighting armors, fourth a robotic cowboy, fifth ninja like armors. https://apps.apple.com/jp/app/roblox/id431946152

Both genders might enjoy, but wouldn’t there be more content and more optimization towards boys play style ?

Re:Brain research on boys’ preference for video games and gi... by LoSboccacc on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @05:27PM (#21064814)
this is self selection bias in action, you liked those games and you sought these genre. there were far more adventures and puzzles than shoters and strategy game, even without accounting the nineties pet simulation craze and all the activities games like mini golf, tabletops conversions etc.
Re:Brain research on boys’ preference for video games and gi... by on_and_off on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:41PM (#21065934)
ovaries are indeed well known to contract when in close proximity to heavy machinery