News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by bb101 on Sunday September 15, 2019 @06:12AM (#20976463)
"Ferrier sat his Leaving Certificate exams last month at Schull Community College and is due to attend university in the Netherlands. The teenager works as a curator at the Schull Planetarium, has won 12 science fair awards, speaks three languages fluently, plays the trumpet at orchestra level, and had a minor planet named after him by the MIT Lincoln Laboratory."

Anyone else feeling somewhat inadequate in comparison?

Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by barking on Sunday September 15, 2019 @07:11AM (#20976701)
Sounds like he has parents from different countries, first name is Irish, surname sounds Portuguese(?) so head start there on the language front, perhaps. Schull is a very small community, couple of thousand max but there's been a lot of 'alternative' type immigration there from other first world countries, artists etc from places like England (eg Jeremy irons), Netherlands so its secondary school is pretty progressive afaik. They have a slipway to the bay right next to the school so the school does sailing classes etc. The planetarium in question is a stone's throw from the school. County Cork has a youth orchestra. Overall not the worst place in the world to grow up.
Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by madez on Sunday September 15, 2019 @09:57AM (#20977216)
This reads like a figurative kick in the face to those who argue against free education and social programmes "because the market will solve it and those that work hard enough will make it, so it's fair". The world is deeply unjust economically and the vast majority loses from that, and those, that manage the inquality by using the cheap larbor and forced constraints of the disadvantaged to serve the more fortunate ones, win. Even the fortunate ones win from rich neighbours, so there should be a big consensus for universal conditionless free education, social security and health insurance backed by the government.

I know this might be interpreted as a flamebait and I see the common "but the government is incompetent/corrupt/inefficient" answers already, but those don't negate what I just wrote in any way upon closer inspection. However, this is genuinely how I feel and I feel stupidified when I see how these programmes aren't yet serious international standards.

Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by leftyted on Sunday September 15, 2019 @11:00AM (#20977491)
> there should be a big consensus for universal conditionless free education, social security and health insurance backed by the government.

You allude to the best argument for these things, something like: "people are born into the world with a set of advantages and disadvantages they neither earned nor deserve, so we should do our best to even the playing field".

But you missed the mark in terms of identifying the best argument from the other side. "Because the market will solve it and those that work hard enough will make it, so it's fair" is not the argument. That's a just world hypothesis. The good argument is: high taxes and large social programs distort economic incentives; if you "tax the rich at 70%," people will behave differently, and your society will be less wealthy as a result. Which would you rather have? A wealthy society with inequality or a poor society without inequality? Anyway, the fundamental point here is that all human progress is agonistic, and "evening the playing field" will result in less progress, not more.

We're trying to walk the line between these two perspectives. We have "free" social programs but wealth still buys all kinds of advantages. I think we're doing a fairly good job, but it's imperative that we take both sides of this argument seriously. There's no reason to think we can have our cake and eat it.

Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by madez on Sunday September 15, 2019 @11:13AM (#20977559)
> Which would you rather have? A wealthy society with inequality or a poor society without inequality?

This is a good as in goodwill and honest point here. However, I think it isn't a dichotomy based on evidence. For example, most of northern Europe has these programmes and they are not poor, and there exist many poor countries without these programmes. If I thought these programmes would leave the people less wealthy, healthy, happy, I would be against them.

If the programmes create negative incentives in people as to not be productive and successful to a degree that offsets the advantages in reduced crime, more tax because of higher educated people and thus salary and countless other and not easily measured advantages like progress on science, culture, and art, then I would be against those programmes. This is however not what we are seeing. It is a scary shadow on the wall while we can see the cute bunny in the foreground with our eyes directly.

Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by Retric on Sunday September 15, 2019 @11:54AM (#20977773)
That’s a falsifiable argument. US has averaged faster economic growth with high marginal tax rates than low ones. The reality is rich people have no choice but to invest their wealth or inflation eats it up. The only real change from 15% to 70% marginal tax rates is the amount of effort put into tax avoidance. The reason for this is maximizing income occurs before taxes are calculated, so you can get nearly identical behavior independent of tax rates.

Further, equality of opportunity is surprisingly cheap over time. You end up with more capable workforce which pays for the cost of maintaining it.

