News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by growlist on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @06:26AM (#21058375)
How can the refusal to agree to a general election be pro-democracy?
Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by katet on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @06:33AM (#21058422)
We've had one, and we're not halfway to the next one. I'm amused to some degree that the idea of another referendum is anathema to some, but the idea of a third election in (almost) as many years is somehow a better idea. If there's another GE now or soon, it'll be the same hung parliament.
Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by tomp on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @10:05AM (#21060294)
Repeating a referendum on the same question is logically inconsistent. What do you do if you get the opposite result, why not just repeat it again, 2-out-of-3, 3-out-of-5? In addition, it casts doubt on and makes a joke out of every other future referendum question.

On the other hand, elections are meant to be repeated.

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by hogFeast on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:17AM (#21059778)
Because the problem is Parliament. We have a deal, it has been voted down four times. Johnson has a clear strategy for Brexit, that is being stymied too.

I think what is unclear to you is the fact that we are leaving the EU. That question is closed. The point of the GE (and Johnson's strategy) is to ensure that we leave with a deal (it is very possible that the EU rejects any extension).

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by matthewmacleod on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:29AM (#21059910)
It is entirely unclear whether or not the UK will be leaving the EU. There is currently no support for any particular next steps, it is entirely possible that there is now majority support in the country for remaining a member state, and there are obvious avenues by which Brexit may be avoided.

You are welcome to support or object to this process in whatever way you see fit, but please do not spread objective disinformation.

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by growlist on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @11:04AM (#21060947)
> and there are obvious avenues by which Brexit may be avoided.

ish - it's pretty telling that the pro-Remain parties are running scared of a GE. They suspect they'll be utterly demolished in many areas.

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by hogFeast on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:37AM (#21059973)
There is no Remain majority in Parliament. I don't know why you think there is, that is factually incorrect.

The Conservative policy is leave. The Labour conference just voted for leave (that is binding on the Executive, that will be their policy in the GE). Yes buddy, I am spreading "disinformation".

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by stordoff on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @11:52AM (#21061477)
> There was earlier another boost for Mr Corbyn, as members backed his Brexit strategy to remain neutral on a second referendum until after a general election.

> Mr Corbyn wants to strike a new deal with Brussels within three months of coming to power and then decide which side to back in an ensuing public vote at that point.

https://news.sky.com/story/labour-to-stay-neutral-on-second-...

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by rtempaccount1 on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @09:56AM (#21060176)
actually you are, unless you'd care to provide a reference for that Labour policy.

My understanding of the Labour position is that they would negotiate a deal with the EU (likely including a custom's union) and then hold a second referendum, in which the government would stay neutral.

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by stordoff on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @12:04PM (#21061613)
Johnson voted _against_ the withdrawal agreement twice, and then for it once. If Parliament is the problem, Johnson has been part of that problem. I'm also not sure what his clear strategy is. The current deal would involve going with a deal he has voted against twice and that his Leader of the House of Commons has recently described as "dreadful", and he has shown no indication that he is going to bring it back. The EU has accused him of "pretending to negotiate"[1], so I'm unclear where a new deal would come from.

Furthermore, unless I'm mistaken, I believe it has only been voted on three times.

[1] https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2019/feb/13/kicking-up-...

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by chaosite on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @06:36AM (#21058433)
That's basically the idea of fixed-term elections.

The problem is that when the current government can choose the timing of the elections, it invariably chooses a date that holds some sort of advantage to it. Therefore, the date of the elections is set in advance and can only be changed by a super-majority, depriving the ruling party this advantage.

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by makomk on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:10AM (#21058632)
That's not how the Fixed Term Parliament Act has worked in practice, though. It let Theresa May schedule an early election because she liked the look of the polls and wanted to increase her majority just fine. What it has done is allowed the House of Commons to keep around a government which has genuinely lost the confidence of the House, to the point that they've lost every single vote since Boris took office, because kicking them out will lead to an election the government will likely win. This is not how Parliament is meant to work. The entire system is built around the idea that the government should have the confidence of the House and that the mechanism for holding them accountable is to kick them out if necessary. The FTPA wasn't meant to change this, but unfortunately I don't think anyone thought through the game-theoretical consequences of the mechanisms it created.

We've basically ended up with a situation where instead of the ruling party manipulating the timing of elections, we have a majority of MPs manipulating the timing of the next general election in order to ensure the current government - who they do not support - is at the maximum disadvantage. (As others have said, the next election will almost certainly happen long before its fixed schedule.)

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by michaelt on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @10:59AM (#21060888)
Let's be honest here: If parliament had voted for an early election, a no-deal Brexit would have been inevitable.

Boris would have simply delayed dissolving parliament so the Oct 31 deadline passed while parliament was dissolved. To do so would have been legal and rational.

The opposition would have had to be dumb to fall for that.

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by makomk on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @02:05PM (#21062969)
That would've been both politically and legally risky. Folks would undoubtedly challenge it on a multitude of legal grounds, some of which could well succeed, and also the general consensus seems to be that Boris' best shot at winning the election is to schedule it before Oct 31 so he can turn it into a vote on no-deal Brexit and scoop up the Brexit Party voter base.
Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by michaelt on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @04:21PM (#21064203)
If Boris's main policy is the delivery of a no-deal brexit, and he had a choice to face an election without delivering it, or shortly after successfully delivering it, you think he'd prefer the former?

I mean, I'd prefer to face election as the victorious conquering hero. Unless I thought everything would go to shit the day after no deal.

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by tomatocracy on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @08:54AM (#21059565)
Yes. The fixed term parliaments act needs repealing in my view. Quite a few people at the time thought the Fixed Term Parliaments Act was a bad idea.

For example, here’s an article from 2010 citing some of those opposed to it: https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2010/may/13/fixed-term-...

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by growlist on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @10:40AM (#21060676)
Problem is that parliament is a. stalled and b. acting in defiance of a democratic vote and c. deliberately blocking the only logical resolution (i.e. a General Election) that does not represent an intentional subversion of democracy.
Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by stordoff on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @11:48AM (#21061423)
Voting for an election without an extension would almost certainly mean a no deal Brexit. _That_ is a subversion of democracy - the election is somewhat pointless if it happens after the major decision of the time has been taken.
Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by growlist on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @05:04PM (#21064611)
No, because what the Remain side are trying to engineer in defiance of the public vote is BRINO.
Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by pjc50 on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @06:32AM (#21058420)
The democratically elected representatives, who are the supreme law of the land under parliamentary supremacy, decided that they didn't want one. And the normal five year term has several years left to run.

It's very likely that we'll have one before Christmas, but obviously it has to be after cancelling or postponing Brexit.

Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by growse on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @06:30AM (#21058401)
Funny, I don't see anything in the court's ruling about having (or not) a general election.
Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by M2Ys4U on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @07:50AM (#21058961)
In order to have a General Election Parliament has to vote for one... Which they can't do if they're prorogued.
Re:Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges... by growlist on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @10:43AM (#21060703)
But they had the opportunity to vote for a GE before they were prorogued and chose not to, didn't they?

'Oh no, the facist has taken away our opportunity to vote! (about this thing we explicitly voted to avoid when we were given the opportunity)'