News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:MegaBots calls it a day, puts fighting robot up for sale ... by magashna on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @03:33PM (#21063714)
Those giant robots are years away from having the mobility needed for entertaining combat. I feel like we peaked with BattleBots nearly 20 years ago, early on before the spinning doom meta took over. There was fun stuff like that bot that had a net in a giftwrapped box, basically begging for a spinbot to tear into it and get paralyzed. Young me has a lot of nostalgia for that, but the new season they tried was not great.
Re:MegaBots calls it a day, puts fighting robot up for sale ... by rasz on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @05:18PM (#21064732)
>I feel like we peaked with BattleBots nearly 20 years ago

Let me introduce you to the present https://www.robomaster.com/en-US https://www.twitch.tv/robomaster/videos FPV controlled, computer vision oriented, AI enhanced (gun controllers/target tracking is fully automated).

Re:MegaBots calls it a day, puts fighting robot up for sale ... by magashna on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:26PM (#21066655)
That looks pretty cool, but I definitely have a soft spot for the jank that was in the scene 20 years ago. Back when it was more like pro wrestling
Re:MegaBots calls it a day, puts fighting robot up for sale ... by giggles_giggles on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:50PM (#21066016)
You know BattleBots has been on a new run since 2015? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BattleBots#Season_6_(2015)

I cannot vouch for this being high quality TV but the spinning meta was broken somehow. There are still a number of spinners, but other designs do OK (drums, flippers, combinations of these things, even some flamethrower bots).

On that note I can vouch for this being highly entertaining low quality TV, and with all the sponsorships and kids you see in the stands, I do hope it's helping to inspire a new generation of roboticists :)

Re:MegaBots calls it a day, puts fighting robot up for sale ... by lahwran on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @08:06PM (#21066131)
So they invited the public to come watch in a venue in the north bay a year or two ago, an hour ish north of sf, and I went - it was, eh, okay. They wanted the crowd to perform cheering and stuff, it was really more like being an extra. The fights were cool, but it was pretty optimized for being a tv show and not very optimized for being a tv replay of a live show. Shrug, seems fine for what it is, just for what it's worth.
Re:MegaBots calls it a day, puts fighting robot up for sale ... by wnissen on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @08:35PM (#21066356)
It sucks for the audience. Sadly RoboGames didn't do a show this year, they are a ton of fun to watch. I hope they come back.
Re:MegaBots calls it a day, puts fighting robot up for sale ... by wnissen on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @08:33PM (#21066330)
The producers deliberately pick interesting robots (and teams) instead of the most likely to win.
Re:MegaBots calls it a day, puts fighting robot up for sale ... by dublinben on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @05:54PM (#21065028)
You might feel that the competitiveness of BattleBots peaked 20 years ago, but combat robots have only continued to get better in the time since. Advancements in battery technology, motors, 3D modeling, and other technologies have made today's combots significantly better than those of your youth.
Re:MegaBots calls it a day, puts fighting robot up for sale ... by XMPPwocky on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @05:59PM (#21065077)
Better at winning, sure. Better at being interesting to watch, though?
Re:MegaBots calls it a day, puts fighting robot up for sale ... by xwdv on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @06:13PM (#21065182)
It’s kind of like how the golden age of warfare was during World War 2. Gritty massive battles with lots of deaths and drama, mixed with a variety of emerging tech and well balanced strength between all opponents. Today’s wars are better, but not as interesting.
Re:MegaBots calls it a day, puts fighting robot up for sale ... by Consultant32452 on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @12:39AM (#21067655)
Don't worry, the next all out war will be "interesting." Countless drones, extended periods without electricity, global oil supply chains disrupted, it will be very very bad.
Re:MegaBots calls it a day, puts fighting robot up for sale ... by xwdv on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @11:22AM (#21071626)
For you. By then I hope to be living entirely off grid in some place nobody gives a fuck about, years behind on current events. It’s only a matter of securing enough money.
Re:MegaBots calls it a day, puts fighting robot up for sale ... by dmix on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:46PM (#21066759)
Was there any competition between spinners? It’s be funny if everyone showed up with variations on the spinner because they win.

