Re:Bing Beats Google In 20-Search Shootout
by kenjackson on Wednesday January 12, 2011 @05:57PM
(#2098067)
I've been using Bing as my primary and Google as my back up now for almost a year. I almost can feel when Google will be better than Bing and vice-versa.
If you look at marketshare,you'd think Google was years ahead. Really they're pretty much at parity, with different achilles heels.
If I were MS I'd push hard into nailing the mobile experience. I thik if they can make Bing an early player in mobile search... they have a good chance of evenly splitting mobile share with Google.
Re:Bing Beats Google In 20-Search Shootout
by b_emery on Wednesday January 12, 2011 @06:36PM
(#2098182)
> I almost can feel when Google will be better than Bing and vice-versa.
Can you please share some of those incites? I never use bing but have had trouble with google on occasion. Finding a home appliance manual can be pretty frustrating.
Re:Bing Beats Google In 20-Search Shootout
by kenjackson on Wednesday January 12, 2011 @06:49PM
(#2098216)
In general I feel like this... the more info I have the better Google will be. The less info I have the better Bing will be.
This isn't a hard and fast rule, but it tends to feel that way.
Like I did a search for "c# async video", looking for this video I saw before with Anders talking about Async. Bing gets the video I'm looking for as the second link. Google doesn't have it in the first few pages (didn't look any further). Adding "Anders" to the search doesn't seem to help Google. But then adding "Anders channel9" got it to the top of the list.
Unfortunately for you, I think finding home appliance manuals is something that I "feel" will be better on Google. Because you typically have very specific info (model number, brand, etc..).
Bing is great when I know what I'm looking for, but don't have details on it. I like Google when I'm looking for something obscure, but I have detailed info on it.
With that said, my hunch is even less scientific than this article.
Re:Bing Beats Google In 20-Search Shootout
by basman on Wednesday January 12, 2011 @07:38PM
(#2098328)
So let's say you're doing an everyday search for something such as researching a new camera. Would you consider the probability of someone eavesdropping on your communication times the amount of harm they could likely cause to you using that information to outweigh any amount of improvement in search result quality? I'm not trying to be facetious — just genuinely curious if that's how your utility function works.
Re:Bing Beats Google In 20-Search Shootout
by TomOfTTB on Wednesday January 12, 2011 @07:29PM
(#2098305)
That would only make the decision simple if you absolutely had to use only one search engine. You could just as easily use Google's encrypted interface for insecure connections and Bing at home IF you thought Bing was better.
Re:Bing Beats Google In 20-Search Shootout
by forgotAgain on Wednesday January 12, 2011 @05:46PM
(#2098038)
I'm going to give bing a try. I'm tired of google search results listings that have too many clone sites full of content copied from stackoverflow, wikipedia, and project mailing lists.
Re:Bing Beats Google In 20-Search Shootout
by hardtke on Wednesday January 12, 2011 @08:27PM
(#2098421)
The problem with this study is that the tested search queries are completely different than what people type into a search engine. Besides being 30% vile, real search queries are very tailored to search engines algorithms -- two to three words, maximal idf (inverse document frequency). People type in the minimum number of least commonly used terms that distinguish what they want.
Both Google and Bing use human evaluators (sometimes with domain expertise) to evaluate real queries against the search results. None of those real queries look anything like these.
Unfortunately, their hasn't been a good public release of search engine query data since the AOL fiasco.
Re:Bing Beats Google In 20-Search Shootout
by hristov on Wednesday January 12, 2011 @07:53PM
(#2098354)
I think the instant search function of google makes it much much more convenient than bing. See now I can type my search terms and look at the results as I am typing. If I am not liking the results, I just keep typing (i.e., narrowing my search), or change some misleading search terms.
This real time searching, is much faster, or at least feels much faster than the old way of typing a query, hitting enter, waiting for the results, thinking whether you should change your query or just look at the next page of results, etc.
At this point Bing just kind of feels like the old generation of technology.
Re:Bing Beats Google In 20-Search Shootout
by code_duck on Wednesday January 12, 2011 @06:23PM
(#2098146)
It's rare that I have to go farther than page two, if even that, to find what I'm looking for on Google. I don't see how Bing could be 'better' enough to make a difference to me.
Re:Bing Beats Google In 20-Search Shootout
by code_duck on Wednesday January 12, 2011 @07:59PM
(#2098365)
I suppose that's what I meant without realizing it. I'm more likely to alter the search terms than go to the next pages.
So, I guess the goal is to make a search that more accurately guesses your intention, without you having to make it clear. I suppose that goal is obvious but I'm not sure whether it even make sense.
It seems like Microsoft is fighting the battles of the last decade. If Bing came out in 2001 it would be a lot different. Do they have anything more innovative in the cards than a 'better Google'?
Re:Bing Beats Google In 20-Search Shootout
by orenmazor on Thursday January 13, 2011 @04:19PM
(#2101362)
DDG is awesome when I'm looking something specific up, but when I'm not sure what I'm looking for it seems to fall apart. I guess thats where google's incorrect/random result helps.
Sounds convincing!
"Not too surprisingly, there was not a massive disparity in the results of my little test."
1. http://searchengineland.com/google-vs-bing-the-fallacy-of-th...
If you look at marketshare,you'd think Google was years ahead. Really they're pretty much at parity, with different achilles heels.
If I were MS I'd push hard into nailing the mobile experience. I thik if they can make Bing an early player in mobile search... they have a good chance of evenly splitting mobile share with Google.
Can you please share some of those incites? I never use bing but have had trouble with google on occasion. Finding a home appliance manual can be pretty frustrating.
This isn't a hard and fast rule, but it tends to feel that way.
Like I did a search for "c# async video", looking for this video I saw before with Anders talking about Async. Bing gets the video I'm looking for as the second link. Google doesn't have it in the first few pages (didn't look any further). Adding "Anders" to the search doesn't seem to help Google. But then adding "Anders channel9" got it to the top of the list.
Unfortunately for you, I think finding home appliance manuals is something that I "feel" will be better on Google. Because you typically have very specific info (model number, brand, etc..).
Bing is great when I know what I'm looking for, but don't have details on it. I like Google when I'm looking for something obscure, but I have detailed info on it.
With that said, my hunch is even less scientific than this article.
1) I'm sometimes using untrusted networks (e.g., Wifi)
2) Google offers an SSL encrypted interface
3) Bing doesn't
Only Semi-Related: Everyone who uses Google SSL should be aware of this: http://www.seofaststart.com/blog/ssl-search-referral-data
Both Google and Bing use human evaluators (sometimes with domain expertise) to evaluate real queries against the search results. None of those real queries look anything like these.
Unfortunately, their hasn't been a good public release of search engine query data since the AOL fiasco.
This real time searching, is much faster, or at least feels much faster than the old way of typing a query, hitting enter, waiting for the results, thinking whether you should change your query or just look at the next page of results, etc.
At this point Bing just kind of feels like the old generation of technology.
So, I guess the goal is to make a search that more accurately guesses your intention, without you having to make it clear. I suppose that goal is obvious but I'm not sure whether it even make sense.
It seems like Microsoft is fighting the battles of the last decade. If Bing came out in 2001 it would be a lot different. Do they have anything more innovative in the cards than a 'better Google'?
In related news. My brother is bigger and stronger than yours so SHUT UP!