News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Australia’s 4G network is faster than 5G: study by crispinb on Monday September 16, 2019 @05:01PM (#20988550)
Well I don't know about faster than 5G, but for my rural location it's a lifesaver. I get a steady 60Mbps down, 12-15 up, which is just a tad better than my previous 0.3Mbps ADSL. It's kind of amazing and is literally what enables me to live where I do (ie. for remote work).

4g here is also far better than the shithouse fake NBN foisted on us by our far-right government, which loathes and fears any technology more recent than coal & witch burning.

Re:Australia’s 4G network is faster than 5G: study by emmelaich on Monday September 16, 2019 @06:19PM (#20989116)
Good post until the last sentence! NBN history is far more interesting than that!

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Broadband_Network

Re:Australia’s 4G network is faster than 5G: study by paranoidrobot on Monday September 16, 2019 @07:59PM (#20989759)
I have to say that it's interesting in the way that watching something be destroyed is interesting.

Being stuck inside it is not interesting, it's horrifying and depressing.

I moved into an apartment that was built with NBN Fibre to every apartment. I moved here and paid a premium for it because I wanted to get a head-start on the FTTH rollout we were promised.

Instead of the promised ability to move just about anywhere and get the same connection quality and bandwidth options, we now have a roulette wheel where most of the options are mediocre at best.

Worse still, we paid even more for this bungled mix of copper based tech than the original FTTH rollout.

Re:Australia’s 4G network is faster than 5G: study by fertibm on Monday September 16, 2019 @08:53PM (#20990104)
Fiber would never be available in every home, it would have always been limited to new estates and inner city areas, which funnily enough is no change over how things were before the nbn. Before the nbn, new estates were supplied with private fiber. Now they get nbn, which will be sold in the future and be private again.... all that changed was billions of dollars were stolen by the political class.
Re:Australia’s 4G network is faster than 5G: study by rosege on Monday September 16, 2019 @09:30PM (#20990320)
Fibre was going to be rolled out to 93% of the population - so very remote people would have been on satellie but that would have been it.
Re:Australia’s 4G network is faster than 5G: study by fertimb_ on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @01:14AM (#20991813)
No, that was their made up promise to fool people who couldn't research the logistics themselves, that is not what was going to happen. Name another country in the entire world where this has happened with similar population density. You can't, because no such country exists. If that actually happened, and it was completed today, Australia would have the world's fastest internet, ahead of all of the countries with extremely dense population such as Taiwan. Such an idea is absurd, but people on the left will never admit it and just claim that is was obviously going to happen.
Re:Australia’s 4G network is faster than 5G: study by crispinb on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @02:59AM (#20992420)
Arrant nonsense. It was a specific plan, budgeted for, with people in government and industry I knew at the time working on it. Even bloody Malcolm Turnbull was bullish about it (he was on the board of a company I worked for in Brisbane) until he turned. It was going to happen but was scotched for purely political reasons by a party that had always opposed public provision.

Big projects, govenment & commercial alike often fail. The real NBN certainly might have. But to make up out of a complete vacuum that it was some sort of deliberate con is just another barmy conspiracy theory.

Re:Australia’s 4G network is faster than 5G: study by fertibm__ on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @03:55AM (#20992713)
>It was a specific plan, budgeted for I like how you call what I said "arrant nonsense". Such a harsh response must have been followed up by some irrefutable facts for justification. Instead, your argument is "it was budgeted for". This level of nativity is complete lack of knowledge of planning and budgeting and forecasting models shouldn't be coupled with your big boy harsh words.

Lets see, Kevin Rudd said it would cost $15 billion. The total cost at the moment seems to be $51 billion. So your conspiracy theory is that the crappier NBN we got which required less work cost $36 billion more than the one you are saying was budgeted for?

Re:Australia’s 4G network is faster than 5G: study by paranoidrobot on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @04:48AM (#20993025)
First, can I ask why you're creating multiple new accounts to comment? It seems very odd.

> Kevin Rudd said it would cost $15 billion.

The first 90% fibre plan was $43b, later revised down to $37.4b of which it was supposed to be $30b of investment from the Federal government. [0]

About $12b of that was in payments to Telstra ($11b) and Optus ($800m) in return for access to lead-in and last-mile conduits/pits, and decommissioning of HFC networks.

That original business plan was revised later after a KPMG study to recommend ~93% fibre, ~4% fixed wireless (LTE variant), and the remaining ~2-3% on two dedicated satellites (new launches).

