News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why industry is going green on the quiet by ezoe on Sunday September 08, 2019 @06:36AM (#20909667)
When I saw a label of organic, I immediately assume it's over-priced fraud product. To me, it's same as those stupid product which claims magical cure for cancer.
Re:Why industry is going green on the quiet by NeedMoreTea on Sunday September 08, 2019 @06:59AM (#20909754)
Why fraud? Organic is certifying different, but clearly defined production and husbandry standards. You have to meet EU, USDA etc requirements before you can legally use the term organic. It's a worthwhile indicator of less excess in farming, and a marked step up from the many, often dubious, self-certification schemes and logos.

Whether you prefer the flavour, or think the restrictions of organic are necessary or not, or don't go far enough are another matter.

Re:Why industry is going green on the quiet by delfinom on Sunday September 08, 2019 @08:01AM (#20910015)
USDA struggles to enforce the labeling standard for organic items. Fraud is rampant and they don't have the ability to enforce it fast enough.

https://newfoodeconomy.org/organic-food-fraud-usda-doj-randy... This was a case just last month. $142 million in false organic grain over 7 years that was shipped as feed to animals later sold as organic.

Re:Why industry is going green on the quiet by NeedMoreTea on Sunday September 08, 2019 @09:07AM (#20910346)
USDA has, I think, just about the weakest definition of organic globally. I can't say I'm surprised to find some fraud in the system, given all we know of the rest of US agriculture. Clearly better enforcement is required, as is a tighter definition of the standard. Even so, it still seems to be the highest US enforced certification available, so remains the best indicator of production and animal treatment a US consumer has, for all its flaws and inadequacy.

Thankfully the EU is doing better, though that may well change markedly for the worse here in the UK after Brexit. Especially if the much mooted, and one-sided UK-US trade deal is made real, not just mythical rainbows and unicorns.

Re:Why industry is going green on the quiet by markdown on Sunday September 08, 2019 @07:19AM (#20909833)
> Why fraud? Organic is certifying different, but clearly defined production and husbandry standards.

Those production and husbandry standards aren't always quite what we expect them to be. You should see how "free range" chickens are raised. Australian farmers who actually care about the welfare of the chickens and the quality of the end product have been trying to create a new brand "pasture raised" or "pastured eggs" (in the case of eggs) because lobbying by the major producers watered down the standards to the point it's disgusting to see chicken feedlots where chooks are free to range at 10,000 hens per hectare.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=can8xFpZKRs

Re:Why industry is going green on the quiet by NeedMoreTea on Sunday September 08, 2019 @09:03AM (#20910325)
Free range is a great example of one of those that's been hollowed out to be a near useless marketing phrase in many parts of the world. EU standards set amount of outside access, and limit birds per hectare - a quick search says 3,500 per hectare. USDA restrict neither making it completely worthless. EU Organic is tighter than the EU free range definition on birds per hectare, and limits total flock size too.

Free range is marketed to imply old time farm yards with a few dozen hens happily pecking around some rural spacious idyll. The reality is depressingly different. Whether you care about organic aims at all, buying EU organic gets you the "most" free range eggs from best treated hens, that you can get at the supermarket. Which is more than a bit silly.

You won't be surprised to learn I'm in favour of much stronger regulation and definitions on food and production labelling. While we're at it, adding carbon impact to labels.

Re:Why industry is going green on the quiet by jhrmnn on Sunday September 08, 2019 @06:54AM (#20909740)
It‘s not the same. If anything, organic produce and its labeling are regulated (at least in EU), magical cures for cancer are not.
Re:Why industry is going green on the quiet by WA on Sunday September 08, 2019 @07:49AM (#20909964)
And usually, organic doesn’t mean that it is more healthy for the consumer. It just means it was produced according to some rules that protect the environment somewhat.
Re:Why industry is going green on the quiet by afiori on Sunday September 08, 2019 @08:44AM (#20910219)
Organic agriculture is in many ways a menace to the environment, pesticides are filtered not on environmental or health concerns but based on a natural/artificial scale.

In practice worse pesticides and fertilizer imply that huge quantities are used still yielding less per square meter.

