News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hong Kong leader to announce formal withdrawal of extradi... by coldtea on Wednesday September 04, 2019 @09:26AM (#20876953)
Huh? If we're strict, it has plenty of avenues, including courts and elections [1]. They might be nominal, but legally they do exist and operate:

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elections_in_China

Re:Hong Kong leader to announce formal withdrawal of extradi... by i_am_proteus on Wednesday September 04, 2019 @09:35AM (#20877035)
Elections are meaningless if the public can't decide who runs.
[dead]
Re:Hong Kong leader to announce formal withdrawal of extradi... by beat on Wednesday September 04, 2019 @12:11PM (#20878588)
More people wanted HRC, though. That's how elections work. It doesn't mean the loser is unpopular or broadly disliked. It means there's another candidate voters like better (or dislike less).
Re:Hong Kong leader to announce formal withdrawal of extradi... by StreamBright on Wednesday September 04, 2019 @02:00PM (#20879762)
[dead]
Re:Hong Kong leader to announce formal withdrawal of extradi... by coldtea on Thursday September 05, 2019 @03:56AM (#20884734)
>Primaries/caucuses are managed at the state level, and are not controlled directly or indirectly by the DNC.

Why would that be?

Re:Hong Kong leader to announce formal withdrawal of extradi... by beat on Thursday September 05, 2019 @10:47AM (#20887223)
Laws. Traditions. Elections have always been managed on a state-by-state basis in the US, which is why my nice competent Minnesota that runs excellent elections is held hostage on a national level by borderline banana republics like Ohio and Florida, where ballot boxes out of the back of someone's car are considered normal.
Re:Hong Kong leader to announce formal withdrawal of extradi... by StreamBright on Wednesday September 04, 2019 @02:35PM (#20880104)
>> Bernie lost by three million votes.

Just like Obama lost by couple of hundred thousand votes?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2008_Democratic_Party_presiden...

"What’s a political party for, anyway?

It’s easy to bash the DNC’s joint fundraising agreement with Clinton, or the leaked emails showing that DNC staffers were supportive of Clinton and frustrated by Sanders. The DNC is meant to be a neutral presence in party primaries, and even minor deviations from that position are affronts.

The harder question in the larger one: What role should party elites play in primaries? It wasn’t that long ago, after all, that they fully decided primaries, meeting in smoky back rooms during the political conventions to hash out the next nominee. Before 2016, the reigning political science theory of primaries was called “the party decides,” and it argued that political elites still largely decided party primaries, albeit through influencing voters rather than controlling convention delegates."

https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2017/11/14/16640082/...

I think it is quite obvious that the DNC did everything in their power to get rid of Sanders and put HRC into position. The problem was that she was unelectable and many Bernie voters just decided that Trump will be a better president than HRC (and many unfortunate other things, like HRC's popularity went down after every public appearance, all the left leaning social media declared HRC president, etc.).

Re:Hong Kong leader to announce formal withdrawal of extradi... by guerrilla on Wednesday September 04, 2019 @11:28AM (#20878074)
By public, do you mean the party elites and corporate newsmedia, like here in the west?
Re:Hong Kong leader to announce formal withdrawal of extradi... by pimmen on Wednesday September 04, 2019 @11:30AM (#20878095)
If you cannot vote for a different party that doesn’t share the values of the CCP, and can’t form one yourself, elections are meaningless rubber stamps.
Re:Hong Kong leader to announce formal withdrawal of extradi... by coldtea on Wednesday September 04, 2019 @01:42PM (#20879576)
You don't need parties to have elections, just like how elections within a single community or organization don't have political parties, just candidates and fractions (voters/executives with different opinions).

As for the values of the CCP, consider them like the Constitution in the US or the values of the "founding fathers". People don't get to change those either in any direct democratic way (but through a slow, ideological and legal process).

Besides, 1 party vs 2 parties alternating seems hardly much of a difference...

Re:Hong Kong leader to announce formal withdrawal of extradi... by pimmen on Wednesday September 04, 2019 @02:13PM (#20879903)
Of course you don’t need parties to hold elections, that’s not what I said. I said they become meaningless rubber stamps since all the different factions are curated by the party establishment to the best of their abilities making any challenge to the establishment at best painfully slow (as in people have to be replaced through death or expulsuon for any blockage to stop) and at worst impossible.

I’m not talking about changing the constitution or policy in a direct democratic way, changing them in a representative way through Western style democracy would be a vast improvement. Because the constitutions of Western governments still leave a lot of political room to manouver, such as taxation. In the US, stuff like that was left out of the constitution because the founding fathers knew they didn’t have all the answers, no one does. Especially not the CCP. Instead, things like basic human rights such as the right to not get locked up and brainwashed because of your religion is enshrined in the constitutions of Western style democracies because unlike taxation or government ownership of enterprises that is really important to make sure all individuals matter.

And yes, changing the constitution is very slow, but if you have a multitude of differences with the government and the majority population, you can still progress politically and change one thing about the constitution where you do find common ground if you’re a competent politician. That’s far faster, more efficient and meritocratic than having to share the vast majority of policy with just one arbitrary party leadership to even be elligeble to run.

All of these advantages are still present even with a two party system, but I prefer the multiparty, parliamentary system we have here in the Nordic countries.

Re:Hong Kong leader to announce formal withdrawal of extradi... by cthalupa on Wednesday September 04, 2019 @06:15PM (#20881932)
There's some major differences here, though.

1) In America, I can just decide to run for office. Especially at the local to state level, independent candidates can be totally viable. Random everyday people cannot run for office in China. The party selects candidates to stand for election, and they generally run unopposed, or opposed by someone who is nearly a perfect mirror on policy.

2) In America, I can run on values that are against the Constitution or the founding fathers. How many people run on platforms of curtailing or amending the second amendment? You see that all the way up to candidates running for the Presidency. You will not see candidates run on policies that are opposite of the CCP in China.

One party that controls which candidates can run means they are effectively just appointing people to positions, while giving the illusion of choice or citizen impact on elections. There's a lot about the US system of representative democracy that could be justly criticized and would be improved by reform, but acting like it is even remotely similar to China is absurd.