(Edited to add: Note that this plan included an eventual ROI, where the government would get it's money back - and hence it be zero/low cost. The current plan has no hope of that happening short of selling the entire thing off to Telstra.)

FTTH installations were budgeted at $1500/residence to install, which by the time the Abbott government was coming into power was actually trending closer to $1200 as the workforce was trained up in deploying the gear and became more experienced in dealing with any odd situations.

There is/was a fantastic video of a talk given by someone from NBNCo (I believe Mike Quigly?) at a University where they go over the architectural design decisions, and how the 93% number was arrived at. The video also went over in detail how the fixed-wireless process was to work.

Arguments that remediating conduit and installing new copper is either cheaper or less work to install aren't backed up by evidence, with NBNCo's current cost for FTTC being somewhere over $3000/residence in 2019[1].

Additionally, because there's now FTTP, FTTN, FTTC, HFC, Fixed-Wireless and Satellite - the whole network is harder to manage and maintain. You need a bigger, more widely trained workforce, you have more equipment to maintain, and more vendors to deal with.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_National_Broadb...

[1] https://www.itnews.com.au/news/nbn-cos-actual-cost-per-premi...

Re:Australia’s 4G network is faster than 5G: study by flukus on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @02:47AM (#20992352)
Fiber isn't rolled out in a uniform grid pattern across the country, so population density is irrelevant.

We are one of the most urbanized countries in the world, more so than many who have rolled out fiber.

Re:Australia’s 4G network is faster than 5G: study by zizee on Monday September 16, 2019 @06:32PM (#20989204)
Agreed. As per the HN guidelines:

> Please don't use Hacker News for political or ideological battle

HN is a great place for considered discussion. Let's keep it that way.

Re:Australia’s 4G network is faster than 5G: study by baroffoos on Monday September 16, 2019 @07:25PM (#20989558)
To be fair, it's a true statement. The NBN is shithouse and compared to what was promised originally, it could be considered fake.
Re:Australia’s 4G network is faster than 5G: study by zizee on Monday September 16, 2019 @07:59PM (#20989765)
This is the part that is questionable:

> our far-right government, which loathes and fears any technology more recent than coal & witch burning.

Re:Australia’s 4G network is faster than 5G: study by manicdee on Monday September 16, 2019 @08:32PM (#20989972)
Let sleeping dogs lie, is my advice here.
Re:Australia’s 4G network is faster than 5G: study by crispinb on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @12:20AM (#20991498)
Yes, let's do that please. The tone wasn't right for HN.
Re:Australia’s 4G network is faster than 5G: study by baroffoos on Monday September 16, 2019 @10:58PM (#20990894)
If you live in Australia you would probably agree that thats not far from the truth either.
Re:Australia’s 4G network is faster than 5G: study by rbp on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @11:48AM (#20996609)
I live in Australia and most people I know would disagree with that statement. Depends on your social circles.
Re:Australia’s 4G network is faster than 5G: study by okmokmz on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @02:44PM (#20998714)
As an outsider I don't have much insight to Australian politics, but all I've read about recently is their stance on fossil fuels and encryption. Based on that, from an outside perspective, I'd be very inclined to agree with that statement. Out of curiosity, in what ways is it untrue?
Re:Australia’s 4G network is faster than 5G: study by crispinb on Monday September 16, 2019 @06:35PM (#20989230)
Fair point.
Re:Australia’s 4G network is faster than 5G: study by crispinb on Monday September 16, 2019 @06:25PM (#20989160)
It was a bit of snark not to be taken too seriously, though with regard to the trogs' fear of technology, it has more than a grain of truth ;)
Re:Australia’s 4G network is faster than 5G: study by sjwright on Monday September 16, 2019 @10:42PM (#20990775)
To the person with the "dead" reply musing about Stephen Conroy being a luddite—I wrote that April fools parody article. Yes, Conroy started off as an embarrassing luddite __BUT__ unlike the luddites that came before him, he improved. He learned. He grew. He surrounded himself with smart, experienced and informed people, and he learned from them. By the time he departed that role he had morphed into perhaps the best communications ministers in recent Australian history.

---------

Whereas you can watch the moment of television where all respect I had for Malcolm Turnbull crashed into the floor (fast forward to the 17 minute mark and watch for about one minute):

https://www.abc.net.au/news/2013-08-12/nbn-debate/4882232

"Anthony said that fibre to the premises can deliver one gigabit per second, 1000 megs, and you're quite right, it can. Do you know what it would cost to have a guaranteed one gig' service? At least $20,000 a month."

