Re:What Is Zoned Storage and the Zoned Storage Initiative?
by amelius on Saturday August 31, 2019 @09:10PM
(#20849888)
> If you are going to use them as expensive tape then by all means, but otherwise I have serious doubts about their usefulness.
Only writing is more complicated. Reading is still simple and fast; and random access reading is fast, unlike tape.
Re:What Is Zoned Storage and the Zoned Storage Initiative?
by rzzzt on Saturday August 31, 2019 @07:10PM
(#20849392)
Drive-managed SMR looks OK to me for general use, although I don't have hands-on experience with it. They also have a non-shingled region that can accept random I/O at higher speeds, and the drive deals with moving data to a linear-only region once it fills up, or at garbage collection time.
It's very much like the QLC drives where a portion is treated as SLC/MLC.
Re:What Is Zoned Storage and the Zoned Storage Initiative?
by loeg on Saturday August 31, 2019 @07:43PM
(#20849507)
It's like the QLC drives with SLC/MLC cache (e.g., Intel 660p) except the performance cliff is far, far worse (and obviously the "fast" mode is far worse as well).
Re:What Is Zoned Storage and the Zoned Storage Initiative?
by josefbacik on Saturday August 31, 2019 @07:16PM
(#20849415)
Agreed, drive managed is far better from a usability standpoint.
Re:What Is Zoned Storage and the Zoned Storage Initiative?
by the8472 on Sunday September 01, 2019 @07:31AM
(#20851713)
Some of the fallocate modes don't make much sense on CoW filesystems anyway. ZoL doesn't support preallocation either, you have to use FALLOC_FL_PUNCH_HOLE.
Lack of DIO might be a bigger issue. Then again it's often used by write-heavy workloads which probably don't want to use SMR drives anyway.
Edit: I’m talking specifically about the SMR side. The general zoned stuff is interesting, but when you start putting restrictions on how you can write to certain zones you wind up with a lot of weirdness that application developers are going to be surprised by.