News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Talent is everywhere, opportunity is not by petra on Saturday September 21, 2019 @07:33AM (#21034693)
How many talented people , in advanced economies, with good technical degrees , do take part in inventing important stuff ?

Very few.

Educating more kids and having more "ideas" won't change that.

We're not lacking ideas. We're lacking the right incentives to make ideas happen.

Re:Talent is everywhere, opportunity is not by PostOnce on Saturday September 21, 2019 @08:30AM (#21034943)
Everything is a hassle. Building permits, operating licenses, legal compliance, etc.

All those things arguably exist for good reasons, but it's a huge hurdle to doing anything useful.

I can't have a 20 foot radio tower in town, I can't subdivide smaller than 10 acres outside of town, I can't build any facility out there to operate the experimental tower without building permits, radio licenses, compliance with tracking (for the police) any radio customer I might get if I qualify as a "communication service provider", etc.

There are (major) hurdles in just about every conceivable industry, and hardly any provision for "hey I'm a guy who wants to experiment, perhaps even noncommercially".

You can overcome the hurdles, but how many people will just stay at their 9 to 5 and not bother because its a huge pain in the ass with no guaranteed benefit?

I wonder how much this holds us back, it's hard to say.

Re:Talent is everywhere, opportunity is not by jjoonathan on Saturday September 21, 2019 @08:55AM (#21035065)
I'm a fan of the chemistry analogy here: you can catalyze (reduce barriers) and you can incentivize (increase rewards). If the incentives point the wrong way, catalyzing won't help. If the barriers are too high, incentivizing won't help.

I strongly suspect we're in a "barriers too high" regime rather than an "incentives are too low" regime, and that our money would be better spent reducing barriers than increasing incentives.

Re:Talent is everywhere, opportunity is not by bumby on Saturday September 21, 2019 @09:20AM (#21035213)
I think I agree but the question seems to be how do we lower the barriers smartly while still keeping the intent of the rules and regulations? Add to it our own bias to put more emphasis on the regulations that concretely prevent us from doing what we want now, rather than those that abstractly benefit us and its easy to point to them being the problem.

It's like the "one mans trash is another mans treasure" cliche, something that you see as an impediment I see as a social good. Finding the right balance is tricky and unfortunately in a polarized political environment it's easy for people to fall into the far sides of the argument.

Re:Talent is everywhere, opportunity is not by abakker on Saturday September 21, 2019 @10:02AM (#21035429)
The real question is: why did we install the protections(barriers) in the first place? I assume that a major component of that was as a reaction to the increasing complexity of modern life. Self sufficiency is fine, but it is difficult to take the consequences for many things knowingly. As such, we created, one at a time, experientially driven barriers designed to protect people from new, novel issues.

I don’t think we need to offer more incentives or reduce barriers per se, but I think we really ought to be talking about refactoring our laws. The amount of legislative “technical debt” is intense and problematic.

Re:Talent is everywhere, opportunity is not by alchemism on Saturday September 21, 2019 @11:06AM (#21035784)
For the many regulations in American society, there is usually a dead body buried underneath, possibly many dead bodies, including those of women and children, etc.

For each and every one, someone suffered terribly or died.

Re:Talent is everywhere, opportunity is not by thrower123 on Saturday September 21, 2019 @05:51PM (#21038128)
Unfortunately, many times, the dead body belonged to an idiot, whose foolishness won them a Darwin Award, and the legacy of inconveniencing millions of people.

We place too high a value on human life, and it's no wonder that we can't accomplish anything when a non-zero level of risk is unacceptable.

Re:Talent is everywhere, opportunity is not by bumby on Monday September 23, 2019 @01:51PM (#21051449)
> We place too high a value on human life

I don't think this is quite right. More accurately, I think we need to the risk assumer and risk accepter may need to be making the informed decisions.

Too often there is someone making a decision that someone else pays for. You want to strap yourself to a rocket and go into space and you have been communicated the risks and accepted them, that's one thing. It's entirely another when you get into a car running on software that you have no clue about. In the latter case, you aren't making a risk informed decision because the person/corporation determining that the risk is acceptable doesn't flow that information down to you (or, there's limited bandwidth that any one person can make an informed decision about). That's where regulation levels to playing field somewhat to ensure perverse incentives don't cause risks to be accepted by those who don't have to bear them. I or [insert relevant company name here] shouldn't be the decider on what risk you should be (perhaps unwittingly) accepting.