Some of them are just toys to be destroyed by the better bots, many with little strategy. But getting one to work is still an achievement IMO. There’s just going to be a finite pool of talent to produce enough of them.

This makes me want to watch a battle again.

Re:MegaBots calls it a day, puts fighting robot up for sale ... by drakenot on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @04:27PM (#21064264)
What kind of advances do we need to make for robots of this size to have the kind mobility that people would generally expect?
Re:MegaBots calls it a day, puts fighting robot up for sale ... by myself248 on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @04:43PM (#21064418)
Financing.

MegaBots was founded by a couple of controls engineers who had done the math and figured they could make a real bipedal walking mecha with current technology, if only someone else would fund it.

Not that much money materialized, also falling on your face hurts when your face started 15 feet in the air, so the current gen went with a tracked base instead. But the tech can be done, we just need to get the pilots out and the money raised.

Re:MegaBots calls it a day, puts fighting robot up for sale ... by Animats on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @06:43PM (#21065435)
There's no market. You can build it, but so far, they don't come.

Honda's Asimo. Boston Dynamics's Atlas. Schaft's humanoid (probably the best one to date). Deere's legged logging machine. All never got beyond a few prototypes. None of them work well enough to do anything useful.

I used to work on this stuff, back in the 1990s. I have two patents in that area. (The big insight is that legs are for traction control - you can mess with the contact normal in useful ways. As soon as you get off flat terrain, traction control dominates the problem.)

I could never see a market for legged machines. Too expensive for toys. Not useful enough for much else. Boston Dynamics has gone from sugar daddy to sugar daddy for decades - first DARPA, then Google, then Softbank. Today, they finally launched a product, their cute little all-electric Spot robot.[1] No price given.

[1] https://www.bostondynamics.com/spot

Re:MegaBots calls it a day, puts fighting robot up for sale ... by kortex on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:34PM (#21066698)
It's still too expensive vs the gained utility. Given a tradeoff of very expensive and finnicky hardware, vs offroad wheels, use animals, or just pay humans, the robot loses.

A big part of that cost is the drive train and transmission. You need low speed and tons of torque, so this usually means geardowns.

Not that the software NRE costs are trivial, but they can be amortized. But building even a single basic six axis arm with human comparable strength is gonna cost several grand.

Re:MegaBots calls it a day, puts fighting robot up for sale ... by smokelegend on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @11:40PM (#21067389)
Re:MegaBots calls it a day, puts fighting robot up for sale ... by Animats on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @01:48PM (#21073193)
That's very nice. They finally got a more general control model. That's progress. The first flip from that crowd was two decades ago. Now they have a way of generating and following more complex motions. "80% success", they write, so there's a ways to go yet.

I wonder what they use for actuators. What you want for running and gymnastics is a spring with adjustable spring constant, zero point, and damping. A pneumatic cylinder can do that, and can store energy briefly between motions. Humans, when running, recover about 60%-70% of energy from stride to stride. (Cheetahs, 90%. That's how they run so fast.) Hydraulics can't do that very well, although there have been some attempts with hydraulic accumulators. There have been attempts to do this mechanically, with two motors and a spring, but they're bulky. Direct drive electric motors can do it, but if you have a gear train, the inertia of the motor is multiplied by the reduction ratio and you lose the ability to absorb shock loads. Also tend to break gear teeth. ("You cannot strip the teeth of a magnetic field" - early electric locomotive selling point.) I once thought that direct drive linear motors [1] were going to be the answer, but those never got popular. (Aura, the main company in that field, had some nice technology and a big financial scandal. Their web site looks like a placeholder now. It's one of those areas where hard problem + limited demand -> no products.)

There's a hack called a 'series elastic actuator', which is a powered screw jack with a stiff spring on the end, used to fake more general springs. When absorbing energy, the motor runs fast to back off the screw jack and unload the stiff spring. This recovers no energy; it uses power when absorbing energy. It's used in research robots where battery life isn't an issue.

It took Boston Dynamics about $120 million to get to the "legged squad support system", the militarized Big Dog. No idea how much it took to get to a usable Atlas.

It's good that they're still trying. The question is how much patience and money Softbank has left.

