The easy ubiquity of LPR is essentially the death knell of privacy of movement. We'd have to move to encrypted transponders that only respond to queries with the right codes, but of course the police would still be able to know where you were whenever they liked. Rolling QR code digital number plates would work. But it won't happen.
I like the "Rolling QR code digital number plates" concept; are you aware of rolling QR codes used elsewhere?
Other digital transponders, either for tolling or just your devices broadcasting their Wifi/Bluetooth addresses, certainly cause problems but they are within your scope to control.
It would be interesting to see if you could design an adversarial LPR jammer, that would not look to a cop like a licence plate.
When I wrote 'rolling code' I was being a bit off the cuff.
A PKI based system might be something like: {nonce,E(rego_pub,(nonce,car ID, date, hour)),S(car_priv,(nonce,car ID, date, hour))}, where rego_pub is the public key of the local authority, car_priv is the private key of the car, E is encrypt, S is sign.
This is already quite complicated, requires central PKI etc. And unfortunately QR codes themselves are not a great fit, because you need to be close to read them, but you could have a variant designed for shorter strings.
Another possibility might be to use a (prefix, TOTP code). With a fixed prefix indexed on car model/year (which is already visible from looking at it), the set of all TOTP codes from that fleet at that time could easily be searched by the registration authority to identify which vehicle it was. So, e.g., all blue Toyota Camry 2018s would have prefix 'P9J' and then a 10 minute changing code, like 'Y3KE'.
So if a cop needs to look up a car the LPR reads P9JY3KE. The local terminal says it should be a blue Camry, and then sends the string to the validator, which computes the TOTP for all vehicles in the class (like, 2000 in a group) and see if any of them match. If none match, pull them over.
There are a few problems with this still, e.g. replay attacks. But possibly solved by using IFF techniques, i.e. the police car can send a signed query forcing the named plate to show more digits of the TOTP code.
Criminals just steal the plates off another vehicle (of the same model/color if they are smarter), so maybe they can just steal the whole digital licence plate computer module? Unless the smart licence plate is part of the vehicle security system, on the car bus, it is still going to happen.
--- The whole IOV (Internet of Vehicles), V2V (Vehicle to Vehicle) space is going to have to deal with these problems, and there is no shortage of protocols but I don't think it is remotely solved. Lots of companies pushing 5G approaches for this, but I wonder if transponders like for aircraft (ADS-B) or ships (AIS) won't be a simpler (and much cheaper) way, even if they are still using mm wave radios.
Ditto for similar big systems like EZPass are expensive. Some read transactions cost the government as much as $2.
It’s a market where the price is going to plummet as it becomes a service delivered thing. You’ll pull into a grocery store parking lot and generate an alarm to have a clerk get your groceries ready, and when you park it will tell him where to go. You’re also going to have a lot more tolls.
Haven’t seen these yet, but Target has a pretty cool system that is app based. Easy to see how they could hook in cars.
Ring/security cameras are fine but being able to pinpoint a handful of plates to the wee hours of the morning would allow theft issues to be handled pretty easily when cross referenced with camera tech.
Ex. Right now you get a description like "Older white 4 door" or "White Nissan Sentra"
Bounce that against plates from that time and you've got a good match to work off of, especially if the owner matches descriptions from cameras.
I've been writing my own home surveillance camera network video recorder software, so I've thought about plugging in something like this, but I don't think it's really necessary. The one time I might use it is if there's a car that was likely involved in a burglary, I might scan the previous few weeks to find previous times they were in-frame. Then I might see their scoping the place out, potentially revealing more about themselves. It's too labor-intensive to look through that many motion events by hand.
[1] My understanding is this requires some care. You have to select the right kind of camera, place/aim/zoom it carefully, and tune it for license plate recognition, particularly at night. I think the cameras typically come tuned for slow-moving, not-very-reflective-to-IR objects. License plates on a moving car are the opposite, so you want to say decrease the aperture and increase the shutter speed from the default, position it carefully as I said, maybe tweak some other settings, and test it.
So be prepared for the requests from divorce attorneys and police. Better to just have video to make it more difficult.
I doubt LPR will be the primary utility of this kind of tech.
You're right. LPR isn't going to be the primary utility, but it's very possible that this will be one of the first areas to benefit from this tech at scale.
https://github.com/openalpr/openalpr
basically:
alpr imagefile
will recognize a plate. It just as simple in python.Success as defined by non-educated (and some from the social studies) people everywhere.