We've basically ended up with a situation where instead of the ruling party manipulating the timing of elections, we have a majority of MPs manipulating the timing of the next general election in order to ensure the current government - who they do not support - is at the maximum disadvantage. (As others have said, the next election will almost certainly happen long before its fixed schedule.)
Boris would have simply delayed dissolving parliament so the Oct 31 deadline passed while parliament was dissolved. To do so would have been legal and rational.
The opposition would have had to be dumb to fall for that.
I mean, I'd prefer to face election as the victorious conquering hero. Unless I thought everything would go to shit the day after no deal.
For example, here’s an article from 2010 citing some of those opposed to it: https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2010/may/13/fixed-term-...
The problem is that when the current government can choose the timing of the elections, it invariably chooses a date that holds some sort of advantage to it. Therefore, the date of the elections is set in advance and can only be changed by a super-majority, depriving the ruling party this advantage.