Re:Anti-intellectualism in American Life
by fzeroracer on Monday September 16, 2019 @08:16PM
(#20989877)
I'm not sure how their existence improves science, considering the questions they often demand of scientists come from no area of scientific rigor or examination.
If anything we've started seeing the clear opposite, where the climate change deniers or anti-vaxxers have been outright suppressing scientists and reports that disagree with their skepticism.
Re:Anti-intellectualism in American Life
by davidcuddeback on Monday September 16, 2019 @08:04PM
(#20989798)
That would make sense if science was a monoculture and could only be challenged from the outside, but scientists question each others' findings all the time. You can't have a scientific process without scrutiny.
Re:Anti-intellectualism in American Life
by quibono on Monday September 16, 2019 @08:15PM
(#20989868)
Why couldn't it be both? Internal scruitny is necessary but I'd say that how well communicated research is influences how much funding and attention it gets which obviously matters a lot in shaping the scientific community.
Re:Anti-intellectualism in American Life
by bllguo on Monday September 16, 2019 @08:17PM
(#20989885)
but I acknowledge that questioning your beliefs is good. It's foundational to the scientific method. I just don't see how uninformed challenges are worthwhile. At this point things like vaccine effectiveness are basic facts. What more can scientists do?
It's like how competition tends to make companies provide better service, even if the competition never actually steals a single customer away. The fact that it could changes the incentives in a way that makes you do your job more rigorously.