News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by lghh on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @10:19AM (#21005684)
Why are for profit prisons any different than state owned prisons? The guard unions and other employees that are contracted out to work in the state owned ones are making just as much money and rely on that slavery in the same way as they do in for profit ones. I see no difference, demolish them all.
Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by rndgermandude on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @10:56AM (#21006067)
Same reason s private corporate run police force or fire department are a bad idea.

With all the flaws current system have, governments are at least accountable (on paper) to the citizens. Corporations are not.

Private prisons are a clusterfuck where they take their "involuntary customers" for all the money they and their extended family got while still underpaying their staff and overcharging the tax payers. They often signed contracts with governments that included guaranteed minimal occupancy clauses.

Now imagine applying the same nice principles to other areas where currently the People (represented by their governments) are in charge.

"Thank you for calling 911, a service of Police Corp, a Comcast company. I see you got home intruders. We'll dispatch one of our associate Crime Fight Technicians to your location shortly. Please make sure you're home next Monday between 9m and 5pm to let them in. Would you like to sign up for our premium Home Intruder Plus coverage? Oh wait, I just saw you're located in an area we currently do not serve."

And the Industry Association of Fire Fighting Corporations would be lobbying government right now to change building codes to require more flammable materials in houses.

Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by criley2 on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @10:33AM (#21005823)
Because state owned prisons do not sign contracts with the state requiring % full or penalties. Only private prisons sign contracts with governments requiring 90%+ capacity or penalties. Thus only private prisons truly incentivize local governments to incarcerate more people to avoid extra costs, while if that facility is run by the taxpayer, they enjoy the savings of hiring less guards and incarcerating less people.
Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by robohoe on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @09:24AM (#21005143)
Gun ownership still makes sense.
Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by curiousgal on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @09:27AM (#21005164)
It makes sense to form an armed militia in order to fight the government?
Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by jsperson on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @09:56AM (#21005457)
Weapons, including small arms, are best viewed as a deterrence. Evidence 1: Many videos of rabidly anti-gun folks who refuse to put a "This home is proudly gun free" sign in their front yard. Evidence 2: The US has thought twice (definitely still not enough) before invading other countries after Iraq and Afghanistan. Why? Small and improvised arms have been a real headache. Evidence 3: Hong Kong. Someone asked below if the situation in Hong Kong would be better if there were lots of guns available. That's not really a relevant question. The situation would be entirely different. The government would have been much more limited in its response. Evidence 4: Historically one of the first things a want-to-be totalitarian government does is confiscate weapons held by the populace.
Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by jamesb93 on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @10:05AM (#21005549)
All it does is raise the stakes. Thats why police forces in America are heavily militarised. I can guarantee that if Hong Kong citizens had guns the police would have a disproportionate answer that included more deadly weaponry than they already do.
Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @10:15AM (#21005651)
> Thats why police forces in America are heavily militarised.

Police forces are heavily militarized because of the bonkers amount of money thrown at them in the name of the "War on Drugs" and more recent "War on Terror". Note the connection between "war" and an increasingly militarized police force.

Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by benj111 on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @10:41AM (#21005903)
"rabidly anti-gun folks who refuse to put a "This home is proudly gun free" sign in their front yard"

Do you have to list all the things you aren't protecting your home with?

Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by ssully on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @10:08AM (#21005577)
How do you reconcile the amount of deaths by firearms and the rise of mass shootings? Talking historically and hypothetical's about where guns come in handy is really simple. It get's really difficult when you wake up to news of another mass shooting - sometimes it is the second or third one to occur that month (or week).
Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by javagram on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @10:28AM (#21005780)
The “rise of mass shootings” is mostly a media phenomenon. They are still extremely rare events.

Gun laws haven’t gotten laxer in the last couple decades either - many states have strengthened them. There isn’t a clear connection between weak gun laws and mass shootings.

(That said, a total and effective ban on guns would of course stop mass shootings and other gun violence - if it could be implemented successfully)

Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by robohoe on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @10:37AM (#21005870)
First you would have to remove weapons from law-abiding citizens and criminals. The first one might be easier (with occasional resistance). The second might be much harder since criminals don't really care about laws in the first place.
Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by homonculus1 on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @10:59AM (#21006100)
>a total and effective ban on guns would of course stop mass shootings and other gun violence

But then, the cherrypicked, tautological nature of this goal is elided by gun control advocates--reducing gun violence without addressing the root social causes of violence is just a shell game.

Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @10:13AM (#21005640)
Admittedly that is a problem. Interestingly, it's a relatively recent one. Believe it or not there was a time in US history when you could mail-order full auto weapons.
Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by homonculus1 on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @10:14AM (#21005648)
Homicide is on a secular downward trend (despite the ever-increasing proliferation of firearms in the US). Mass shootings, while tragic, are black swan events and it does not make sense to dismantle a political foundation with long-term benefits to deter a marginal crime that could be done with a van.