Re:Why industry is going green on the quiet by NeedMoreTea on Sunday September 08, 2019 @09:08AM (#20910353)
Except the EU, and even more restrictive UK organic standard restricts both amount, number of applications, and requires an audit trail of why it was applied, so no it doesn't imply huge quantities. No idea if USDA permits unlimited use...
Re:Why industry is going green on the quiet by fact_factory on Sunday September 08, 2019 @03:42PM (#20912898)
>No idea if USDA permits unlimited use...

They do not, in fact it is a last resort.

[0]https://www.ecfr.gov/cgi-bin/text-idx?SID=94361624bc8858349d...

Re:Why industry is going green on the quiet by fact_factory on Sunday September 08, 2019 @03:41PM (#20912887)
In practice, organic farms are required to use pesticides as a last resort, whereas conventional farms use as much pesticide as they feel is necessary routinely. Furthermore, pesticides that are approved for organic use are non-selective, meaning that they must be applied carefully or they will damage the crop. Modern conventional agriculture is dominated by selective herbicides that are used in volume, because the crops are resistant to their effects. This means that the amount of pesticide used by a conventional farming operation dwarfs that of an organic farm.
Re:Why industry is going green on the quiet by chicob on Tuesday September 10, 2019 @03:36AM (#20925892)
So do farmers engaged in Integrated Farming: only as a last resort, and if the economical threshold has been reached.

The difference is that there are no restrictions regarding the use of 1) synthetic pesticides 2) man-made fertilizers, 3) GMOs and 4) antibiotics.

So Integrated Farming is just like Organic Farming, but without the bullshit.

Re:Why industry is going green on the quiet by chicob on Sunday September 08, 2019 @09:39AM (#20910498)
I agree, but I should say that the main concern is not what is better for the environment, but what is certifiably non-synthetic. A secular kosher, is how I'd put it.
Re:Why industry is going green on the quiet by snthd on Sunday September 08, 2019 @07:31AM (#20909885)
Organic farming is primarily about producing products better rather than producing better products.
Re:Why industry is going green on the quiet by chicob on Tuesday September 10, 2019 @03:39AM (#20925908)
Organic farming is primarily about producing organically (i.e. without synthetic means), rather than producing sustainably.
Re:Why industry is going green on the quiet by enriquto on Sunday September 08, 2019 @09:12AM (#20910371)
better for whom? for the environment in the long term or for the health of the consumer in the short term? these two criteria are probably contradictory.
Re:Why industry is going green on the quiet by Merrill on Sunday September 08, 2019 @07:51AM (#20909972)
The benefit of organic is the presumed lower amounts of pesticide and herbicide residues in the product, hence some tiny lessening of the probability of getting cancer. Some would also assert that the products have better nutritional values, but this seems very marginal and unlikely.

On the other hand, the amount of energy used to grow, process and distribute the product is likely to be higher than for non-organic due to less efficient fertilization, more cultivation, lower yields due to pests, and smaller-scale production units.

Re:Why industry is going green on the quiet by AngryData on Sunday September 08, 2019 @07:52PM (#20914126)
Ignoring the labor costs, the organic methods only use more energy if you completely ignore the chemical energy harvested from natural gas to produce artificial fertilizer. It is just taking a shortcut of using chemical energy directly as a reagent, rather than burning the fuel and using that energy to create the same reagents from electricity. But at the end of the day, you still pulled natural gas out of the ground and released it on the surface of the planet the same as burning it. Using an organic fertilizer however would just be recycling energy that was already on the earth's surface rather than letting it rot away uselessly.

All that said, our current practices and facilities cannot recycle or produce enough non-fossil fuel fertilizer to support or agricultural practices.

In order to produce fertilizer renewably in an artificial way, ie draw it from the air and water in a chemical facility, we need to increase our energy usage in making fertilizer 10x or more over. Which essentially means we need near the current entire world's worth of energy production produced again, renewably, for the sole production of fertilizer.

Re:Why industry is going green on the quiet by ctdonath on Sunday September 08, 2019 @08:20AM (#20910097)
"Presumed" is the problem. Organic: you keep using that word; the government does not think it means what you think it means.
Re:Why industry is going green on the quiet by Merrill on Sunday September 08, 2019 @08:52AM (#20910260)
>Organic 101: What the USDA Organic Label Means https://www.usda.gov/media/blog/2012/03/22/organic-101-what-...