Re:Talent is everywhere, opportunity is not by jhayward on Sunday September 22, 2019 @10:56AM (#21041628)
> We place too high a value on human life, and it's no wonder that we can't accomplish anything when a non-zero level of risk is unacceptable.

This is too close to another formulation of the same thought: "we should allow corporations to kill people for profit, with impunity" for comfort.

Re:Talent is everywhere, opportunity is not by thrower123 on Sunday September 22, 2019 @11:18AM (#21041734)
No, it's really, really not. It would be nice if we could have a discussion of acceptable levels of risk versus inefficiency without immediately taking a left turn into "Soylent Green is People!" territory.
Re:Talent is everywhere, opportunity is not by jhayward on Sunday September 22, 2019 @12:34PM (#21042229)
The "lefty" epithet, how handy.

You could start by telling us why the statements aren't the same, using examples and facts.

You seem to want to have an abstract, bloodless, clinical discussion of when it is acceptable to kill people in the name of "efficiency" (I will interpret this as "profit").

I can tell you that is a dishonest discussion, if that's what is intended. If you want to have it honestly you will have to first indicate an understanding of exactly, in detail, the most evil things that will happen as a result. Also the most devastating things that will happen and be protected from proportionate legal recourse under your proposed or imagined regime.

It won't be a bloodless conversation.

Re:Talent is everywhere, opportunity is not by abakker on Sunday September 22, 2019 @09:26PM (#21045215)
Evil and blame free do not necessarily follow from acknowledging that some level of risk is acceptable.
Re:Talent is everywhere, opportunity is not by jhayward on Monday September 23, 2019 @04:05PM (#21053003)
This is a non-statement intended to deflect into the abstract and away from actual consequences.

Policies and regulations aren't made in some Platonic ideal universe, they are made in specific, factual circumstances.

Come back to us when you can talk about how a specific "acceptable" level of risk does not involve enabling evil actors, and indemnified doers for a specific policy area.

Then we'll talk about the specific things you find acceptable, and just whose death and suffering you will trade for profit.

Re:Talent is everywhere, opportunity is not by bumby on Monday September 23, 2019 @04:49PM (#21053465)
I don't read their statements the same way you do. The way they come across to me is that there needs to be a discussion of risk grounded in the understanding that in many (most?) domains, zero risk is unattainable.

It's like the idea of the FDA setting limits to the amount of insect contaminates allowed in food. At first, it seems disturbing until you realize that if they put a zero tolerance policy in place, there would be near-endless grounds to sue every food manufacturer out of business.

Re:Talent is everywhere, opportunity is not by malandrew on Monday September 23, 2019 @07:10PM (#21054760)
> in many (most?) domains, zero risk is unattainable.

Not only is it unattainable, it's actively counterproductive to try and achieve because of unexamined and unintended consequences.

Re:Talent is everywhere, opportunity is not by NhanH on Saturday September 21, 2019 @03:42PM (#21037448)
Yes, but that doesn't mean the regulations are still relevant, or that they were ever been a good regulation to start with. The PATRIOT act came from a horrible tragedy, and many people would tell you how terrrible it is.
Re:Talent is everywhere, opportunity is not by mch82 on Saturday September 21, 2019 @01:21PM (#21036595)
“Refactoring” is great word choice. It implies there might be a set of test scenarios we check against before revising a law to make sure we don’t break the intent. It also sets an expectation for continuous improvement.
Re:Talent is everywhere, opportunity is not by mncharity on Saturday September 21, 2019 @12:46PM (#21036352)
> Everything is a hassle. Building permits, operating licenses, [...]

Tesla's politically-connected Shanghai Gigafactory 3 looks to be going from bare field to production in around a year. Part of that was apparently government inspection being done in parallel with construction, to minimize sign-off delays.

Re:Talent is everywhere, opportunity is not by nscalf on Saturday September 21, 2019 @09:07AM (#21035128)
On this topic, I felt this while looking into building a healthcare startup. HIPAA seemed like some goosebumps character, don’t say it’s name 3 times or else you’re in violation.

Not only are hurdles a pain, they’re not easily understood.

Edit: beetle juice, not goosebumps

Re:Talent is everywhere, opportunity is not by alchemism on Saturday September 21, 2019 @11:03AM (#21035768)
That is precisely why it is (potentially) lucrative, too. It’s an awfully tall fence.
Re:Talent is everywhere, opportunity is not by delfinom on Saturday September 21, 2019 @10:04AM (#21035445)
>All those things arguably exist for good reasons, but it's a huge hurdle to doing anything useful.