I wish Schaft had made it. They were a University of Tokyo spinoff, bought by Google and dumped by Google. They used small liquid-cooled motors, so they could run the motors much harder than usually done. Like Tesla's motors, but far smaller.

[1] http://www.aurasystems.com/actuators.html

Re:MegaBots calls it a day, puts fighting robot up for sale ... by goldenkey on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @05:02AM (#21069014)
That thing is nightmare fuel. What kind of power in voltage/amps is it on? With fusion technology, the iron man fuel cell will pretty much actually exist. Think about how much more capable these things would be with higher energies..
Re:MegaBots calls it a day, puts fighting robot up for sale ... by manigandham on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @05:00PM (#21064565)
Materials science so that they can be built from composites and weigh 1/10th of their current mass, and also take some hits.

Otherwise it requires ridiculous amounts of energy to get any kind of real velocity in the movements, and then the first impact would explode both robots.

Re:MegaBots calls it a day, puts fighting robot up for sale ... by bArray on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @10:24PM (#21066974)
I would say that you're barking up the wrong tree. It's really about cost of investment vs return on investment. 15 tonne robots still cost too much to build, transport, run, etc. Therefore, they have no competitors, because everybody else did the same napkin math but realized it wouldn't work.

That's not to say that something like this isn't possible, the size simply needs to be reduced. Remove the human from the inside and then your robots can also deal proper blows.

Re:MegaBots calls it a day, puts fighting robot up for sale ... by saalweachter on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @04:42PM (#21064404)
About ten years of lowering people's expectations for how mobile a 15-ton robot should be.
Re:MegaBots calls it a day, puts fighting robot up for sale ... by k__ on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @04:01PM (#21064015)
Did they try new rules or something?

Like going bigger every year, etc.

This could have led to an evolutionary path to big bots with good mobility.

Re:MegaBots calls it a day, puts fighting robot up for sale ... by magashna on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @04:18PM (#21064178)
They had a heavyweight class but in the end, spinning really fast crushed all competition at every level from what I remember. Any design that deviated was a novelty, and I can see why you wouldn't want to bother with an interesting design, only to have it ripped apart in a few seconds.

There were some flippers, some hammers, some flamethrowers, but spinning really fast always tore into them instantly. Kinda made it boring after the first few seasons.

I'd be on board again if there wasn't such an obvious winning strategy. They banned nets, but they should probably ban spinners as well.

Re:MegaBots calls it a day, puts fighting robot up for sale ... by logfromblammo on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @05:34PM (#21064869)
Well, the obvious counter to spinners is nets and loose fibers, or otherwise fouling the spinner's bearings, so it's like banning paper from a rock-paper-scissors tournament. Everybody's gonna throw rock, and the people who still throw scissors because rock is boring get creamed.

Ablative spinner shields are too heavy, and get in your way as much as they get in the spinner's way.

Re:MegaBots calls it a day, puts fighting robot up for sale ... by aidenn0 on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:53PM (#21066042)
Spinners won because they were the only thing left that could damage the typical armor, and most robots ended up with self-righting mechanisms to defeat flippers.

IIRC good pushers could still compete with spinners though.

Re:MegaBots calls it a day, puts fighting robot up for sale ... by icebraining on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @04:57PM (#21064536)
Have they tried drones yet? There's probably a nice challenge in having to balance weapons weight + battery weight + battery capacity + maneuverability.
Re:MegaBots calls it a day, puts fighting robot up for sale ... by michaelt on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:21PM (#21065771)
People have tried such things [1] I would say it doesn't make for particularly good viewing. Every engagement sends one or both drones involved to the ground, which rewards not engaging. Although perhaps more sophisticated rules could improve on that?

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jFiYqVKFJ0U

Re:MegaBots calls it a day, puts fighting robot up for sale ... by germinalphrase on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @08:43PM (#21066400)
Obviously, the drones need to learn how to grapple.
Re:MegaBots calls it a day, puts fighting robot up for sale ... by wtracy on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @06:51PM (#21065491)
Behold, robot sumo fights:

https://youtu.be/4qHe5K3KktY

For the most part, nobody is insane enough to battle autonomous robots with destructive weapons on board.