News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Measles: Four European nations lose eradication status by pjc50 on Friday August 30, 2019 @09:17AM (#20838237)
Vaccines never used to be mandatory because mandatory medical treatment has a very bad track record. Medical treatment requires informed consent to be ethical.

Unfortunately, there is a new viral threat - or rather, a memetic one. A meme that encourages people to immunocompromise themselves and their children. We're not so good at vaccinating against lethal memes, but perhaps this is the pandemic of the 21st century.

It's not just an internet phenomenon; the originator was Andrew Wakefield, with the help of lots of traditional sensationalist poor quality news publications.

Edit: this is more controversial than I was expecting .. I don't normally ask for explanations of downvotes, and I know it's frowned upon, and normally when I get downvoted I know exactly which audience I'm offending and why. But I don't understand it here.

Re:Measles: Four European nations lose eradication status by gizmo686 on Friday August 30, 2019 @09:33AM (#20838411)
Its not just that mandatory medical treatments are ethically fraught (but not unheard of. Mental health is the most obvious example, but there are also mechanisms to force treatment on non consenting minors with their gaurdian's approval).

The other reason we didn't have mandatory vaccinations is that there was just no need. Vaccines are about as close to a miracle drug as you can get. With virtual no side effects, a 1 minute procedure makes you immune to illness that would previously have devastated society.

If you took vaccines back in time and told people what they did, but claimed the had every side effect they are accused of having, there would still have been lines out the door.

Re:Measles: Four European nations lose eradication status by pjc50 on Friday August 30, 2019 @10:23AM (#20838879)
Pasteur had to do quite a lot of work convincing people of the safety and efficacy of vaccines originally. It wasn't an uncontroversial instant success. The versions of vaccines we have now are excellent, but there's still some which aren't side effect free - BCG leaves a scar most of the time!
Re:Measles: Four European nations lose eradication status by mercutio2 on Friday August 30, 2019 @11:28AM (#20839535)
I suspect you’re getting downvotes because your paragraph about a meme leading to people being immunocompromised could be interpreted either:

as being opposed to the meme that vaccines should be mandatory, or:

as being opposed to the meme that vaccines immunocompromise people.

I initially read it as the former, because your first sentence was critical of mandatory vaccines. Then I read your other posts, and realized you were likely making an argument about how this is a subtle problem, where we had an effective cultural/medical system before which avoided making anything mandatory, which is good because it’s better to not be authoritarian when we can avoid it, but a meme broke that effective system.

Is that right?

Re:Measles: Four European nations lose eradication status by pjc50 on Friday August 30, 2019 @01:55PM (#20840884)
Basically yes. I'm opposed to vaccines being mandatory unless it's "absolutely necessary" - but it appears to be becoming necessary because the false meme "vaccines cause autism" is very infectious. But making vaccination mandatory doesn't stop the spread of the meme. So political pressure is going to build against vaccination, and that will have all sorts of weird and ugly side effects of making anti-science parties more popular.

I'm also saying we need to develop better public health methods against dangerous memes. Whether that's vaccination of the mind or breaking off a few pump handles.

Re:Measles: Four European nations lose eradication status by Freak_NL on Friday August 30, 2019 @10:11AM (#20838760)
Not sure why you are getting downvoted. It is probably quite helpful to look at the spread of vaccination misinformation as a meme (or rather, a memetic virus), and to attempt to formulate strategies against it.

There are few hypotheses as closely scrutinised and solidly disproven as the theory that (measles) vaccines cause autism, but a quick glance at the material spreading online shows that as one of the all-time favourites of the army of trolls and the misinformed.

Re:Measles: Four European nations lose eradication status by spraak on Friday August 30, 2019 @09:38AM (#20838468)
> A meme that encourages people to immunocompromise themselves and their children.

Being unvaccinated is not immunocompromised. They're almost orthogonal and indeed someone can be both vaccinated and immunocompromised (and actually immunocompromised from vaccine injury).

> It's not just an internet phenomenon; the originator was Andrew Wakefield

Maybe in recent times? But there seems to have been people against vaccination since its origin.

Re:Measles: Four European nations lose eradication status by starvingbear on Friday August 30, 2019 @10:09AM (#20838740)
Andrew Wakefield was simply an expert in gut health he didnt even want into the vaccine debate. He did very fair research that proved a link between between what he found in the gut and autism at the request of parents bringing their kids to him that was signed off as fully accurate by 12 scientists that assisted the research. It scared a pharma sponsor and got pulled from publication. That's all his story was and it turned into the all time anti vaxxer conspiracy somehow.
Re:Measles: Four European nations lose eradication status by pjc50 on Friday August 30, 2019 @10:14AM (#20838788)
He spent years promoting the idea, and achieved a level of misconduct that got him disqualified from practicing medicine. Relevant chunk of Wikipedia:

> After the publication of the paper, other researchers were unable to reproduce Wakefield's findings or confirm his hypothesis of an association between the MMR vaccine and autism,[8] or autism and gastrointestinal disease.[9] A 2004 investigation by Sunday Times reporter Brian Deer identified undisclosed financial conflicts of interest on Wakefield's part,[10] and most of his co-authors then withdrew their support for the study's interpretations.[11] The British General Medical Council (GMC) conducted an inquiry into allegations of misconduct against Wakefield and two former colleagues.[12] The investigation centred on Deer's findings, including that children with autism were subjected to unnecessary invasive medical procedures such as colonoscopies and lumbar punctures,[13] and that Wakefield acted without the required ethical approval from an institutional review board.

> On 28 January 2010, a five-member statutory tribunal of the GMC found three dozen charges proved, including four counts of dishonesty and twelve counts involving the abuse of developmentally delayed children.[14] The panel ruled that Wakefield had "failed in his duties as a responsible consultant", acted against the interests of his patients, and acted "dishonestly and irresponsibly" in his published research.[15][16][17] The Lancet fully retracted the 1998 publication on the basis of the GMC's findings, noting that elements of the manuscript had been falsified.[18] The Lancet's editor-in-chief Richard Horton said the paper was "utterly false" and that the journal had been "deceived".[19] Three months following The Lancet's retraction, Wakefield was struck off the UK medical register, with a statement identifying deliberate falsification in the research published in The Lancet,[20] and was thereby barred from practising medicine in the UK.[21] A British Administrative Court Justice noted in a related decision—"There is now no respectable body of opinion which supports (Dr. Wakefield's) hypothesis, that MMR vaccine and autism/enterocolitis are causally linked".[22]

Re:Measles: Four European nations lose eradication status by starvingbear on Friday August 30, 2019 @11:05AM (#20839305)
Fair enough. His conduct afterward could be looked at (though going beyond wikipedia may be necessary). But the original hysteria definitely painted a huge target on his back with a lot of misinformation. I don't think that's deniable
Re:Measles: Four European nations lose eradication status by hhas01 on Friday August 30, 2019 @02:50PM (#20841434)