Humans are good at coming up at ideas, the problem is, not all ideas are good ideas. But humans are especially good at ideas to maximize their profit resulting in permits and compliance are written in resulting blood along with the engineering standards enforced.

Unfortunately the threat of jail does not deter those ideas, but putting enough barriers that everyone working under them have to jump through does a really good job at reducing the amount that follow through with them.

The other aspect, it doesn't take much to kill a human. The rules may seem overkill, but a human is a soft squishy fleshbag where tripping on a pencil could kill you.

Re:Talent is everywhere, opportunity is not by cwingrav on Saturday September 21, 2019 @08:44AM (#21035019)
(US centric comment) I'll add that we're making it less likely people will take risks and act on their ideas with student debt and a lack of healthcare. People can't take risks if they don't have a cushion to rely on and risk their lives (or face massive debt) if a non-trivial health concern occurs. Compounding this is a draw back of social programs to get people back on their feet if their risk turns south. I'm not advocating for paying for "slackers", but giving people a chance at least as good as what their parents had.
Re:Talent is everywhere, opportunity is not by mch82 on Saturday September 21, 2019 @01:23PM (#21036612)
People are also less likely to speak up about problems at work when they must worry about losing healthcare along with a job.
Re:Talent is everywhere, opportunity is not by zzzcpan on Saturday September 21, 2019 @07:53AM (#21034767)
Well, if governments let corporations dominate, monopolize markets they are inevitably giving up competition and therefore innovation. Forcing talented people to work on evil things that advance company's dominant position, rather than working on innovations to have a temporary edge over competition.
Re:Talent is everywhere, opportunity is not by aripickar on Saturday September 21, 2019 @08:31AM (#21034945)
It depends on social pressure. For places like Silicon valley, the ultimate status symbol is being a founder, which inherently involves inventing (what a founder would call) important stuff. It's similar in Israel. Heck, there, startups are struggling to scale becuase everyone wants to be a founder.
Re:Talent is everywhere, opportunity is not by petra on Saturday September 21, 2019 @09:49AM (#21035353)
I don't agree that founders are unique in inventing "important stuff".

In reality, most important inventions, are efforts of large groups of people(that may be distributed across organizations), and most of it is work - not coming up with a "great" "vision".

// Everyone wants to be a founder

Well, you know the song "asiti":

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=x6ezbFpkGlw

It's on Hebrew, but it basically talks about the Israeli tendency to always say "I did this, I did that"

Re:Talent is everywhere, opportunity is not by everybodyknows on Saturday September 21, 2019 @11:39AM (#21035963)
>I don't agree that founders are unique in inventing "important stuff".

Not what @aripicker claimed: "... being a founder, which inherently involves inventing ..." No mention of uniqueness.

Re:Talent is everywhere, opportunity is not by paulcole on Saturday September 21, 2019 @10:06AM (#21035453)
I mean virtually nobody does anything that's important, whether they're talented or not or have a good degree or not. We're pretty good at fooling ourselves into thinking what we're doing is important though.
Re:Talent is everywhere, opportunity is not by petra on Saturday September 21, 2019 @01:13PM (#21036533)
Not necessarily important as in "single handedly curing cancer". But taking part in an important thing , even in a small role, is important.

But so much talent is wasted on insignificant things.

Re:Talent is everywhere, opportunity is not by solinent on Saturday September 21, 2019 @09:10AM (#21035152)
I think we can certainly incentivize people more, but in order to invent "important stuff" we need significant resources. If everyone was given the money to invent this important stuff, it's hard to allocate the proper resources to them, or at the very least, they will get fewer resources.

Even at large R&D companies which have the investment, people are still hesitant to invest in new ideas since they simply don't have the money. It works the same way with the government, just at a larger scale.

Many people don't care about any of this though. They just want to live their lives, find something to be passionate about, and die peacefully. You'll always have to fight these people, politically.

We also have to consider the legal ramifications of such things. It is difficult to do ethical R&D.

Re:Talent is everywhere, opportunity is not by mncharity on Saturday September 21, 2019 @01:23PM (#21036614)
> We're lacking the right incentives to make ideas happen.