A better response to mass shootings would be to desensationalize the media coverage, which since Columbine has been indulging the shooters' motives to shock society.

Incidentally though this whole thread is grossly off-topic and I expect it will be collapsed or detached.

Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by Grakel on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @09:50AM (#21005413)
Absolutely, it's a highly effective tactic that has resulted in success across continents and centuries. It's nice that peace is so taken for granted in developed countries, but it is an outlier in the human experience.

And to the commenter who said modern militaries could never be stopped by small militias, you have only to look seriously at our adventures in Afghanistan and the fact that we're still there. The AK 47 is a less accurate, high-recoil stamped out piece of garbage compared to the AR 15, and it's all you need to stop a modern military in its tracks for decades.

Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by cheeseomlit on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @09:49AM (#21005404)
It certainly did in 1765. Do you really think the government should have a monopoly on force? Might = power, you disarm the population and they are rendered powerless. I just don't understand putting that much trust in the government
Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by wDcBKgt66V8WDs on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @09:57AM (#21005461)
Historical and logistical context aside, 1765 vs modern weaponry and war waging abilities, are you joking? The ability for militias with small arms to fight our own military has been a joke for several decades.
Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by dsfyu404ed on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @10:09AM (#21005584)
>modern weaponry and war waging abilities, are you joking?

The Taliban aren't joking.

You are grossly under-estimating what it takes to fight an insurgency. A military fighting in the same country on which it depends is vulnerable to attacks and sabotage on all its support infrastructure. You can't just carpet bomb areas of resistance because that creates more resistance elsewhere or destroy the country you're trying to control. It's a hard problem and on some level you have to get people on "your side" to win in any sort of long term sense.

Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by ra1n85 on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @10:36AM (#21005854)
Amazed this was downvoted. The willingness to ignore history because it doesn’t fit in with some folks’ perception of the world is fully on display here.
Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by vageli on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @10:39AM (#21005889)
How can you say this given the fact that America is still at war in Afghanistan?
Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by Grakel on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @10:53AM (#21006028)
The Taliban were scheduled to be at Camp David last week. Why? The AK-47.
Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @10:02AM (#21005515)
Can you explain to me then why Vietnam is a communist country? As I recall, they were able to cause quite a lot of trouble for the US military and its modern weaponry and war waging abilities with pretty much nothing but small arms.
[dead]
Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @10:07AM (#21005567)
Way to do some explaining there. How is it different?
Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by wDcBKgt66V8WDs on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @10:23AM (#21005710)
This is not a conducive medium to either of us swaying each other on any small point nevermind the larger argument so I'm leaving it here.
Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by sharpneli on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @10:12AM (#21005628)
Armed militia will not win the fight in raw power terms, but it changes the governments position completely.

Unarmed riot can be dispersed using tear gas etc, no need to kill the civilians. Armed riot requires actually killing the opposition.

While government will almost certainly succeed in killing the militia the international opinion is wholly different in that case. 10000 person protesters dispersed vs 10000 killed.

Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by artificial on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @09:37AM (#21005261)
How’s it going in Hong Kong?
Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by mc32 on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @09:52AM (#21005422)
Or Venezuela. As part of consolidating power, often authoritarian governments implement an arms buyback or confiscation program to minimize armed uprising later on.
Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by artificial on Thursday September 19, 2019 @09:29AM (#21015952)
I like the Orwellian term “buy back” as if you purchased arms from them in the first place, and secondly they’re using your money to deprive you. For the small arms nay sayers (against a well equipped military) case in point is Afghanistan, guerrillas wore down the Soviets.
Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by mikeash on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @09:45AM (#21005352)
How do you think it would be going if Hong Kong has gun ownership at the level of the US?
Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by seanmcdirmid on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @10:25AM (#21005745)
Not the fight government part, but Switzerland actually has an armed militia unlike America. Their gun laws are a lot saner than the states to boot.

Any pro gunner will tell you that the 2nd amendment is sacred, except it’s first clause, that’s meaningless.

Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by TheRealSteel on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @09:33AM (#21005217)
It absolutely does not.
Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by Grakel on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @09:53AM (#21005439)
Anyone who believes that the US Government is committing terrible acts, but also wants them to take away firearms is in a really indefensible rational position.
Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by minikites on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @10:21AM (#21005702)
Do you think successful armed rebellion with small arms is realistic these days? How well did that work out for the people at Waco or the Cliven Bundy standoff?
Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by Grakel on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @10:36AM (#21005860)
It worked great for Bundy, I doubt the government would have backed down without the threat of violence. It works great in Afghanistan, and it worked great in Vietnam. It didn't work out great in Waco.
Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by jimktrains2 on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @09:52AM (#21005433)
How does gun ownership not make sense to farmers, hunters, and most people living in truly rural areas, e.g. Appalachia?