PS: Now targeted deductions are another story, those can cause real economic harm.

Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by leftyted on Sunday September 15, 2019 @12:08PM (#20977853)
I don't think you've falsified the argument. Maybe you would have if economic growth and marginal tax rates are the only variables.

I think it's pretty clear that progressive taxes create negative incentives, particularly when it comes to encouraging people to get rich in the first place (which usually means starting a business).

> Further, equality of opportunity is surprisingly cheap over time. You end up with more capable workforce which pays for the cost of training it.

Yeah, the question is where to draw the line. Public education seems like something we definitely want. But if we truly want equality of opportunity, I don't think we can have communities like this:

> Schull is a very small community, couple of thousand max but there's been a lot of 'alternative' type immigration there from other first world countries, artists etc from places like England (eg Jeremy irons), Netherlands so its secondary school is pretty progressive afaik. They have a slipway to the bay right next to the school so the school does sailing classes etc. The planetarium in question is a stone's throw from the school. County Cork has a youth orchestra. Overall not the worst place in the world to grow up.

Everyone can't have sailing lessons and a planetarium.

Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by Retric on Sunday September 15, 2019 @12:39PM (#20978037)
Plenty of evidence for the same thing exist in other countries. Which is my point, if that’s your line of argument you need to verify it not just assume it to be true.

Anyway, few people are going to turn down becoming rich because they end up with only 100 million instead of 300 million dollars. Opportunity however plays an important role and again you can measure relative importance via social mobility. Comparing different counties at different time periods and once again Opportunity ends up far more important than high but not punitive tax rates.

We are never going to have absolutely identical opportunity for everyone in society. But, these are not platonic ideals rather measurable and testable pragmatic choices.

Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by tripzilch on Monday September 16, 2019 @09:03AM (#20983579)
> Which would you rather have? A wealthy society with inequality or a poor society without inequality?

Is a powerful false dichotomy argued by the rich. It is NOT a poor society, but people fear they would be less rich, when 99% of them won't be if you add in the societal benefits.

Just having good education is going to make your country wealthier in a generation.

Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by skybrian on Sunday September 15, 2019 @12:02PM (#20977824)
That's ok as far as it goes, but it's not very far. To be convincing, the argument about negative incentives resulting in lower growth needs to be expanded on more than it usually is. (Or is reasonable to do in casual conversation.)
Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by 52-6F-62 on Sunday September 15, 2019 @10:00AM (#20977229)
You’re not alone there. Ontario is battling it out over this (once again). It’s regretful that it’s even a question anymore.
Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by cheez on Sunday September 15, 2019 @10:37AM (#20977379)
A few years ago, we were considering relocating to Toronto. We went to a school and had a meeting with the principal of the local school. This principal said to us in no uncertain terms that if we can afford private school, to not send our children to public school in Toronto. Now, could this be a selfish reason on his part? Sure, but I doubt it. He walked us through why.

Toronto is huge.

What you see with the teenager in question is a small town with decent enough resources. And that is the decision we took ultimately: to move to a small town with rich residents.

Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by 52-6F-62 on Sunday September 15, 2019 @12:24PM (#20977936)
I grew up on the other side of that coin—a small town without enough resources. It wasn’t the worst of them, but when school boards were amalgamated it sparked internal politics as to where funding was allocated. I was a kid, so I wasn’t directly involved, but looking back on it—it was sad. Rural regions basically battling each other to keep textbooks up to date. And even in that state there were kids winning nation-wide scholarships. The problem was the others who weren’t so gifted had opportunities stripped from them by some man they’d never know. I could go on an anger-filled rant about it but I won’t. (Haha?)

I prefer to say anything I’ve done or accomplished was in spite of that situation (and because of good teachers) rather than because of those stringent circumstances.

But yes, in Ontario the best schools are probably just outside of the big city centres rather than in them. Upper Canada College for one. The world that places like that exist in is so far removed from the Canada I grew up with that I still think I’d have to see it in person to believe it exists. I’m only partly exaggerating.

I hope we can do better than that in the future I’m realizing that we’re all better off if every child has the opportunity to learn and experience from the widest array—rather than limiting those opportunities to children who had the good fortune of good circumstance. It’s not exactly in their control, and it seems like a hell of a good investment to me.

Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by cheez on Sunday September 15, 2019 @01:42PM (#20978403)
Sounds good but it's that kind of thinking that leads to the current situation (I mean this literally) . School is basically glorified babysitting at this point.
Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by 52-6F-62 on Sunday September 15, 2019 @07:16PM (#20980029)
I’m sorry. I don’t follow.

I was advocating for more funding to public education so that more children have access to more learning experiences.

I hope that’s more clear.

Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by cheez on Sunday September 15, 2019 @09:34PM (#20980477)
Sorry, I was trying to say that that people have been adding more funding for generations and it keeps getting worse.

Example: declining student enrollment, increased spending https://www.fraserinstitute.org/article/per-student-spending...

http://www.edu.gov.on.ca/eng/general/elemsec/quickfacts/2016...

Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by 52-6F-62 on Sunday September 15, 2019 @09:54PM (#20980540)
It’s not getting worse, though.

Canadian provinces’ public schools are ranking in the top 10 of world countries.

https://www.conferenceboard.ca/hcp/provincial/education.aspx

https://www.bbc.com/news/business-40708421

As an aside, I do not trust the Fraser Institute to be unbiased on the matter of any kind of public spending. Public spending is a essentially against their core values.

Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by cheez on Sunday September 15, 2019 @10:07PM (#20980586)
Hey, if you're happy with a "B" grade, that explains a lot about Ontario schools :-)
Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by 52-6F-62 on Monday September 16, 2019 @07:03AM (#20982864)
That’s a bit of a dishonest interpretation of the rankings, don’t you think?
Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by cheez on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @05:29PM (#21000272)
All I know is the test results on the tdsb website were pathetic. Not sure about this other stat you're using.
Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by purple_ducks on Sunday September 15, 2019 @03:04PM (#20978906)
> What you see with the teenager in question is a small town with decent enough resources

Everything bar the geo-specific things (sailing,planeterium) come from the same money pot for every school in Ireland (ROI) and are pretty much the same for most schools countrywide. The more disadvantaged an area your school is in, the more resources(a la funding/support) it gets.

This extends outside school to community. The most disadvantaged/crime-ridden communities get the most government funding(local sports/after-school activities/local community centers etc.)

Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by cheez on Monday September 16, 2019 @06:21AM (#20982640)
Interesting formula. Still I'm going to bet that this kid is better off than most
Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by specialist on Sunday September 15, 2019 @11:23AM (#20977603)
Agreeing with you...

""but the government is incompetent/corrupt/inefficient""

There's always some kind of overhead. Open markets and open societies require infrastruture.

Rules, government, lawyers, accountants, judges, cops and so forth are cheaper (for society) than anarchy (laissez faire).

I'd take the Freedom Markets™ advocates a bit more seriously if they offered any kind of alternative. Something a bit more constructive than "taxes are theft!".

Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by _edo on Sunday September 15, 2019 @10:46AM (#20977413)
> The world is deeply unjust economically.......and I feel stupidified when I see how these programmes aren't yet serious international standards.

It's not really that simple. Taking, by force, from Person A to raise Person B's children is complicated especially if you're worried about justness.

Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by jadbox on Sunday September 15, 2019 @11:03AM (#20977505)
Person's A child won't be held back tangibly if instead of a living on a 100+ million family fortune, that instead it's a fraction of that due to equalization of education efforts. Man cannot be born as equals when one child could buy their entire university, while another cannot even afford basic living.
Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by _edo on Sunday September 15, 2019 @11:52AM (#20977761)
And what happens to society as a whole when we abandon a person's right to own the products of their labor? What happens when highly productive people decide they have better things to do than go to work and get taxed at 70%?

A lot of people like a carbon tax because it will lower carbon emissions, if you tax productivity it has the same effect. A lot of people like clean energy subsidies because it makes clean energy more common, unfortunately subsidizing poverty often has the same effect.

I'm not saying you're wrong to care, I'm saying it's not a simple problem.

Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by jtr1 on Sunday September 15, 2019 @12:33PM (#20978004)
> And what happens to society as a whole when we abandon a person's right to own the products of their labor?

