"What should a student know?" "Everything"
"What should a lab technician know?" "Almost the same as the student"
"What about a graduate?" "In which book is that thing that the student should know?"
"And the associate professor?" "Where is this book?"
"And the professor?" "Where is the associate professor?"
The higher someone is the less overall they know. I know regulars that I would put way higher than some of our experts. And its not only technical knowledge but also problem solving, attitude and craftsmanship.
Thats what happens when promotions are given based on "years worked" or "office politics" instead of work excellence.
Sad reality in a lot of companies in IT.
Promotions to new positions based on performance in the previous position don't always work out great either.
I'd suggest their skillset changes as they grow into their new role. As they transition from writing code to people wrangling, the code skills stop being important and new ones take their place. Same with attitude, they have to transition to a new focus.
My take is that engineers between like 4 and 15 years experience and are not managers of some sort have the hardest duties. As a novice you get help or are not handed the really hard tasks and as senior you talk about the hard tasks or do some pre-study and leave the implementation as a exercise to someone else.
Promotions are more about having a ticket away from hard engineering tasks than engineering competence.
Agree 100%.
I tell people who are speaking for the first time that it is likely they are among the top 1-3 experts in the room on their subject (unless it is super basic). This is because knowledge is so vast, and, in the tech industry, so ephemeral. (Some kinds of knowledge aren't ephemeral, but many kinds are subject to rapid evolution.)
Yet this industry interviews them like they are expected to.
From what I can see, most people are trying to do their best but being a staff principal senior engineer does not necessarily you can answer everything (but usually they know who to ask or what to do to get an anwser)
It is not that people are incompetent, but you can't be an expert at everything.