Re:Dear Email Industry, We’ve Got a GDPR Problem
by giancarlostoro on Friday September 20, 2019 @07:19AM
(#21025345)
Do any email clients block tracking pixels? My understanding is that they block images by default but if you choose to view them you will load all the tracking pixels.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Dear Email Industry, We’ve Got a GDPR Problem
by iamacyborg on Friday September 20, 2019 @07:24AM
(#21025376)
Article author here - Tracking pixels aren't blocked per se in most email clients but you're correct that they rely on images being loaded.
Re:Dear Email Industry, We’ve Got a GDPR Problem
by giancarlostoro on Friday September 20, 2019 @07:27AM
(#21025397)
Thanks for answering, it's curious enough that I'm now looking into Thunderbird plugins to see if there's one to block (or try to) tracking pixels.
Re:Dear Email Industry, We’ve Got a GDPR Problem
by chopin on Friday September 20, 2019 @07:35AM
(#21025468)
Thunderbird blocks images per default. I never bother to load them.
Re:Dear Email Industry, We’ve Got a GDPR Problem
by ape4 on Friday September 20, 2019 @08:27AM
(#21025889)
Just to be clear, it blocks remote images by default. Images embedded in a mail are displayed.
Re:Dear Email Industry, We’ve Got a GDPR Problem
by microcolonel on Friday September 20, 2019 @07:24AM
(#21025380)
I guess I'm just not that familiar with HTML email anymore in general, and when I do read it I generally do not have images regardless.
I always assumed that disabling 1x1px images would be first on the list of mitigations against this technique. I was under the impression that email clients, in addition to an option to block images in general (usually on by default for an address or origin), generally prevented the loading of remote images. Embedding images directly into emails is fine, isn't it?
Re:Dear Email Industry, We’ve Got a GDPR Problem
by iamacyborg on Friday September 20, 2019 @07:29AM
(#21025418)
Depending on the platform used to send the email, it's trivial to change that pixel to any other image, ie a brand logo in the template.
On the whole, disabling images entirely is the only real defence against email tracking.
Re:Dear Email Industry, We’ve Got a GDPR Problem
by microcolonel on Friday September 20, 2019 @07:37AM
(#21025483)
Or I guess the mail server could just always precache all images at the time of receipt. Then nothing new happens when the mail is read. I think somebody here is describing GMail's approach that way.
Re:Dear Email Industry, We’ve Got a GDPR Problem
by accatyyc on Friday September 20, 2019 @07:51AM
(#21025593)
Then email servers would have to download billions of images of which 99% the corresponding email won't even be opened
Re:Dear Email Industry, We’ve Got a GDPR Problem
by iamacyborg on Friday September 20, 2019 @07:49AM
(#21025573)
gmail's cache hides a users location but you can still tell when they've opened an email, and you can still get a ton of information if they click a tracked link within the email as well.
Re:Dear Email Industry, We’ve Got a GDPR Problem
by mobjack on Friday September 20, 2019 @07:38AM
(#21025490)
You can't tell if an image is a 1x1 pixel until you load it from the server. At that point, the pixel has already done its job.
Most email clients these days don't block images by default unless it ends up in the spam mailbox.
They never embed images directly into emails either.
Re:Dear Email Industry, We’ve Got a GDPR Problem
by benjymo on Friday September 20, 2019 @07:45AM
(#21025542)
At least Thunderbird and Outlook on Mac block images by default and you can whitelist people from your address book.
Re:Dear Email Industry, We’ve Got a GDPR Problem
by giancarlostoro on Friday September 20, 2019 @07:30AM
(#21025420)
The easiest way is to disable them by default which is why Thunderbird defaults to not loading from senders not yet whitelisted, which thankfully most HTML email has the text on the email, it's those darn emails that have all the text in an image that I get suspicious of and delete (usually spam / probably malware). It would be nice to see plugins to block them for sure. I use Thunderbird for work, keep forgetting to use it for regular email. At least even webmail email services block pictures by default now, probably to prevent browser exploitation, never know when someone finds some rogue PNG exploit.