So basically Turnbull used a deceptive truth (the cost of a high speed service with dedicated guaranteed backhaul) to blatantly and intentionally lie about the cost of gigabit services that would be sold to 99.9% of NBN-connected customers. The fact that he knew enough to concoct this deception made me realise that he wasn't just as bad as the rest of them, he's worse. He used his knowledge and intelligence to cleverly and carefully craft a statement that's blatantly false yet defensible as technically true if he were caught out. Nobody is that clever by accident.

Re:Australia’s 4G network is faster than 5G: study by hug on Monday September 16, 2019 @05:33PM (#20988783)
For some people, 4G is definitely better than NBN. Not all people.

I’m not saying the NBN isn’t a trash fire of an infrastructure project (it is), or that our 4G is bad (it isn’t), but at least for me I get rock solid 100/40 on HFC, which is for sure better than my NBN service in inner-North Melbourne

Re:Australia’s 4G network is faster than 5G: study by crispinb on Monday September 16, 2019 @05:40PM (#20988846)
Yes of course you're right. In a way that's the big problem with the NBN - a 'national infrastructure' project that is a complete lottery regarding what you get is not worth the name.

40 odd km from me there are estates wired up with NBN's original FTTP. Yet in my location, all that's available is the hopeless Sky Muster satellite service, which tends to go offline for days at a time, and has trouble with weird contingencies like rain. It was originally slated as a last-ditch option for people in truly remote areas, but the hapless NBN Co has gradually extended its use to anywhere they can't be arsed to serve properly.

[Edit: as a side note, my location shows the corporate fakery behind the 'mixed tech' model. Using a cheap 4g modem from ebay, and without even so much as a fixed antenna, I can get 60Mbps down with 4g. Yet NBNCo doesn't make the fixed wireless option available here, instead foisting on us the 'outback solution' of satellite with its 600ms ping times, pitiful data caps & unreliability]

Re:Australia’s 4G network is faster than 5G: study by tenryuu on Monday September 16, 2019 @09:20PM (#20990268)
It's interesting, becusee I moved from FTTC getting 100/40 to HFC and still getting 100/40.

Each technology has their own hardware faults though, and I've witnessed both. But as a user of the service, I'm actually surprised how decent HFC has been working.

My parents of FTTN get about 50/20,which is what I expect a lot of users on these lines would only be able to access. But the sheer cost of using a NBN over 4G makes it a lot easier to sell, data sims are not cheap

Re:Australia’s 4G network is faster than 5G: study by rosege on Monday September 16, 2019 @09:35PM (#20990354)
What about your latency? - Ive tested FTTP and got around 3ms to 8.8.8.8 but hfc its around 30+ Any idea what FTTC would be?
Re:Australia’s 4G network is faster than 5G: study by tenryuu on Monday September 16, 2019 @11:12PM (#20991002)
Getting ~20ms on HFC, with 12ms to our BNGv(first hop)

I no longer have a FTTC connection to test, but I don't think it's 3ms low.

Using AussieBB. It's around 20ms from Sydney to Melbourne on our routes

Re:Australia’s 4G network is faster than 5G: study by rosege on Monday September 16, 2019 @11:40PM (#20991184)
Yeah I'm going with Aussie too.
Re:Australia’s 4G network is faster than 5G: study by anderspitman on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @12:11PM (#20996900)
I grew up rural. First internet connection I used at home was a 14.4k connection through my dad's Startac. I used to have to put a rubber band on the connector to keep it properly plugged into the phone for data. Eventually we got a 1Mpbs microwave connection from a local WISP. It was a huge improvement in a lot of ways but the latency was terrible and very jittery.

Now when I go back to my parent's house I get 10+ Mbps 4G on Verizon and Tmobile. It's awesome.

Re:Australia’s 4G network is faster than 5G: study by quickthrower2 on Monday September 16, 2019 @06:30PM (#20989189)
Are you affected by weather? Do you use a directional antenna?
Re:Australia’s 4G network is faster than 5G: study by crispinb on Monday September 16, 2019 @06:43PM (#20989292)
I don't need an antenna - I get a good enough signal with my modem stashed in the rafters. I'm about 12km from a 4g tower, but it's up on a decent hill which is nearly line of sight.

