News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:European Court limits right to be forgotten to E.U. by Vinnl on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:40AM (#21059999)
> What it essentially does is limitation of low-skilled users search results. And that's all.

That sounds like it's still something though. If someone gets falsely accused of e.g. being a pedophile, and their prospective employer does not run into that information when researching them during the interview process, that seems like it achieves one of the goals people had in mind with this legislation.

Re:European Court limits right to be forgotten to E.U. by brokenkebab on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @10:41AM (#21060696)
>That sounds like it's still something though

Sure, but nothing to celebrate: it puts average Joe in even more disadvantaged position compared to organized entities (corporations, and gov't agencies) when searching, while still won't save anyone from professional info gathering. E.g. all headhunting companies certainly will use VPNs, or similar technologies when compiling data.

Re:European Court limits right to be forgotten to E.U. by inlined on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @11:55AM (#21061503)
Wouldn’t this be a systematic violation of the candidate’s right to be forgotten?

It seems like this is the now-missing part of the puzzle: other countries still have sovereignty over their data but explicitly using a vpn to access legally protected pii should be itself a violation.

Re:European Court limits right to be forgotten to E.U. by brokenkebab on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @10:40AM (#21071213)
I don't think so. The law doesn't oblige me to abstain from searching information (IANAL), and it really must not, because it won't be technically enforceable unless you are willing to go to the space of totalitarian state solutions, and overall decrease of rights people enjoy just to expand one particular (and not particularly well tested) legal concept. I think it worth keeping in mind that attaching word "right" to some legal novelty doesn't necessary means it is something sacred, and even just good. We always have to assess cost/benefits balance, and not just declared intentions when looking at laws. RtBF conflicts with rights regarding searching facts/data which everybody needs to make informed decisions. Therefore it cannot be pushed farther without rather unpleasant consequences.
Re:European Court limits right to be forgotten to E.U. by BurningFrog on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @12:15PM (#21061711)
Doesn't it equally help actual pedophiles have their actions forgotten?
Re:European Court limits right to be forgotten to E.U. by simias on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @12:30PM (#21061902)
If you consider that somebody who has accomplished his sentence paid their debt to society it doesn't really matter. Either the person is still in prison (and they have bigger problems than worrying about Google search results) or they have left prison and society deemed that they deserved a second chance, in which case the right to be forgotten actually works as intended.

I realize that for these types of heinous crimes not everybody will agree with that but on the other hand letting these people free but living as pariahs shunned by the rest of society doesn't seem like a good solution (especially if we want to prevent them from acting on their impulses again).

Re:European Court limits right to be forgotten to E.U. by iamstupidsimple on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @12:48PM (#21062117)
Some crimes I can forgive, this I cannot. And therin lies the root of the problem. I do not want crimes that are deemed acceptable to be forgotten to be delegated to private corporations.
Re:European Court limits right to be forgotten to E.U. by simias on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @04:16PM (#21064167)
>I do not want crimes that are deemed acceptable to be forgotten to be delegated to private corporations.

But that's effectively the opposite of that. It's the government that mandates that private corporations implement the "right to be forgotten", regardless of the reason. The corporation has no say on the matter.

On the other hand if you do not have something like that then you live it up to private entities to effectively implement vigilante justice by listing supposed pedophiles forever on their websites for instance.

If you really think that people who commit pedophilia and other heinous crimes are forever unfit to live in society you should get your government to enact laws that make sure they're never released without supervision for instance. I mean unless you're a proponent of vigilante justice, but then you are effectively delegating justice to private entities, corporations or otherwise.

Re:European Court limits right to be forgotten to E.U. by iamstupidsimple on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @06:54PM (#21065533)
AFAIK search engines have the right to determine if a request is 'reasonable' according to some internal criteria. That's not something I'm comfortable with anyone having.
Re:European Court limits right to be forgotten to E.U. by true_religion on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @02:03PM (#21062953)
In the specific case you mention, sex offender registries are administered by the government.

Anyone that society deems to still be a risk is still on the list, regardless of the right to be forgotten removing newspaper entries about them.

Re:European Court limits right to be forgotten to E.U. by skrebbel on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @12:26PM (#21061854)
So long as they're not convicted, yes, and that's a good thing.
Re:European Court limits right to be forgotten to E.U. by bilbo0s on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:44AM (#21060044)
But the employer would, because the firm they use to do background checks will use an IP in the States to do the search.
Re:European Court limits right to be forgotten to E.U. by AstralStorm on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @10:02AM (#21060244)
Well if the employer is in the EU, they won't. So it's a win for EU, they get a potentially skilled employee.

USA privacy laws are bad enough you can get sicced by a private investigator most of the time with no questions asked, no repercussions.

Re:European Court limits right to be forgotten to E.U. by brokenkebab on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @10:33AM (#21060587)
>Well if the employer is in the EU, they won't.

They would, of course. Unless, someone's planning to build a whole Chinese-style censorship state, it's not possible to disallow to obtain information through VPN.

Re:European Court limits right to be forgotten to E.U. by Vespasian on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @10:45AM (#21060731)
I think the assumption is that the employer wouldn't do a background check in most cases (education etc. is an exception).

I've never encountered one in Germany and we certainly don't do them with potential applicants at my place of employment. (No idea whether this is because of a law or for different reasons)

Re:European Court limits right to be forgotten to E.U. by brokenkebab on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @10:58AM (#21060880)
So employing company either does, or does not do background checks. And if it does it works irrespective of RtBF law.
Re:European Court limits right to be forgotten to E.U. by Ded7xSEoPKYNsDd on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @12:08PM (#21061648)
No 'background checks' by private investigators in Germany. Some employers ask for a police certificate of conduct. There's a law saying which kind of convictions are listed there (nothing below a certain amount of days) and how long (to allow re-socialization).
Re:European Court limits right to be forgotten to E.U. by CodesInChaos on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @11:06AM (#21060971)
Preventing the search may be hard. But I don't see a problem with disallowing hiring discrimination based on such information (which is likely already the case).