Look, I'm all for stricter gun laws, but at the same time not everyone lives in a (sub)(ex)urban area and a blanket ban simply will not work.

Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by microcolonel on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @09:39AM (#21005290)
Cue the barrage of comments from people who live in condos and apartment buildings surrounded by competent police forces a couple minutes away.
Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by berbec on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @10:03AM (#21005531)
Cue the barrage of comments from people protecting their children from 30-50 feral hogs.
Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by krisroadruck on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @10:00AM (#21005486)
The rebuttal for this argument is so often used that it's been turned into a nice bite-sized repeatable phrase:

"When seconds count, the police are only minutes away"

Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by homonculus1 on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @10:09AM (#21005587)
I think you and the person you responded to (and me too) are in agreement.
Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by IanDrake on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @09:41AM (#21005320)
I see your list contains the electoral college but not the Senate. Can you explain why?
Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by mac01021 on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @10:04AM (#21005538)
They're different things.

The senate gives equal representation to each state.

The electoral college gives each state a degree of representation approximately proportional to its population, but the approximation is somewhat poor.

Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by IanDrake on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @10:18AM (#21005676)
Yes, they are different things. Yes, the Senate gives states equal representation.

However, the Senate isn't "like" the Electoral College. The Senate is what makes Congress like the EC...or vice versa.

So if you believe the US isn't a collection of united states, which is why the senate exists and why the EC exists, then it is only rational to argue against both intuitions.

Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by mac01021 on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @10:38AM (#21005881)
You could believe that the Senate is a fine implementation of it's goals (to protect inhabitants of smaller states from the tyranny of the majority, or whatever) while also believing that the electoral college is a failure that just adds noise to the popular vote.

Not saying that's precisely my position...

Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by IanDrake on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @03:58PM (#21009410)
The EC has the same goal. You either believe in the goal or you don't.
Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by mac01021 on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @08:27PM (#21011995)
I feel like you didn't read and try to understand my last comment. You're certainly not pointing out any flaws in its logic.
Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by IanDrake on Thursday September 19, 2019 @09:01AM (#21015732)
The EC "adds noise the the popular vote" in the same way the senate adds noise to the legislative will of the population.

In one hand you say it's a bad thing, on the other its OK. It's not logical and the only way I can explain it is being sore losers of the last election.

I keep hearing how Trump is going to destroy our Constitution, but I also keep hearing from leftist how we need to change the first amendment, the second amendment, and the EC.

Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by swebs on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @09:33AM (#21005213)
Which part of the electoral college do you have a problem with? I'm a fan of the fact that it gives smaller states a voice, but don't like the fact that it's winner-take-all in every state except Maine. Also faithless electors is complete bullshit that needs to go.
Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by Dobbs on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @09:38AM (#21005277)
That is called the senate. There is no reason that a person in Wyoming's vote is worth four times as much as a person in California.

You can sorta maybe make the argument that the elctoral college should be to make sure someone unfit shouldn't be put in, by using their sense of judgement. Well that obviously failed, and you are advocating getting rid of that potential benefit.

Why not get rid of the entire anti-democratic idea and just vote for the president.

Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by Grakel on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @09:56AM (#21005455)
In a direct democracy the President could be chosen by a handful of highly populated states. There would be no reason for Wyoming to continue participating in the Union without a meaningful stake in representation. The direct vote concept sees this country as homogeneous, and it's too large and diverse for that.
Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by minikites on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @10:23AM (#21005726)
How many campaign stops are in Wyoming? How often do Republican presidential candidates campaign in California? How often do Democratic presidential candidates campaign in Alabama? The Electoral College doesn't actually address any of the issues raised in its defense.
Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by jrockway on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @10:23AM (#21005712)
The meaningful stake in representation is their two Senate seats, the exact same number that states large enough to be world powers if they were their own countries get.

Remember, this body of representatives was the one that managed to stall Obama's Supreme Court nominee until a new President was elected. That is a lot of power.

There will never be a President that everyone wants. The way to make the most people happy is to put into power the one that the most people voted for.

Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by swebs on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @10:10AM (#21005598)
>Why not get rid of the entire anti-democratic idea and just vote for the president.

Why not get rid of the entire anti-democratic idea of voting for representatives altogether and just vote directly on issues?

Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by Dobbs on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @10:54AM (#21006048)
There is a very big difference between voting for a representative to represent you, and some people being worth 4x another.
Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by jimktrains2 on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @10:01AM (#21005498)
Part of the issue is that there is a fixed number of house seats, which disproportionately favours smaller states. If we had an unbounded number of house seats and instead fixed the max constitutes-per-representative, the house would have a different makeup.
Re:Whole Foods Will Cut Health-Care Benefits for Nearly 2k E... by Dobbs on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @10:54AM (#21006042)
Not sure why you are being downvoted. That is an actual solution to the issue.