Perhaps it's also not what our industrial policy is tuned for? In California, if a company kills a project, the staff might go elsewhere to pursue it, but that can be harder in states which enforce non-competes. Similarly, in China, if a supplier drops a product, you might go elsewhere for it, which can be harder in the US which has patent law tuned for exclusivity. A great deal of VR/AR tech has vanished into FAMG, and become unavailable for anyone else in the US to "make ideas happen". Part of why China accepted trade war as the lesser of evils.

[dead]
Re:Talent is everywhere, opportunity is not by Jonnax on Saturday September 21, 2019 @08:37AM (#21034981)
"extreme socialism inspired progressive agenda"

A meaningless phrase that just states that "as a conservative, this makes me upset"

Re:Talent is everywhere, opportunity is not by journalctl on Saturday September 21, 2019 @10:34AM (#21035606)
The idea that the world isn’t the meritocracy one might believe it to be is very disconcerting to some people, especially the people who benefit from such privilege as wealth, or being the preferred race/sex in their particular culture. The idea that perhaps not everyone can just “pull themselves up by their bootstraps” is foreign to people like this.
Re:Talent is everywhere, opportunity is not by tekmate on Saturday September 21, 2019 @07:55AM (#21034772)
it's got nothing to do with socialism and everything to do with capitalism. restricting the advanced workforce and research to the thin slice of a population with the opportunity (mostly well off parents, sometimes race and sex) you lose out on a tremendous amount of human resources with the potential to create value.
Re:Talent is everywhere, opportunity is not by akhilcacharya on Saturday September 21, 2019 @07:55AM (#21034773)
What, pray tell, is socialistic about this?
Re:Talent is everywhere, opportunity is not by thrower123 on Saturday September 21, 2019 @08:23AM (#21034895)
It's not socialist, necessarily, but it's definitely blank-slatist, and the two are often stablemates.
Re:Talent is everywhere, opportunity is not by akhilcacharya on Sunday September 22, 2019 @01:14AM (#21039792)
I’m far from a blank slatist or a socialist, but as someone who is generally considered “untalented” on the HN scale of things please continue. What is objectionable about this viewpoint?
Re:Talent is everywhere, opportunity is not by thrower123 on Sunday September 22, 2019 @10:20AM (#21041476)
To be honest, I find the blank slate model just cruel, because it shifts blame for failure to achieve results onto either a personal failure to work hard enough, or some ill-defined societal boogieman of oppression or structural isms. Which tends to need massive amounts of money or power in the hands of someone to try to rectify.

In reality, you just can't make chicken salad out of chicken shit, no matter how hard you try.

Re:Talent is everywhere, opportunity is not by akhilcacharya on Sunday September 22, 2019 @07:14PM (#21044600)
> In reality, you just can't make chicken salad out of chicken shit

This is one of the most disgusting things I've seen on this website. Am I "chicken shit" to you?

Re:Talent is everywhere, opportunity is not by thrower123 on Monday September 23, 2019 @08:07AM (#21048081)
I don't know anything about you. Who are you again?

I grew up in bumfuck Appalachia, and there's a lot of people there that are so inbred and unfortunate that they can barely chew gum and walk at the same time. You can put people through years and years of education and spend all the money in the world on them, but you're not going to ever get them to understand calculus or read on grade-level.

Acknowledging people's individual abilities and limits is far more humane than pie-in-the-sky optimism.

Re:Talent is everywhere, opportunity is not by mav3rick on Monday September 23, 2019 @10:49AM (#21049407)
He clearly used a generic phrase not aimed at you. What is it with deliberately taking things personally ?
Re:Talent is everywhere, opportunity is not by haihaibye on Sunday September 22, 2019 @06:33PM (#21044409)
It's not true.

Some countries have higher IQ populations than others. Eg South Korea was poorer than many African countries in the 60s, now they make smartphones.

This would have been hard to predict given a blank slate talent is everywhere thesis, but not if you know they have one of the highest IQs in the world. Same with Singapore.

Of course a really bad government (North Korea) can screw you up.

Re:Talent is everywhere, opportunity is not by akhilcacharya on Sunday September 22, 2019 @07:13PM (#21044596)
> Some countries have higher IQ populations than others.

Are you saying I'm inherently inferior due to the country my parents were born in?

Re:Talent is everywhere, opportunity is not by haihaibye on Monday September 23, 2019 @06:12AM (#21047452)
No, these things work in distributions.

It's perfectly possible for very smart people to come from very low average IQ populations, it's just less likely than from higher average IQ ones.

Many countries also have very high IQ subpopulations eg India, Nigeria and Iran off the top of my head.