Re:Anti-intellectualism in American Life
by wtallis on Monday September 16, 2019 @07:30PM
(#20989586)
Do you think India, Russia and China have been notable for achievement in those categories on any kind of per capita basis rather than through sheer scale?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Anti-intellectualism in American Life
by oarabbus_ on Monday September 16, 2019 @07:36PM
(#20989616)
Well - I think that's an unanswerable question.
My gut says that "any country if given the same economic opportunities could produce equal achievement". Obviously, that's in a completely idealized world.
As it stands in actual, real life across human history, I do think that India, Russia, and China are more notable than most countries if we look at those criteria across history, but with "extra weight" given to modern day (e.g. Greece would not qualify with the "extra modern day weight" scale, but would be highly ranked if we only looked historically).
All 3 belong in an "unranked top 5". Just my personal opinion.
Obviously Western Europe and the US have achieved more on a per capita basis given they are areas where the Scientific Revolution and industrialization occurred. I would say intellectual achievements is driven by the number upper-middle class individuals instead of the entire population.
Rough guess of share of present day intellectual production by country (I like to make stuff up):
US: 30% Western Europe: 30% China: 15% Japan: 5% India: 5% CIS countries: 5%
I agree. If you have a billion people you should have 3 times the intellectual achievement as the US.