You don't acquire a $100 million fortune by performing 1000x the labor of a person with $100k, you get it by skimming the fruits of a lot of other people's labor.

Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by _edo on Sunday September 15, 2019 @02:11PM (#20978592)
No, you add value to their labor and in return get to keep some of it.

Or you can solve some previously unsolved problems which allow you to produce better products for lower costs than your competitors. This is how Carnegie, Rockefeller, Walton, Bernard Kroger, Aaron Montgomery Ward, Richard Warren Sears, etc. all made their fortunes. Even modern tycoons like Jeff Bezos, Elon Musk, Bill Gates, etc.

Can they get too much market power and start stealing from society? Absolutely, that's why we have anti-trust laws. But to see a fortune and assume a theft is to fundamentally misunderstand economics.

Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by jtr1 on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @04:53PM (#20999966)
> No, you add value to their labor and in return get to keep some of it.

How much value? Who determines how much you get to keep of it? These are highly charged political questions that have driven a lot of economic history!

> But to see a fortune and assume a theft...

I never said theft. I responded directly to the idea that people vast wealth is merely "the fruits of one's labor." And I stand by this statement: it is not, it is the fruit of many people's labor.

> ...is to fundamentally misunderstand economics.

I suppose I should tell my economics professors.

Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by vharuck on Sunday September 15, 2019 @12:24PM (#20977938)
>A lot of people like a carbon tax because it will lower carbon emissions, if you tax productivity it has the same effect.

It's not the same situation, so there's no reason to think it'd have the same effect.

A carbon tax's effect would come from opportunity cost. A company stops a behavior because of a carbon tax when they've found something more profitable. The tax just shifts the line of "more profitable."

But what's somebody going to do if you tax their wealth more? They only "other opportunities" are leaving the country or having more free time. The first is definitely a risk to consider, but the second seems unlikely for the class whose income comes from just investing their wealth. Why not invest, even if the profits are smaller?

Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by _edo on Sunday September 15, 2019 @02:31PM (#20978704)
Taxing something makes it less common. Doesn't matter if it's carbon, cigarettes, sugar, productivity, or investing.

Tax investing and that shifts the line just like a carbon tax, except in this case the people investing are more likely to start buying politicians or sending their money overseas. Those things don't benefit society like having them fund the research and diligence necessary to find and invest in the next Google, the next Target, or the next energy revolution.

Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by RootKitBeerCat on Sunday September 15, 2019 @12:13PM (#20977878)
Here you begin to sound like you’re equating productivity to income.

There are many companies that produce little real world value, yet tons of income.

Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by Tade0 on Sunday September 15, 2019 @07:27AM (#20976752)
Reminds me of my friend who, when asked about this girl he's been dating lately, listed all her accomplishments(she has perfect pitch, good job etc.).

I think the author of this piece values these accomplishments more than the guy in question.

Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by falcor84 on Sunday September 15, 2019 @08:27AM (#20976926)
For what it's worth, I noticed that a similar list of accomplishments appears on the guy's own website: https://www.fionnferreira.com
Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by 9nGQluzmnq3M on Sunday September 15, 2019 @08:49AM (#20976987)
...and a photo of him accepting an award from Vint Cerf.

inadequacy intensifies

Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by barking on Sunday September 15, 2019 @09:05AM (#20977044)
He's pretty driven all right. Good luck to him. Actually it says on a youtube video that he is half German and half Portuguese though his parents gave him an Irish forename!
Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by barking on Sunday September 15, 2019 @07:51AM (#20976815)
Yes, it's a tabloid style account so it lists the accomplishments that are more readily recognisable to a wider readership.
Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by simonebrunozzi on Sunday September 15, 2019 @11:01AM (#20977495)
> had a minor planet named after him by the MIT Lincoln Laboratory.

I could somewhat deal with the rest with a shoulder shrug, but this one is what makes it too hard to swallow :)

Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by test1235 on Sunday September 15, 2019 @11:19AM (#20977588)
Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by aiddun on Monday September 16, 2019 @02:14AM (#20981519)
Yep. Someone from my high school also got a planet named after him, but I think it was from ISEF.
Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by secfirstmd on Sunday September 15, 2019 @06:13AM (#20976467)
As an Irish person, I feel both proud of his work and saddened by the fact that our own university research system is so lacking he has to move abroad.
Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by coldtea on Sunday September 15, 2019 @10:02AM (#20977241)
Well, don't take it bad.

