News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by eesmith on Monday September 23, 2019 @10:58PM (#21056076)
Free software isn't about making data openly available.

Stallman, at https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/selling.html , argues that free software developers should "charge as much as they wish or can, ... if you are redistributing copies of free software, you might as well charge a substantial fee and make some money."

If you have useful data, the free software principles say that you might as well charge a lot of money for it, which is not what most chemists and biologists think of in discussion of data openness.

FWIW, the discussion in science started independently of free software. Here's an example from structural biology. Previous to the 1980s, it was common for crystallographers to withhold structure data from a publication, and perhaps only publish an image showing the C-alpha backbone. This was because they wanted to be able to publish additional papers from the same data set, without competition. By 1987[1], there was a push to require coordinate submission into the PDB as requirement for publication. Most journals adopted this new policy in 1989, and funding agencies started to do so as well[2].

While the GNU project started earlier (1983), there is no connection between free software and the open data availability requirements for publication and funding in structural biology.

[1] https://search.proquest.com/openview/0a93cbb72da63b2899793bf...

[2] https://journals.iucr.org/a/issues/2008/01/00/sc5004/index.h...

Open Source also isn't about making data openly available. Both are only applicable to those who acquire software. It just happens to be that most free and open source developers also make their software available at no cost.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by inimino on Monday September 23, 2019 @11:51PM (#21056342)
> Free software isn't about making data openly available.

You must be allowed to redistribute the software, and you must be allowed to get, modify, and redistribute the code. Binaries and code are data.

Maybe what you mean is that the biologists' and x-ray crystallographers' journals developed their push for data access independently of the free software movement, but it's a stretch to say that access to the data that a programmer creates and access to the data that a biologist creates have nothing in common.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by eesmith on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @12:22AM (#21056516)
"Allowed to" is not the same as "required to."

Open science people generally want people who publish papers to be required to publish the data. This might be in a public repository, or with the journal, and if there is a fee, that fee should effectively only cover cost.

Stallman's conception of free software says that you should be able to charge as much as you want. Hence, these are different concepts.

What I mean is that the statement in the original comment, "Now chemists and biologists have started talking about making data openly available and so forth" is wrong. Chemists and biologists "started talking about" this decades ago. The evidence I showed is that it was no later than 1987. It's almost certainly older - I just happened to read about this example.

I'm not saying they have nothing in common. I'm reacting to the hyperbole in the idea that the free software movement was instrumental to "the paradigmatic changes in how science itself is done".

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by redis_mlc on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @01:20AM (#21056810)
> Stallman's conception of free software says that you should be able to charge as much as you want.

Yes, he was referring to the service of duplicating and mailing tapes pre-Internet. You seem to have mistaken that for a key philosophical issue of some kind, when it's secondary.

> reacting to the hyperbole

I worked for national labs back in the day. Every dept. wrote their own terminal applications, plotting programs, etc. which consumed serious grant budgets. Free and open source software has been a huge boon to science. The most important? GCC and family. Second is probably Linux, which is GPL. See a pattern yet?

It really sounds like you need a history lesson on the FSF, because you're way off base.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by eesmith on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @03:28AM (#21057427)
Really? Because I think it is part of the key philosophy of free software.

Consider #1: I think of an improvement to gcc. I get a copy of the gcc source, modify it, and prove to my satisfaction that it works.

I stop at that point, intellectually satiated, tell a few friends, and don't release any software (source or binary).

The principles of free software say that I am not forced to release any changes. I am not even obligated to send improvements upstream.

Am I wrong about this?

Consider #2: The same as above, but I know that Yoyodyne could save $1 million per year with my improvements. I don't tell them. The free software principles say that I have no obligation to tell them.

Am I wrong about this?

Consider #3: The same as above, but I go to Yoyodyne and say that I'll sell my gcc modification to them - under the GPL - for $250,000. They of course can then redistribute those changes, including back to mainline.

Is that contrary to any free software principle? I don't think so, according to my years of reading the history of the FSF and the free software movement.

