Re:Scientists Demonstrate Mammalian Regeneration Through a S...
by Zak on Thursday January 13, 2011 @12:02AM
(#2098908)
I think an important question to research here is why p21 evolved in mammals. The article says knocking it out doesn't appear to increase cancer rates, which would have been my first and only guess.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Scientists Demonstrate Mammalian Regeneration Through a S...
by chc on Thursday January 13, 2011 @03:09AM
(#2099199)
My guess would be that regeneration is too big a drain on the metabolism. Compared to the animals with that ability, mammals have positively ridiculous energy needs already. It may be that better healing from wounds is not sufficiently useful to make up for the strain that the healing itself entails.
Re:Scientists Demonstrate Mammalian Regeneration Through a S...
by arethuza on Thursday January 13, 2011 @04:17AM
(#2099302)
So weight reduction (or the ability to eat more food and stay the same weight) and regeneration - now that does sound good!
Re:Scientists Demonstrate Mammalian Regeneration Through a S...
by bpd1069 on Thursday January 13, 2011 @07:04AM
(#2099554)
That's a simple one, chicks dig scars...
Re:Scientists Demonstrate Mammalian Regeneration Through a S...
by mickdarling on Thursday January 13, 2011 @05:03PM
(#2101518)
I seem to remember reading a while ago that the immune system in animals with regenerative ability needs to be stronger because the blastoma wound is "open" longer and more prone to infection. For humans today we can mitigate infection pretty well relative to a pretty much any mammal in the wild.
Re:Scientists Demonstrate Mammalian Regeneration Through a S...
by lotusleaf1987 on Thursday January 13, 2011 @01:06AM
(#2099021)
Maybe somehow it speeds up the system of evolution by keeping life expectancies shorter, thereby increasing turnover (death and new births)? I have no clue just throwing that out there.
Re:Scientists Demonstrate Mammalian Regeneration Through a S...
by srean on Thursday January 13, 2011 @01:30AM
(#2099058)
To survive natural selection the gene must give the animal some reproductive advantage. I can understand that promoting longevity beyond the reproductive stage of one's life cycle affords no such benefit. But one still has to account for the fact that the lack of the gene appears to increase the survivability in the reproductive pahse as well. Something more must be going on.
Re:Scientists Demonstrate Mammalian Regeneration Through a S...
by ckuehne on Thursday January 13, 2011 @04:13AM
(#2099298)
Strictly speaking, it must give the _gene_ a reproductive advantage, not necessarily the animal. Often, these two advantages are aligned. But they need not be. This is the case in kin altruism. And this is also, why "promoting longevity beyond the reproductive stage of one's life cycle" affords sometimes very much such benefits. Example: grandparents can help raising their children's children (and their children's children's children ;)). Kin altruism becomes even more apparent in ants (or other social animals). Worker ants or bees are pretty much infertile but they help a lot.
Re:Scientists Demonstrate Mammalian Regeneration Through a S...
by btilly on Thursday January 13, 2011 @08:47AM
(#2099726)
It should be noted that the difference is much more extreme for ants than it can be for mammals due to a genetic quirk where a female ant shares 50% of her genes with her children and 75% with her sisters. (Therefore having more sisters is better than having children.)
Re:Scientists Demonstrate Mammalian Regeneration Through a S...
by ckuehne on Thursday January 13, 2011 @09:15AM
(#2099803)
Still there are mammals that live eusocial. The naked mole rat comes to mind.
Re:Scientists Demonstrate Mammalian Regeneration Through a S...
by bambax on Thursday January 13, 2011 @03:19AM
(#2099216)
> To survive natural selection the gene must give the animal some reproductive advantage.
Most probably, but not necessarily.
A gene can be present without being useful because it is linked to another gene that is itself useful; or it can be a leftover from an earlier moment of evolution where it was useful, and then it ceased to be useful but there was never an evolution pressure strong enough to have it disappear.
In summary, just because a gene is present and active does not mean it's useful today.
Re:Scientists Demonstrate Mammalian Regeneration Through a S...
by moozilla on Friday January 14, 2011 @02:28AM
(#2102864)
Not necessarily. The mutation could have survived for any number of reasons including genetic drift. As long as it didn't kill the organism right away there wouldn't be significant negative pressure to get rid of it.
Re:Scientists Demonstrate Mammalian Regeneration Through a S...
by Tycho on Thursday January 13, 2011 @02:36AM
(#2099145)
Perhaps not having the ability to regenerate leads to more cautious behaviour, avoiding life threatening situations to a much greater extent? Puzzling...
Re:Scientists Demonstrate Mammalian Regeneration Through a S...
by endtime on Thursday January 13, 2011 @09:10AM
(#2099784)
I don't think the ability to regenerate means that losing a limb doesn't hurt...
Re:Scientists Demonstrate Mammalian Regeneration Through a S...
by DavidSJ on Thursday January 13, 2011 @09:48AM
(#2099910)
Individual organisms don't work for "the system of evolution"'s benefit. They work for themselves.
Re:Scientists Demonstrate Mammalian Regeneration Through a S...
by JoeAltmaier on Thursday January 13, 2011 @10:12AM
(#2099995)
But mammals do! They are social creatures. A social group that has more efficient food use due to turnover of injured members would be selected for.
Re:Scientists Demonstrate Mammalian Regeneration Through a S...
by jessriedel on Thursday January 13, 2011 @11:13AM
(#2100231)
Group-selection explanations are rarely correct.
Re:Scientists Demonstrate Mammalian Regeneration Through a S...
by JoeAltmaier on Thursday January 13, 2011 @01:17PM
(#2100716)
Yet empirically the effect exists.