What about the presumption is wrong?

Also https://www.ams.usda.gov/grades-standards/organic-labeling-s...

“Organic”

“Organic” can be used to label any product that contains a minimum of 95 percent organic ingredients (excluding salt and water). Up to 5 percent of the ingredients may be nonorganic agricultural products that are not commercially available as organic and/or nonagricultural products that are on the National List.1

Principal display panel: May include USDA organic seal and/or organic claim.

Information Panel: Must identify organic ingredients (e.g., organic dill) or via asterisk or other mark.

Re:Why industry is going green on the quiet by PeterisP on Sunday September 08, 2019 @10:04AM (#20910607)
> What about the presumption is wrong?

Everything?

You quote a bunch of resources, and none of them support the presumption you made "lower amounts of pesticide and herbicide residues in the product, hence some tiny lessening of the probability of getting cancer. Some would also assert that the products have better nutritional values". The presumption is understandable, intuitive, but has no basis in reality.

The presumption seems to be that organic farming is closer to traditional farming and avoids practices that pollute the products and the environment. However, the government doesn't see it that way, and describes (in the resources you quote) "organic" in a way that does not require to avoid polluting practices as such, but only certain types of polluting practices... while farmers/manufacturers (obviously) compensate for them.

In particular, if we're talking about produce, then the large growers who want to satisfy the USDA Organic Label criteria of "Produce can be called organic if it’s certified to have grown on soil that had no prohibited substances applied for three years prior to harvest. Prohibited substances include most synthetic fertilizers and pesticides." achieve that by using nonsynthetic fertilizers, herbicides and pesticides in large quantities (as they're less efficient as the "default" materials). The substances replacing standard synthetic fertilizers and pesticides are not safer for humans, they're not safer for the environment, they're simply "more natural" because of arbitrary criteria.

While an organic farmer could make produce with less pesticides, that's not cost efficient, so on average mass-produced organic produce that meets all the USDA Organic Label requirements generally has more harmful herbicide and nitrate residues than the "default" non-organic produce. A friend works in food safety testing labs, and most of products that exceed the allowed limits of various unhealthy substances or are near the limits come from certified organic farms.

Re:Why industry is going green on the quiet by fact_factory on Sunday September 08, 2019 @03:46PM (#20912932)
>achieve that by using nonsynthetic fertilizers, herbicides and pesticides in large quantities

Citation needed.

In fact, the organic program requires farmers to manage the weeds and insects using methods besides pesticides, and only allows non-routine pesticide use in the exceptional case.

>friend works in food safety testing labs, and most of products that exceed the allowed limits of various unhealthy substances or are near the limits come from certified organic farms.

This is likely due to contamination and fraud, since the letter and the spirit of the law in the United States do not permit routine use of pesticides of any type.

Re:Why industry is going green on the quiet by ctdonath on Sunday September 08, 2019 @10:43PM (#20914808)
A recursive definition, ignoring the fact that "organic" includes toxic substances.
Re:Why industry is going green on the quiet by 7952 on Sunday September 08, 2019 @07:34AM (#20909899)
We all have to make decisions on complex products with very limited data and understanding. Words like "organic" are just a heuristic. It is maybe better than nothing.
Re:Why industry is going green on the quiet by johnchristopher on Sunday September 08, 2019 @06:44AM (#20909699)
What do you mean ? That fraudsters mix regular product with organic product to lie to consumers in order to cash in the benefits ? Or that organic products are a fraud ?
Re:Why industry is going green on the quiet by ctdonath on Sunday September 08, 2019 @08:21AM (#20910103)
That consumers think it means something different than what the industry knows it means.
Re:Why industry is going green on the quiet by noja on Sunday September 08, 2019 @07:02AM (#20909766)
What? Why would you do that?
Re:Why industry is going green on the quiet by jacknews on Sunday September 08, 2019 @08:54AM (#20910272)
yes I think this is it, it's a backlash of sorts against over-hyped (and over-priced) marketing to hipster values.