But, suppose you are correct, and Stallman's essay only applies to "the service of duplicating and mailing tapes pre-Internet". If so, there's a simple workaround:

Consider #4: I have the idea, implement it, and distribute it to a single organization - a tape duplicating service - and it's that organization which sells the software to Yoyodyne, for $300,000, of which $250,000 comes back to me. (My brother just happens to run the tape service.)

Is that against the principles of free software, and if so, how?

I don't think Stallman's "selling free software" essay was meant to be so easy to work around.

Just because free software is generally distributed at no price or "reasonable cost of physically performing this conveying of source" (quoting GPLv3), doesn't make it the same as saying that there's an free software principle which obligates that.

While the open data movement in science does have the principle that the data should be free, or should only cover the "reasonable cost of physically performing this conveying of" data.

How am I off base?

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by pessimizer on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @06:11AM (#21058274)
I don't think you are. Trade secrets aren't covered by GPL except in the case of v3 on software accessed through a terminal. Even in this essay, he makes clear than open patents aren't the same as Free Software.

That being said, the Free Software movement was obviosly seminal in all of the open data talk, and for that matter open patent talk; it's not the same thing, but a strong and heavily influential idea in one context inspires analogues in other contexts. I think your overall point is wrong, although I think your supporting point is completely correct.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by inimino on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @11:54PM (#21067462)
Your #4, by the way, is basically the "bounty" model of open source funding, and is not unheard of. For example, Blender was open sourced this way.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by inimino on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @11:44PM (#21067408)
You're not wrong, however... if you sell the software, you're obligated to provide source. A better analogy would be if you publish the paper, you're obligated to release your data. Nobody ever suggested that individuals or companies can't do private research at all. You just shouldn't be able to have it both ways. If you want the credit, show your work.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by eesmith on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @12:28AM (#21067600)
Yes, that analogy is the argument in open data.

My argument is that that analogy doesn't follow from free software principles.

If it did, then it would follow that if you publish the paper, you're obligated to release your source.

And we don't see that coming out of the free software movement. We do see that coming out of the open data/open science movement.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by inimino on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @03:03AM (#21068431)
Yes, if you publish, you're required to release everything necessary for a practitioner reasonably skilled in the art to reproduce your results, without undue effort. For example, releasing a tarball of source code missing the Makefile that runs the arcane build process is not within the spirit of free software and you will be soundly ridiculed and if GPL is involved may be sued. Dumping a database that, together with your paper, still requires n > 1 grad-student-years of effort to reproduce is not really open science, although it's a huge step up from Elsevier. Is this broadly understood? Probably not, but it is at least well known by some. Honestly, free software people have been working out these "reproducibility" issues in practice for decades before the biologists even got on the bus.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by eesmith on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @10:43AM (#21071235)
Free software is only concerned with software.

If you publish your software, you are required to release everything needed to develop it further, yes.

However, if you publish your paper, you are not required, under the free software principles.

If I am wrong, show me where the FSF/GNU say that.

I believe your argument is that there's a clear parallel to publishing a paper and publishing the software.

However, there's also a clear parallel to, say, publishing an internet service based on free software, and publishing the software. This lead to the AGPL.

The GPL does not have that requirement, which means it isn't a free software principle. It could have - I think I've heard Eben Moglen say it was discussed early on. But if so, then having a telnet server, or ftp server, or anything reacting to the network, would require the ability to download the source.

> free software people have been working out these "reproducibility" issues in practice for decades before the biologists even got on the bus.

While biologists were working out other "reproducibility" issues long before there were buses.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by inimino on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @05:18PM (#21075609)
You're correct about FSF/GNU having narrow focus. Also that the GPL doesn't say anything about what biologists can't publish. Analogically we can make the arguments but we can't attribute these arguments to the FSF. Whether the west coast hackers influenced the open access science movements -- it's obvious that they did, this is not all post hoc parallels that everyone missed at the time.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by kqr on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @01:11AM (#21056761)
Well, when you purchase GPL licensed software, the author is required to supply you also with the source code, and you must be allowed to redistribute this (under terms and conditions.)

