Are you saying you have that checkbox you pointed out unchecked, and still get new reddit by default?
I basically never ever want to be there. I've specifically not enabled JS for 'www.reddit.com' so that the site won't load, but I still have to fix URLs manually when directed there.
What I'd like is for any 'www.reddit.com' I encounter on the site to be rewritten to 'old.reddit.com'.
So maybe this is a misfeature on old.reddit.com, or you don't have the box unchecked?
Not sure if you're saying that setting's not working for you or you're just annoyed that it doesn't explicitly link to https://old.reddit.com../blah/..
1: https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/b7rums/why_d...
I personally wound up using an extension[1] to keep old Reddit active, which so far has taken care of the weird behavior.
[1]: https://addons.mozilla.org/nl/firefox/addon/old-reddit-redir...
https://old.reddit.com/prefs/
There is no "always use old reddit"