News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Teardown of a Failed Linux LTS Spectre Fix by fragmede on Wednesday September 04, 2019 @03:15PM (#20880474)
GRSecurity has the same, odious, if legal posturing as RedHat - the GPL requires the current version's source (which customers have access to), be made available to customers. Upon sharing of the current version's source in a useful format to the public, licensing for future version is denied - ie, you cannot be a future customer of RedHat. Thus you don't have a right to the binaries and thus neither the source.

RedHat, gets away with distributing the source to their modified kernel as a giant patch file to the vanilla kernel because adheres to the letter of the GPL but not the "spirit", insofar as a law can have a spirit, and insofar as I can claim what the spirit even is. Business-wise though, RedHat is able to get away with it as a billion dollar company. Spender (of GRSecurity) is smarter than I, but has tried to build his product upon something that requires more smarts and more resources - that he is too fiercrely protective of - than he is willing to trade rights to, in order for his contributions to be available to the wider community, as he purports to desire. Facebook's kernel modifications, nor Google's "interesting" kernel modifications (as defined by those requisite for running Google.com and other properties) aren't made available, nor are they t required to, by the GPL. (Android's Linux kernel sources and select other kernel changes are made available.)

The GPL allows building a business by providing support, and/or tuning of kernel parameters (eg VM swappiness, or disk scheduler deadlines) for running highly specialized workloads, eg Oracle DB. If providing a highly successful product, eg Google.com or Facebook internal knowledge will naturally follow. External benefits not necessarily so. The fat client of the pre and early Internet made the GPL (and LGPL) sufficient for the time, but things are different on the cloudy Internet, and arguably the broader community suffers for it.

Re:Teardown of a Failed Linux LTS Spectre Fix by misc228 on Sunday September 08, 2019 @09:55PM (#20914605)
Redhat distributes it's sources to everyone, thus making any violation of the no-restrictions-on-redistribution clause acedemic to the linux copyright holders who would be the claimants.

GRSecurity successfully prevents redistribution: it's violation is blatant and NOT academic.

A court can be shown the attempt and it's successful conclusion.

Quite different in substance from RedHat's possible violation.