Sure, there are distinctive features for each domain, but in broad strokes, I don't see the above description as very different from the one following:

When you purchase access to an open-data paper, the author is required to supply you also with the raw data, and you must be allowed to redistribute this (under terms and conditions.)

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by eesmith on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @02:21AM (#21057085)
"when you purchase GPL" .. sure.

But there's nothing to force me to provide you with the software until you've given me money. Even if I used someone else's GPL'ed software in my software, I can simply not distribute it until someone gives me $100,000.

"When you purchase access to an open-data paper"

Some provisos first. Some papers are gratis, and don't require being purchased. (Eg, author-pays papers.) Also, I think you are defining "open-data paper" that way, making your argument a bit tautological.

Those aside, I'm pointing out that the "open-data paper" movement started independently and likely co-temporally, if not earlier than, the free software movement.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by doesnt_know on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @03:33AM (#21057454)
> I can simply not distribute it

Of course, you haven't infringed on anyone's freedom yet, there are no users. I guess the thing is if you massively overcharge without providing any corresponding service of value the first person that purchases it has the option to throw the source code up on the internet and it can be forked.

I guess you also have to find a buyer that is willing to pay you the large sum while also knowing they can't charge others for it without also handing over the source code, so it's doubtful anyone would do so.

There are other options though, if a single person or entity owns the copyright for the entire code base, with no outside contributors, they can dual license it. GPL for the public and then commercial proprietary license for businesses. That way the business can build on it if they wish without redistributing the source.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by eesmith on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @03:41AM (#21057502)
Exactly! I am free to talk about it, boast about it, write papers about it, etc.

While, to go back to my first comment:

"If you have useful data, the free software principles say that you might as well charge a lot of money for it, which is not what most chemists and biologists think of in discussion of data openness."

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by inimino on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @03:21AM (#21068534)
If you have useful data, you might as well get a big research grant to publish it. If the buyer (in this case the government or university) were to demand reproducibility, this would cost more, because reproducibility takes work, and it would be worth more; overall scientific progress would accelerate, because reproduction with variation (sounds familiar) has value.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by inimino on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @02:50AM (#21068361)
> Stallman's conception of free software says that you should be able to charge as much as you want.

Yes, once. After this your first customer is now free to undercut you and bring the price as close to zero as they like, as is their first customer, etc.

The analogy is: you can charge Nature as much as you want for the rights to publish your paper, but when you do, you have to give them the raw data, in replication-ready form, which they will then publish to anyone they sell the journal to. And Nature's customer is in turn allowed to republish and if they do is required to again make the source data available.

I think you're reading more than is warranted into rms selling some emacs tapes by mail order back in the day.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by inimino on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @02:42AM (#21068323)
> Open science people generally want people who publish papers to be required to publish the data.

Free software requires that if you publish (or sell) binaries you MUST release the source as well, with full rights to modify and redistribute.

You are not required to publish, just as you are not required to release software.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by cma on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @12:54AM (#21056691)
If I'm understanding right, those journals still kept it copyrighted, without copy-left provisions. It's more like the notion of open source, where the source may be viewable but isn't necessarily available for redistribution.

While Stallman says you can charge as much as you can, his terms say that once someone buys it they can immediately undercut you, and he admits that limits the amount you could charge sustainably.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by olalonde on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @06:34AM (#21058427)
> It's more like the notion of open source, where the source may be viewable but isn't necessarily available for redistribution.

That's incorrect: open source software is necessarily available for redistribution. What you are referring to (source viewable but not necessarily available for redistribution/modification) is commonly referred as "source available" software [0].

Now, the distinction between open source and free software is more a social/political one rather than a practical one. Free software encompasses an entire philosophy while open source is simply concerned with software licensing.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Source-available_software

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by COGlory on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @02:21AM (#21057086)
>If I'm understanding right, those journals still kept it copyrighted, without copy-left provisions. It's more like the notion of open source, where the source may be viewable but isn't necessarily available for redistribution.

