In the end, it is about culture. You have to decide that these things matter. You can have productive 5 minute stand-ups or non-productive 60 minute stand-ups. You have to build the expectation that the point of all meetings is to get on the same page as a team or to make sure you stay there. Most meetings do fail at this.
The whole point of structure in these types of dialogues is to reveal the nuggets worth talking about, not cover them up in favor of following the rules.
We have someone who always brings up some story about some company he worked at 20 years ago and blah, blah, blah. But it isn't a "We solved this at company X by doing Y, should we try that here?", it is more like a 15 minute chest pounding of "Back when I ran the largest logistics company providing dental products to all the Fortune 500 and the government, I was in charge of 5K employees. When we faced challenge X,...... blah blah blah". This is where someone needs to step in. Again, most people don't want to be the jerk and so everyone sits there listening to this person talk about himself and wasting everyone's time.
That was why I liked the CNN debates in July. (Democratic presidential primary candidates in the US.) The moderators kept the debate on topic and politely (as best as they could) cut off the candidates when they went off topic.
The next day, a lot of the political coverage complained that the moderators got in the way too much! Sigh.
1. Agenda 2. Expected outcomes
Agenda forces the host/chair to consider how many items are going to be discussed, how long each might take and most importantly scopes the meeting allowing the host/chair to keep things on-topic. If you're organising an important meeting with lots of topics to discuss, but only have 30 mins scheduled due to "scheduling issues", you're doing it wrong.
The expected outcomes ensures that everyone knows up front what is expected to be the output of the meeting. Is a decision is to be made? Are we just looking to gather input?
This helps ensure that the right people are in the room. No-one should be able to say "I'd like to say yes, but Bob is out and I can't say yes without Bob's say-so." It also helps with a focus for the ending of the meeting.
Flippant answer: "I'd like to talk to you about [product / project / job title]"
I'd get a follow up email with something like "You have to come. It's your job."
How do people pull off stuff like this?
I make no warranty on this method however, just a thought.
It's a judgment, and if you can engage with the details of what went right and wrong with this week's meetings, then it's possible to tune next week's so the attendees judge them to be "useful" instead of something that "takes up people's time".
1. Purpose
2. Agenda
Purpose makes me think - is this meeting necessary? - and also answers why we are having this meeting.
Agenda gives others context on what to expect within the meeting as topics of discussion, as well as clarifies the format of engagement.