News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Richard Stallman Resigns from CSAIL and FSF by ecmascript on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @10:44AM (#20995704)
Good article for me as someone who is entirely outside the news cycle about this.

Pretty insane that you loose your job just because you have the wrong opinions about something. I don't understand why not FSF and others simply stand behind him in events like these?

This is pretty ridiculous and I hate this PC-elite that is currently ruling tech. I don't care about your code of conduct or what your thoughts are about different words.

I just hope Stallman the best and that he should not back down to the kind of bullshit that's been thrown on him. That is simply letting them win.

Fuck everyone that has the "you said something that I do not like, now you must resign"-mentality.

Re:Richard Stallman Resigns from CSAIL and FSF by glofish on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @11:04AM (#20995988)
He demonstrated a complete lack of understanding of how the legal system works.

IMHO he is not qualified to lead FSF.

Re:Richard Stallman Resigns from CSAIL and FSF by lukebitts on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @10:49AM (#20995782)
Simplifying the issue this much to boil it down to "a difference in opinions" is a bit dishonest. It was a very specific opinion that crossed the line, it's not like he said he prefers chocolate to vanilla.
[dead]
Re:Richard Stallman Resigns from CSAIL and FSF by lukebitts on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @11:04AM (#20995989)
The slippery slope is a very tired argument. When people start getting fired for illegitimate reasons then I'll defend those people. The outcome of this specific situation seems rational, fair and expected. "Don't say controversial shit on the job" is a really low bar, even if what is controversial changes from time to time.
Re:Richard Stallman Resigns from CSAIL and FSF by ecmascript on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @05:55PM (#21000500)
Nah man, the "dont say controversial shit on the job" is a very tired argument. The slippery slope is a real argument that is based in reality. Just look at events like this one and say to me with a straight face that is hasn't become 1000 times worse in the last couple of years. I say whatever I like and feel is fit for the current discussion.

If you don't like that, you may choose not to hang with me. You decide for yourself, not for me. If you think your coworker is a shitty person because what their opinions are then quit the job, don't force others to do it in order for you to have a safe space.

That is what I believe and fight for. People don't tend to realize that next time you may be the victim and then I'll defend you, the hate-crowd which you defend this time won't.

Re:Richard Stallman Resigns from CSAIL and FSF by lukebitts on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @06:11PM (#21000601)
Here I am saying with a straight face: this hasn't become a 1000 times worse in the last couple of years. Do I have any data to back this up? No. Do you? If you do I'd like to see it, otherwise this is irrelevant to the discussion.

You keep turning this discussion into something big, like this giant problem that society is facing or something and I just disagree it is that serious, that's all. Stallman was wrong and no matter how this was handled the outcome was acceptable (to me). If this happens to someone that isn't wrong then I'll be on your side next time. I won't defend someone who is wrong out of principle.

Re:Richard Stallman Resigns from CSAIL and FSF by ecmascript on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @03:31AM (#21003102)
All I have is a lot of anecdotal evidence. But it's evidence nonetheless. Stuff like this wouldn't simply not happen or noticed 10 years ago but today it is a big deal.

Well, it's because I believe it is something big and a giant problem.

Re:Richard Stallman Resigns from CSAIL and FSF by lukebitts on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @08:51AM (#21004809)
Stuff like this has been happening since at least the 60s, 20 years ago it was happening to the dixxie chicks for being against the war, 30 years ago it was happening to gay people when their bosses found out, etc. This isn't new, it just gets more attention from the media.

And anecdotal evidence is the opposite of evidence, it is meaningless. Your personal experience can be biased in so many ways I wouldn't draw any conclusions from it.

Re:Richard Stallman Resigns from CSAIL and FSF by c0ff33 on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @12:00PM (#20996770)
I think everyone is tired of these likely stories regarding Epstein, then RMS wanders in to defend a 70 year old pervert.
[dead]
Re:Richard Stallman Resigns from CSAIL and FSF by dx87 on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @10:55AM (#20995886)
Can you show me where he excused the actions of Epstein? From what I saw, he called him a serial rapist and said he deserved to be locked away in prison.
Re:Richard Stallman Resigns from CSAIL and FSF by mikeash on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @10:57AM (#20995903)
And doing so on a work related mailing list.
Re:Richard Stallman Resigns from CSAIL and FSF by homonculus1 on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @10:52AM (#20995835)
Please quote a full sentence wherein he excused the actions of Epstein.
Re:Richard Stallman Resigns from CSAIL and FSF by okmokmz on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @03:10PM (#20998974)
It's pretty incredibly how many pro-pedophile and pro-rape comments there are on HN, although I'm not surprised as this isn't the first article I've experienced this in on this site

1. "The word 'assaulting presumes that he applied force or violence, in some unspecified way, but the article says no such thing. Only they had sex" -stallman

First of all, having sex with someone unwilling is applying force. There was obviously an abuse of power at play, and to discount someone being raped because you don't think they got beaten or something similar and that somehow makes it not a sexual "assault" is twisted, disgusting, and again, rape apologism

2. "We can imagine many scenarios, but the most plausible is that she presented herself to him as entirely willing" -stallman

She said that she was raped. Saying that the "most plausible" scenario is that she was willing is clearly acting as a rape apologist. Not all woman will physically fight off the attacker when they are raped due to differences in power structure, age, physical strength, their ability to escape, etc.

>Giuffre was 17 at the time; this makes it __rape__ in the Virgin Islands

3. "Does it really? I think it is morally absurd to define "rape" in a way that depends on minor details such as which country it was in or whether the victim was 18 years old or 17" -stallman

Again, rationalizing and acting as a rape apologist for his friend who raped children. It doesn't matter whether he thinks its absurd, if you fly someone into a country or location where they are a minor, legally cannot consent, and you have sex with them you are a rapist.

I'm sure I'll get told how my liberal, PC nonsense needs to go find a safe place. I am generally the last person to support political correct nonsense that leads to censorship and other issues, but frankly what Stallman wrote was disgusting and clearly discounting rape survivors based on false assumptions and pedantry. I'm glad he lost his position and will not be able to spread such a toxic way of thinking. I'm also looking forward to all the downvotes from people supporting child rapists with no actual counterargument, as is standard on HN

[dead]
[dead]
[dead]
Re:Richard Stallman Resigns from CSAIL and FSF by tzs on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @11:11AM (#20996087)
Can you provide complete, in-context quotes from Stallman's emails to support those claims in paragraphs 3 and 4? I mean directly from Stallman's emails, not copied from Forbes or Vice or the other articles that have taken things massively out of context.
Re:Richard Stallman Resigns from CSAIL and FSF by homonculus1 on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @11:06AM (#20996025)
>What an emotional, insulting and ultimately terribly inappropriate reply for you to write on Hacker News

Please reflect on this one for a bit...