I did have to go through a few modems to find one that worked reliably. Oddly enough, an old Huawei B315s has turned out to be by far the best for my situation. I've tried fancier models that multiplex radio bands, but they were slower and less reliable.

Weather seems to have little to no effect. What does sometimes cause a problem is tourist influxes to the nearest town. The occasional big weekend event can bring speeds down to 12Mbps or so. Still, I'm not complaining and consider ubiquitous internet availability a kind of modern miracle.

Re:Australia’s 4G network is faster than 5G: study by jjtheblunt on Monday September 16, 2019 @05:55PM (#20988953)
NBN ?
Re:Australia’s 4G network is faster than 5G: study by cstrat on Monday September 16, 2019 @06:01PM (#20989004)
It is an acronym for the National Broadband Network. A government owned enterprise which was supposed to build a ubiquitous broadband network covering Australia but has been plagued with political meddling and interference since the get-go.
Re:Australia’s 4G network is faster than 5G: study by quickthrower2 on Monday September 16, 2019 @06:32PM (#20989207)
My residence now has NBN as an option. I have decided to wait a year or two. Going for NBN is a bit of a gamble. My OK-ish ADSL connection is finally working without interruptions, and on forums people with NBN are talking about resetting their modem several times a day, coaxial cable connections need to be perfect otherwise it doesn't work etc. Sad really to miss out, but I am prioritizing uptime over speed. The UK got this right in the late 90's by connecting cable to almost every residence (IIRC).
Re:Australia’s 4G network is faster than 5G: study by fertibm on Monday September 16, 2019 @08:47PM (#20990073)
Errr... our government isn’t far right, and the disaster of the nbn was created by the left, and made worse by the right. The narrative being repeated in this and other left wing sites like reddit of “the nbn would have been good if it was all fiber” is just wrong.

The nbn from its conception was a half-baked, last minute idea made up by Kevin Rudd. If any public network was needed, it should have been wireless. The nbn discounted any possible future that resulted in wireless being a viable way of delivering the internet to everyone. Wireless is also necessary because things aren’t stationary. Cars can’t use fiber internet, for example. Fiber to every home is ridiculously expensive, with a large percentage of homes not even using any more bandwidth than is required to stream Netflix. Fiber also excludes rural areas, and any lower density areas in general.

A public wireless network would be utilised much more, as even a lower speed wireless network that is available everywhere and cheaper opens up more possibilities than a limited high speed network. It isn’t just speed that is important. We also have the issue of data caps. High speed connections that have 20gb per month data caps are pretty useless, yet a large percentage of the population can’t afford any more than that. The nbn, whether fiber or not, would always just result in a product a large percentage of normal people couldn’t even utilise.

The liberal party made the nbn worse, but it was a terrible idea to begin with. All the political parties are corrupt.

Re:Australia’s 4G network is faster than 5G: study by ntSean on Monday September 16, 2019 @09:32PM (#20990336)
>If any public network was needed, it should have been wireless.

I don't believe the rural NBN customers on Wireless Satellite technology would support this premise.

Even customers in suburban shopping centres struggle with their cellular connection - hence Free Wifi being so ubiquitous.

But regardless, our conservative government relies on minerals and education rather than investing in Australia's ability to compete in a digital world.

So here's hoping we can keep up with developed nations who are making use of the high-bandwidth infrastructure made available to them today.

Re:Australia’s 4G network is faster than 5G: study by jussij on Monday September 16, 2019 @10:40PM (#20990749)
> the disaster of the nbn was created by the left, and made worse by the right

The left proposed an NBN based on 'fiber to the home' technology.

The right threw out that plan and replaced it with 'fiber to the node and copper to the home' technology.

Now it is hard to say if the NBN proposed by the left would have been a disaster as it was only rolled out to a few place. But being fiber based it would at least have been future proofed.

However, now that the most of the money has been spent and the NBN copper system is nearing completion, we are seeing that the NBN as it now stands is a total disaster.

It is already obsolete before it is complete.

Re:Australia’s 4G network is faster than 5G: study by fraudsyndrome on Monday September 16, 2019 @11:38PM (#20991165)
> Now it is hard to say if the NBN proposed by the left would have been a disaster as it was only rolled out to a few place.

Can people not see and pros/cons based on suburbs that have fttp/ftth?

You can do the same with fttn based on some suburbs - where people who have paid for 100Mbps end up only getting 20Mbps during peak hour