Ireland has like 5 million people? How would it have/support an adequate university research system to support a top-tier talent?

Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by notfashion on Sunday September 15, 2019 @10:50AM (#20977429)
Ireland's per capita level of funding for research has been lagging badly behind the European average, though. It's really a cultural problem: R&D doesn't happen here, except in rare cases. It's not really down to the size of the population: in the 19th C we had Hamilton and Boole, the world's largest telescope in Birr, Grubb telescope manufacturing in Dublin, and the Titanic was built in Belfast in the early 20th C. But independence, for better or worse, saw the Republic kind of divesting itself of technological stuff—it didn't match the national image, and separating from the UK meant that the communication and exchange of technical knowledge became an exception rather than the norm.

So it even has to do with the protestant/catholic divide (science and manufacturing was something "they" did). It's a very painful story, and a lot of Irish tech people have a chip on their shoulder (narcissistic injury) because of our backwardness.

Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by secfirstmd on Sunday September 15, 2019 @10:53AM (#20977441)
I would also argue that the successful way that Ireland has brought big companies to the country hasn't yet resulted in the spin off of benefits that the presence of such companies has had in other areas.
Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by purple_ducks on Sunday September 15, 2019 @03:22PM (#20978994)
> brought big companies to the country

Unfortunately, these companies were brought over by accountants, not engineers..

In so far as, Ireland gave them an opportunity to target EU market (& tax deals) which meant their staff is mostly non engineering (customer service/finance/legal).

The big mistake Ireland made (back then) was not ensuring some of their core business functionalities _had_ to be present in Ireland (i.e. engineering)

A lot less new tech companies built by accountants and customer support staff compared to engineers.

Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by majewsky on Sunday September 15, 2019 @01:08PM (#20978218)
Has Ireland really brought big companies to the country? Honest question. I'm only aware of big companies having their accounting department there for taxation purposes.
Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by OisinMoran on Sunday September 15, 2019 @02:05PM (#20978559)
Apple set up their first base outside the US in Limerick, which now also boasts the likes of Analog Devices (Limerick was where the current CEO started out), who actually do a lot of design and manufacturing there. Dell also used to have a massive presence, mainly making keyboards and the likes. Also I think something like nine out of the top eleven pharma companies worldwide have manufacturing facilities in Ireland, mainly in Cork I believe.

These are just a few off the top of my head, but the history is really interesting. A good bit of it has to do with Shannon, which actually served as inspiration for Shenzen believe it not!

I've been tempted to write up this history for quite a while because it's not really well known, and even despite being in STEM myself was quite surprised when I found out Analog Devices actually do design and manufacturing here and were making chips for Apple and Waymo!

Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by ajayh on Sunday September 15, 2019 @01:52PM (#20978465)
Google, for example, have over 7,000 staff in Ireland. I know of at least 9 buildings in Dublin it owns/rents.
Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by pvaldes on Sunday September 15, 2019 @01:21PM (#20978291)
Size is not all. Ireland, Norway, and Denmark, being small countries of similar population, all somehow managed to have a similar amount of nobel laureates than China or India.
Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by esotericn on Sunday September 15, 2019 @10:57AM (#20977462)
You may be familiar with a certain Linus Torvalds.

Finland has a population of 5M.

Granted, he moved later, but that's a counterexample for the first ~30 years at least.

Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by secfirstmd on Sunday September 15, 2019 @10:52AM (#20977433)
I read recently a survey about European wide research grants and we came bottom. Well outpaced by similar sized, smaller and/or less wealthy countries like Denmark, Finland, Estonia etc.
Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by scarejunba on Sunday September 15, 2019 @06:28AM (#20976528)
Superstars exist, dude. The only actionable view is to improve on the current you. Sometimes there will be things you're not good enough to do or that you don't want enough to practise enough.

I can't ollie a board. Such is life.

Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by odessacubbage on Sunday September 15, 2019 @08:36AM (#20976949)
if you actually want to learn how to ollie, it's very achievable. just try to commit some time to it every day. it's a weird motion to get used to at first but once you understand what it feels like to pop the board the right way you never lose it.
Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by esotericn on Sunday September 15, 2019 @10:59AM (#20977476)
Yep. I learned to ollie at like, 26? It's just scary because as a 15 year old you don't care about falling as much.
Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by avip on Sunday September 15, 2019 @07:50AM (#20976814)
Depending on circumstances, speaking 3 langs could be completely normal
Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by pvaldes on Sunday September 15, 2019 @10:53AM (#20977438)
Yup, in Europe is not uncommon.
Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by kiliantics on Monday September 16, 2019 @09:29AM (#20983790)
In Africa, 3 is pretty much the minimum number anyone can speak
Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by coldtea on Sunday September 15, 2019 @10:02AM (#20977243)
Well, in Europe that would be an easy 10-15% of the population...
Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by yowlingcat on Sunday September 15, 2019 @02:02PM (#20978527)
I don't think inadequacy is the strong emotion I'm feeling. It's probably more relief, or some sense of hope. I wish this sort of youthful experience was more the norm the world over. Outside of the curator and minor planet part (which are very much out of the ordinary for obvious reasons), many of these other characteristics match up pretty closely with high achieving students I saw grow up around me in my own youth. I very much agree with a sibling comment that "This reads like a figurative kick in the face to those who argue against free education and social programmes."
Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by RomanBob on Sunday September 15, 2019 @07:14AM (#20976703)
>Ferrier sat his Leaving Certificate exams last month at Schull Community College and is due to attend university in the Netherlands.

pretty normal to graduate high school and attend university

> works as a curator at the Schull Planetarium

I don't know what responsibility this holds how he got the job so it's hard to say.

>has won 12 science fair awards

I don't know the award scheme so hard to say. Even if he won 1st place 12 times, a science fair is hardly difficult to win since you are basically competing against semi-motivated highschoolers.

>speaks three languages fluently

This depends on the language. Some people get 2 languages for free from home and learn another to fluent level in high school. Not really a mind-blowing accomplishment.

>plays the trumpet at orchestra level,

This is really the only one that required consistent effort.

>had a minor planet named after him by the MIT Lincoln Laboratory."

meh

Out of all these, the only thing I wish I had is the ability to play the trumpet.

Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by themarkn on Sunday September 15, 2019 @08:11AM (#20976873)
Luckily the young dude has no need to prove himself to you, and hopefully he never reads this comment.

Being engaged enough as a teenager to win stuff, have a job, become actually fluent at languages (Irish high school does not make you fluent), do your grades in music, and choose then qualify for a university outside Ireland - none of this is easy or the "default" that is expected of children growing up there.

The default is you either stay in the town you grew up in or attend one of several major Irish universities free of charge with a bunch of your friends. After which you get a job in one of the bigger cities, maybe emigrate for employment reasons, or indeed head on back to your home town anyway and look for work there. That's normal.

You're doubtful of this kid's accomplishments but you have no context for the surrounding culture or how hard these things might have been for him individually.

I grew up there. It's not easy to stick your neck out and try to achieve things or be interested in success as a teenager in a rural school in Ireland.

Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by frabbit on Sunday September 15, 2019 @09:36AM (#20977127)
attend one of several major Irish universities free of charge

Those days are long gone thanks to the neo-liberals.

Impressed by this guy's accomplishments. His parents and environment are doing something right.

Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by frabbit on Sunday September 15, 2019 @09:54PM (#20980541)
In case anyone is confused: although the "fees" are covered under many circumstances you nevertheless need to pay a "student contribution" "service charge" of around 3000 euro at most institutions. So, it ends up being the same as fees were a few decades ago anyway.

A lack of popular support for the truly free education movement (some name like FEIS if I remember correctly) while it looked like the Celtic Tiger was going to provide every Irish(wo)man with a rental property in Bulgaria led us to this pass.

Re:Irish Teenager Wins Global Science Award for Removing Mic... by coldtea on Sunday September 15, 2019 @10:03AM (#20977247)
We didn't learn much about him from this comment, but we learnt 1-2 things about you :)