News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: What type of restrictions does your employer have... by davismwfl on Thursday August 29, 2019 @01:25PM (#20831646)
Large employers attempt to do this quite often, even in states that specifically forbid it in state statue. Some states have laws that prevent this behavior but it doesn't stop employers from trying to bully those without knowledge.

I personally would be highly suspicious of any startup that was trying this while simultaneously offering or paying you a below market wage. If a company wants your attention they should pay to hold it, not threaten your job because you take a side job to make more money or have a hobby.

Another similar policy to this is the "assignment of all inventions", related and unrelated to the company, done on or off company time and even done using personal equipment. Again, some states prevent this, and even in states that don't have specific laws preventing it, generally I have seen the legal system is remiss to allow employers these wide unfettered control over peoples private lives.

Also, this is a reason you should write down every thought, idea or actual stuff you have worked on as excluded works before signing any document about inventions, non-compete etc. While I 100% disagree with the concept of these policies, there are ways around them almost all the time if you plan ahead.

This is also always something up for negotiation when you are being hired. The companies first response is almost always well this is the only way we hire anyone, and your response to that is what matters. It is also your first look at what the company really thinks of employees, if they care they'll figure a way to work with you, assuming you aren't being unreasonable yourself. If they are there to use you as a cog then they'll say no to all reasonable requests and that should be your warning sign to walk. I had people tell me you can't get more vacation back in the day when 2 weeks was the norm in the U.S. for all new employees. And here I'd be hired and have 4 weeks the first year and people were pissed cause they didn't negotiate it. Those are policies written by people, not laws of nature, it is all on the table you just have to work a little and be brave enough to push a little.

*edit -- fixed a spelling mistake and a repetitive word

Re:Ask HN: What type of restrictions does your employer have... by brlewis on Thursday August 29, 2019 @01:40PM (#20831821)
> "assignment of all inventions", related and unrelated to the company, done on or off company time and even done using personal equipment

This is such a big grab, I don't understand why they limit to inventions. Shouldn't they also demand assignment of all creative work so that if you write a novel on your own time and equipment they can collect all the royalties?

Re:Ask HN: What type of restrictions does your employer have... by StaticRedux on Thursday August 29, 2019 @02:07PM (#20832078)
"inventions" is not used in the same context as you would use it when talking about an inventor, like Tesla or Edison.

It's legalize. It depends on the language in the contract, but it usually includes everything under the sun, including creative works like books.

Sometimes there is a clarification for anything that can be related to your work, my current employer does that, but I've seen others without that. Which basically says they own you and everything you do or even think while employed by them.

Re:Ask HN: What type of restrictions does your employer have... by davismwfl on Thursday August 29, 2019 @05:41PM (#20833988)
This has been my experience too. When I had my consulting practice we were very careful on the contracts and always had an attorney review any proposed changes to the MSA or SOW that had any material feel to it. It was not uncommon for startups and enterprises alike to send us things to add to our MSA or ask us to use their contract "for simplicity and speed" but when we would review their suggestions around assignment of IP/inventions it was rare to find one that wasn't overreaching. Most were pretty cool about changing it and I think didn't realize how far reaching their attorneys had made it, and that wasn't their intent. Others I think were fully aware and felt that was their right if we did any work for their company, so we never worked with those teams.
Re:Ask HN: What type of restrictions does your employer have... by brlewis on Thursday August 29, 2019 @03:27PM (#20832757)
Sorry, I should have specified: This is in the United States. Here "inventions" is specifically patentable stuff. See https://www.uspto.gov/patents-getting-started/general-inform...
Re:Ask HN: What type of restrictions does your employer have... by StaticRedux on Thursday August 29, 2019 @03:42PM (#20832892)
I'm in the US too.

Inventions is usually defined in the contract itself and does not necessarily apply to patentable things.

This is just my personal experience, so take it for what it's worth, though I do have a fair amount of experience with contracts and non-competes.

Re:Ask HN: What type of restrictions does your employer have... by brlewis on Thursday August 29, 2019 @04:06PM (#20833087)
That seems weird to me, that a contract would redefine a term that already has a legal meaning, but there are weird things in law.
Re:Ask HN: What type of restrictions does your employer have... by Silhouette on Thursday August 29, 2019 @05:02PM (#20833636)
Shouldn't they also demand assignment of all creative work so that if you write a novel on your own time and equipment they can collect all the royalties?

Some places do. I once worked for a UK business that was taken over by a US one. The difference in mindset between the original management team and the new one was nowhere more evident than in the one-sided IP terms they tried to introduce into everyone's contract and the laughable defence of this made by the corporate VP who was effectively taking over the top job. IIRC it was something about how they nurture their staff and deliver pots of gold to the end of their personal rainbows by unicorn ferry and all they ask in return is everything you ever create and your mortal soul, though the memory is fuzzy and it's possible that I added a couple of those details later.

Re:Ask HN: What type of restrictions does your employer have... by buckminster on Thursday August 29, 2019 @03:04PM (#20832569)
Some employers do lay claim to all IP. I guess restricting it to inventions is an attempt to seem reasonable. Not successfully though.
Re:Ask HN: What type of restrictions does your employer have... by davismwfl on Thursday August 29, 2019 @05:34PM (#20833937)
This is what I think has happened, some employers do ask for all IP still. But others use the term inventions to make it seem like they aren't as over reaching. But generally I have seen that they do define "invention" in the document to basically include all IP still.

This is one that drives me insane, and I just won't touch a company that is doing this as it is unreasonable and so evil to me. But sadly a lot of startup legal firms put this in their standard IP documents for employees to sign and if you don't catch it you can be screwed.

Re:Ask HN: What type of restrictions does your employer have... by davidjnelson on Thursday August 29, 2019 @07:34PM (#20834719)
And get multiple offers for leverage ideally ;-)