The publication, yes. The structure, no. You can go download the structure of any and every known and published protein from any organism in the world for free with no copyright restrictions from the PDB. And that structure will be heavily scrutinized and reviewed before it's accessible.

That said, working in structural biology, it's incredible how quickly that field attached to open source, and in particular, free software. The big players in the field (coot, Relion, PEET and IMID) are all GPL. Additionally, software like PyMOL, Chimera, Phenix etc are available for free, sometimes with source. Those are basically all the software in the structural biologist toolset, with HKL2000 perhaps being the only paid software on anyone's workstation.

I suspect there's probably multiple reasons for this phenomenon. There's not many structural biologist, and of the few that there are, many are in academia and have no money to spend on software. Additionally, the field moves so rapidly that most software is actually piecemealed toolkits from tons of labs. Also, anything algorithmic requires substantial analysis if you want to publish data acquired with it, meaning it needs to be open. Finally, 99% of structural biology is done on Linux, so there's simply a culture aspect as well.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by eesmith on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @01:01AM (#21056721)
I think you refer to the publication, and not the journal? I was referring to "making data openly available", quoting the top-level comment, and "If you have useful data" in my comment you replied to.

The data repository I mentioned is the PDB. Quoting http://www.rcsb.org/pages/policies :

> Data files contained in the PDB archive (ftp://ftp.wwpdb.org) are free of all copyright restrictions and made fully and freely available for both non-commercial and commercial use. Users of the data should attribute the original authors of that structural data.

That means it's available for redistribution.

BTW, the general trend is to use "source available" instead of "open source" when the source is available for viewing and perhaps local modification, but not for redistribution. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Source-available_software

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by cma on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @02:48AM (#21057220)
Ah, I didn’t realize what the PDB was, sorry.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by thayne on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @02:39AM (#21057175)
> It's more like the notion of open source, where the source may be viewable but isn't necessarily available for redistribution.

I think you misunderstand the distinction between open source and free software. Open source software also needs to be available for redistribution. The main practical difference is Free Software also requires that if you make any changes to the software, those changes must _also_ be released under the same licensing, whereas open source may or may not have such provisions.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by colonwqbang on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @03:23AM (#21057408)
No, you are thinking of copyleft software. "Free software" means the same thing as "open-source software".

See for instance this GNU page where permissive licenses like the MIT license are also described as "free software licenses":

https://www.gnu.org/licenses/license-list.html

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by denton-scratch on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @08:38AM (#21059406)
That is incorrect. Stallman defined 'free software'. He has said:

"The term “open source” software is used by some people to mean more or less the same category as free software. It is not exactly the same class of software: they accept some licences that we consider too restrictive, and there are free software licences they have not accepted. However, the differences in extension of the category are small: nearly all free software is open source, and nearly all open source software is free."

In particular, he notes the example of DRM software. DRM software can be distributed under an open-source licence, but by design and in practice it serves to restrict the freedoms of its users, not to enhance them.

Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by GoblinSlayer on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @08:22AM (#21059250)
It's up for interpretation. Toviozation clearly restricts freedom of modification.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by Digit-Al on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @10:51AM (#21060804)
Really though? When the inventor of the concept of "free software" and the founder of the Free Software Foundation says that free software is not the same as open source software I don't really think you can seriously declare that "it's up for interpretation".
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by Sudarshan_SMD on Wednesday September 25, 2019 @01:12AM (#21067808)
With Tiviozation, the Software can be modified and used in any way you want, on your own hardware. It's the Hardware that is being locked by Tiviozation.
Re:Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007) by WalterBright on Tuesday September 24, 2019 @02:25AM (#21057114)
There are a lot of things free on archive.org. Some people download categories, burn them on DVDs, and sell them for a few dollars. I find that worth the money rather than laboriously downloading things one by one, and bought a few.